AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Reindeer Ex for Christmas

Page 9

by Noelle Drake

Jack stretched out his arms, offering Theo the pile in his hands. He held a folded pair of pajamas, underwear, and a brand new towel in a rich, cobalt blue. As Theo took them, their hands brushed and an electric spark jumped from his hand to his brain. He watched in silence as Jack rifled around the bathroom cabinets and drawers until he supplied a brand new toothbrush, loofah, and face cloth.

The man was as meticulous about cleanliness as he’d always been.

“I think that’s everything.” Jack said. “I’m sorry I don’t have underwear in another size, but at least it’s unused.”

Theo was disappointed about that last part, but he shook the thought out of his head. He couldn’t wait to shower—it would do him some good to wash his lust away.

Jack was saying something, but it took Theo too long to jump back into the conversation, so all he caught was “…in the shower. Feel free to use as much as you need.”

“Thank you.”

Jack stood there with his arms dangling at his sides. After a moment, he started towards the shower, opening the transparent glass door and twisting the shower knob. “This shower’s pretty tricky. Thought I’d lend a hand while I’m in here.” The water pressure was strong, like one of those spa showers that pelted your back like it was massaging it. As Jack twisted the knob the other way, he added, “this is how you turn it off.”

Theo chuckled. “I have showered before, you know.”

Jack ran a hand through his hair. “Yeah, but this one’s new.” His tone was light and Theo couldn’t help but smile as he watched Jack twist the knob on again until the shower was on. “I had to screw in a new head today. I think I did it correctly, but I’m not sure, so if the water pressure isn’t…”

Theo was barely listening.

With anyone but Jack, he’d have felt some level of shame. But when it came to him, the words screw and head in the same sentence made Theo’s brain forget every questionable part of his brain choosing the “get horny now” signals.

He shook his head. He had to snap out of it. He was just taking a shower at Jack’s house—nothing more. He wasn’t going to fill his head with delusions of any kind, especially not after the way things had been between them for their entire adult lives so far.

Things were supposed to be different now. He was no longer the guy who ran away during funerals or refused to answer letters with anything but silence. He was nearly forty and that meant he needed to admit how much of an asshole he was and how badly he’d hurt the only man he’d ever truly loved. He needed to stop hiding. Afterall, before they’d ever been lovers, they’d been friends.

Things needed to happen in steps…if they were going to happen at all.

What was he expecting to happen, anyway?

Nothing, he told himself. I expect nothing.

“Thank you.” He fought to keep the desire out of his voice.

Jack started walking out of the bathroom. On the other side of the threshold, he spun around, his hooves clopping loudly on the hardwood floor.

“If you need anything, scream for me.”

Then Jack rushed off.

Theo, on the other hand, was frozen in place. Had he heard that correctly? Had Jack Claus really said “scream for me” and then ran away like a middle schooler?

No, he certainly had not. Theo had clearly dove into a new layer of delusion.

Theo took his time undressing, his mind running through the events of the night so far. The free standing mirror across the shower was calling to him, so he walked over to take a look at himself.

At nearly six feet, Theo was taller than the average man. His shoulders were broader and stronger than they’d been in his twenties, thanks to the gym regime Will had forced him into over the last few years. His chestnut brown hair was wind-touseled from the storm and it curled at the nape of his neck. He’d needed a professional haircut for a few weeks now, but he was glad he hadn’t bothered. It’d been a long time since he’d worn his hair this long and he liked the boyish look it gave him. The one thing he’d miss about living in Los Angeles was the sunny days and the golden glow of his perpetual tan.

As he studied himself, Theo’s hand trailed down his muscled belly to the full bed of dark curls growing directly below his navel. His fingers curled around the hairs and he twisted, enjoying the sensation from the gentle tugging.

He stood like that for a few moments, holding his breath. Then, he remembered the laundry hamper in the bathroom and the curiosity was impossible to ignore. He dug through the hamper, anxiety and curiosity mixing inside him. Theo didn’t have any right to be so nosy about someone else’s space, especially when that person was his (potentially) married ex-boyfriend. If he was single, there’d be no pause. He tried to convince himself that there was no harm in getting answers to questions he didn’t want to voice, especially when the questions were about a relationship he had no business inquiring about.

He dug around for a few moments, realizing that there was not a single thing in the basket that didn’t belong to Jack. Which could mean nothing. As far as he knew, Jack could be there by himself temporarily

Theo touched a thick, familiar brand and his mouth instantly became dry as he pulled out a pair of briefs. It was a dark red cotton pair with a black band, and Theo knew instantly that he’d crossed the line, but he didn’t want to put it back in the hamper.

The steam from the shower had filled the room like a sauna, and instead of relaxing his muscles under the spray of heat, he was trying to separate his tongue from the dry roof of his mouth. His brain was on pause as he brought the underwear closer to his face and pressed it against his nose.

The first inhale was like getting struck by lightning. Instantly, he was insatiable, pressing the piece of discarded clothing hard against his nostrils. He was supposed to be using his time in the shower to think about how he was going to explain himself to Jack, but instead, he was fully naked, crouched in front of a dirty hamper sniffing his married ex’s dirty briefs.