AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Christmas at the Cabin

Page 12

by Katie Winters

December 2026

For Hazel, it was difficult to understand how her father had learned about her Grandma Clara’s disappearance. After all, Timothy and Grandma Clara hardly spoke, and Timothy lived thousands of miles away in New Mexico. He’d made it his business not to relate to family. He’d made it his business to step far away. But during the week after Thanksgiving, when it became increasingly clear that Clara wasn’t going to pop back up again with an easy explanation, Timothy called Hazel and told her he was going to Maine to look for her. “I can’t stay here a second longer,” he said. “I have to figure out what happened.”

Her father’s voice was stricken with panic. Hazel had never heard it quite like this before.

In the midst of her ongoing divorce, Hazel was in a fog of regret and fear. Still in her pajamas at two that afternoon, she still hadn’t figured out what to do with herself. She spent her days waiting for Annabelle and Josephine to come home from high school. Sometimes they called to tell Hazel they’d made plans with friends and would be home late, and it devastated her so much that she didn’t get dressed at all. These were pathetic days.

But now that it was the first week of December and the roads had been cleared after the recent blizzard, Hazel realized she had no real reason not to go to Maine with her father. The girls were seventeen and fifteen and could take care of themselves, especially when their father was around. She could be gone for a few days, help her father find her grandmother, and return with funny Maine souvenirs for the girls. Maybe she’d even get something for Marvin as a peace offering. Or not, she thought, laughing darkly at herself.

Although she knew that Marvin was in the midst of a dress rehearsal for The Night Shift, she called him to discuss her trip away and what they would do with the girls.

“You know I can’t talk now.” That was how he answered the phone, which gave Hazel a tiny bit of pleasure.

“I need to talk to you about something serious,” Hazel said. “Or is The Night Shift more important than your family?”

Marvin groaned. She heard his quick footsteps clicking through the studio. “I have three minutes,” he said. “But it’s a disastrous week. Our guest is that musician—what’s her name…”

“I don’t care about that,” Hazel said flatly.

Marvin was stunned into silence. Had he really forgotten that she no longer worked there? That she’d been kicked from the only job she’d ever cared about?

“My grandmother is missing,” Hazel said then.

Marvin’s voice was credulous. “Your grandmother? The one in Maine you never talk to?”

“We’ve been talking recently,” Hazel lied. “I don’t know if you remember, but my grandfather died twenty-six years ago. She’s been alone up there in those mountains. And now, nobody can find her.”

Marvin scrambled. “Hazel, that’s tough. I’m sorry.” And then he added, “I guess you’ll want to go up there and check on her.”

It was relatively simple to arrange what happened next. Without hesitation, Marvin agreed to take the girls for the next week or two and instructed Hazel to keep him in the loop. Hazel had no interest in keeping Marvin in the loop. He’d lost that privilege.

But she appreciated that he was open to co-parenting, she guessed. Men weren’t always so keen on that. That was something.

The drive from New York City to Whistler’s Hollow took approximately eight hours. According to her father’s flight plans, if she left tomorrow morning at dawn, she’d reach the airport half an hour before Timothy’s arrival. It was almost cozy: a father and daughter, reuniting in the father’s small town. If only there weren’t a sinister mystery involved.

Packing for Maine, Hazel threw six thick sweaters into a bag, plus jeans, leggings, socks, and boots. She guessed there would be nothing but snow, wind, and ice up there. She remembered what Grandma Clara had always said. “In Maine, there’s no bad weather, just bad clothing.” Since then, Hazel had heard many people from cold climates saying similar things, as though they’d been the ones to make it up. But that didn’t make it any less true.

The following morning, Hazel sped away from Manhattan and headed north toward Maine, her heart skittering and the radio tuned to a classic oldies station. The Eagles blared from the speakers, and tears raced from her eyes. It was cathartic to run from the city so soon after she’d lost nearly everything. Everything but the apartment and the girls, she reminded herself.

As she went north, the snow on either side of the highway grew higher, thicker, and brighter. Cabins dotted the trees, some decorated sensationally for Christmas. Hazel couldn’t remember the last time she’d gone north rather than south to somewhere warm, and it felt counterintuitive, as though she wanted the punishment of frozen toes and the threat of ice. Still, she couldn’t fight the feeling that she found it beautiful. Being from “up north” was in her blood.

In the hour before she reached the airport, Hazel tried to prepare herself to see Timothy Walton again. Over the years, her contact with him had been so minimal that most of the information she’d gleaned about his life had come from news shows and Wikipedia. The fact was, her father was something of a genius, but a tortured one. His award-winning and deeply philosophical novels spoke to humanity and to the distance between people in ways that often broke her heart. In fact, they were so sad that Hazel had decided to stop reading them altogether, as they reminded her too much of the distance between herself and her father. Often, Hazel saw New Yorkers reading her father’s books, and she wanted to rip the novels out of their hands and tell them to pick up a beach read instead. Save yourselves! she wanted to scream.

Hazel knew that her father had had a difficult childhood, although she’d never been clear on why. As far as she knew, Grandma Clara had always been very kind to him. She’d given him all the reading material he’d craved, plus all the time in the world to create. He’d been an only child, but Hazel knew that hadn’t been the plan. Grandma Clara’s pregnancy complications had demanded surgery. It was probably alienating to be her father, all alone with Clara and Felix in that cabin in Maine. But hadn’t Grandma Clara’s love been enough?

Hazel parked the car in the lot and went inside to wait for her father. She knew he would think that was impractical, that he’d say something like, “You shouldn’t pay for parking. There’s a pickup lane for a reason.” But Hazel had a little while to wait, and she didn’t want to do it in the car after spending the past eight hours in said car.

As she waited in the lobby, Hazel sipped a hot coffee and thought about her childhood. Before her mother had passed away, her father had put incredible pressure on Hazel, her brother Mark, and her sister Layla. To him, they were never as brilliant as they should have been. Their grades were subpar, and their creativity, according to him, was next to zilch. Their mother had tried to get him to lighten up, to see Hazel, Mark, and Layla for the humans they were. But Timothy hadn’t wanted that.

When their mother died in 1998, Timothy had more or less boarded up the walls of his heart. He’d adored their mother, so much so that Layla had suggested their mother was the first and only person in the world to understand him. Whether that was true could never be proven. By the time their mother passed, Hazel was as old as Annabelle and eager to step out on her own. But her younger siblings had needed her. As she’d attempted to mother her grieving brother and sister, Hazel’s teenage years had been stunted. Their father, seemingly, hadn’t noticed or cared. The following year, when Grandpa Felix had passed, Timothy hadn’t known how to grieve his father. He’d taken Hazel and her siblings to Maine, sat with them at the funeral, then driven them back again. There had been no conversation between them about what had happened. Throughout, Grandma Clara had been pale with shock.

Twenty minutes after Timothy’s plane landed, he appeared, wheeling a suitcase behind him. He wore all beige-colored linen, from linen slacks to a linen button-down, and he scowled as he searched for her. He looked much older than he had the last time Hazel had seen him, and the thought made her feel claustrophobic and morose.

Hazel walked over to meet him. Because he didn’t see her at first, he nearly walked right by.

“Dad?”

Timothy yanked around and looked at her. He blinked, then said, “I figured you’d be outside.”