Page 7
Hazel hated to admit how pleased she was. She’d been dreading the “divorce” conversation all day. Despite his mistake, she did not want to break up their perfect family. She did not want to destroy the girls’ sense of the world. More than that, she didn’t want to jeopardize her perfect job at The Night Shift. If she and Marvin had broken up, she wasn’t sure how people at the show would treat her. Of the two, Marvin was the much more important member of the crew.
There was one more week at The Night Show before they took a break for Christmas and New Year’s. Throughout their writing meetings and dress rehearsals, Hazel kept tabs on both Marvin and Polly. She never saw them interact, not once. When Hazel and Polly had to work together, Hazel kept everything professional. Otherwise, the women didn’t go out of their way to speak to or look at one another. When Hazel asked herself how long she could keep this going, her mental answer was, I can do this forever, as long as Polly doesn’t try to talk to me.
On Christmas Day that year, Hazel woke up in their Manhattan apartment and drank coffee with her husband. Last night, even though the girls were too old to believe in Santa, they’d filled the space beneath the tree with presents, and now they exchanged stories about past Christmases, both of them heavy with nostalgia about the girls and how old they were getting. When Annabelle and Josephine woke up, they sat on the floor, exchanged presents, and listened to Christmas music. When it was Hazel’s turn to unwrap her gift from Marvin, she shrieked with pleasure at the diamond earrings she’d been given. He’d never been good at gift-giving before, and it felt like proof of something, as though he really wanted to make a go at fixing their marriage.
She put the earrings in right away and kissed Marvin on the lips, right there beside the sparkling Christmas tree.
Later that afternoon, Hazel called her siblings Mark and Layla to wish them well.
“Thanks,” Layla said, laughing nervously on video chat, one eye on her sons in the background as they wrestled on the living room rug. “Have you called Dad yet?”
“Have you?” Hazel asked.
“No,” Layla said, groaning. “I was hoping you’d do it for all of us. You’re the oldest.”
“You’re the youngest. Doesn’t that mean he likes you the most?” Hazel asked.
“I don’t think he likes anyone but himself,” Layla said. “How are you, anyway? I haven’t heard from you in weeks.”
Hazel was cozy on the sofa, listening as Annabelle and Josephine played a game on the television. Marvin was beside her, reading a novel she’d bought for him about the Civil War.
“I’m good,” Hazel said. “Busy.”
A little while later, when Hazel tried to call her father out in New Mexico, he didn’t answer. When she retried after the girls went to bed, he texted: No service. Hazel knew it was a lie to avoid communicating with his family on such an important day. Still, it stung.
Before Hazel and Marvin went to sleep, Hazel wiggled across the mattress to hug her husband good night. Since she’d discovered him in his office (with Polly!), they’d hardly touched when she reached out for him. He flinched, as though her touch was unwanted. Hazel returned to her side of the bed, her pulse quick in her neck.
“I’m sorry,” she whispered into the dark.
“I’m just tired,” Marvin said. “I love you.”
“I love you, too.”
During the second week of 2026, Hazel and Marvin started couples therapy. It was difficult to squeeze in their sessions between writing meetings, dress rehearsals, and all the obligations Marvin had at the show. But they were committed and wanted to make the marriage work.
Their therapist was Regina, a kind-looking woman of about forty-eight with red-and-gray hair and green eyes. To begin the session, she asked them to introduce themselves and talk about what they thought was good about their marriage. Hazel appreciated that she wanted to begin with the positives. Hazel went first, saying, “We’re both comedians, so we make each other laugh all the time. I mean, we used to, and I’d really like to get back to that.” She went on to talk about their professional relationship, how marvelous they were at making The Night Shift work, and how they’d somehow managed to balance parenting with such a difficult schedule. She talked about how attracted she was to Marvin, how kind he was to his friends, and how good he was at cooking.
But when it was Marvin’s turn, he seemed stumped, his head tilted. Hazel’s heart dropped into her stomach.
“She’s very funny,” Marvin said, echoing what she’d already said. “And she’s a good mother.”
He said a few more things, to be fair. But Hazel couldn’t help but feel that he was only half awake during their first therapy session in a ten-session round meant to reunite them as a team. If she didn’t know any better, she’d say they were doomed.
And by the end of September, nine months after their first couple’s therapy session and ten months after Hazel had first discovered Marvin’s affair, Hazel and Marvin decided to call it. Their marriage was over. Tear-streaked, Hazel waddled into the living room and collapsed on the couch. Outside, an alarm sounded, bringing an ambulance to someone who needed it. By comparison, her problems were so small.
“I don’t understand,” Hazel breathed into the darkness. “Why couldn’t you just stop?”
Marvin stood behind her, shifting his weight. She could see him in the reflection of the television. “I think, um. I think we’re just really in love,” Marvin said. “I tried not seeing her for a while. I really did. I told her that we wanted to make things work for the girls. But we work together. I see her all the time.”
“You see me all the time, too,” Hazel said.
Marvin kept quiet.
Hazel closed her eyes tightly. She’d first learned that Marvin was seeing Polly again at the end of August, when Marvin had accidentally texted Hazel a message meant for Polly. It had said: yeah room 72. Hazel had called him right away and asked him point-blank, “Who was that for?” He’d been so stricken that he’d answered right away.
That night, Marvin packed a bag and went to a hotel down the road. To keep things normal for the girls, he returned in the morning before they went to school. Annabelle and Josephine were both groggy and out of it, so they didn’t catch on till later in the week, when Annabelle asked their father why he’d started wearing jeans and tennis shoes to breakfast every morning. Marvin and Hazel came clean after that, explaining to Josephine and Annabelle that they were taking some time off the marriage for a while. As expected, Annabelle and Josephine had burst into tears.
But Hazel was relieved the girls knew. It meant that she didn’t have to see Marvin every morning at the apartment. It meant she could avoid him at work as best she could.