Page 75
There is no word for what I am.
There are words adjacent to it. Estrangement, which is clinical and implies mutuality, as though I chose this too. Ambiguous loss, which a therapist once used and which is technically correct and completely insufficient. There is no word for the specific grief of losing a child who is still alive.
When someone dies, people bring food. I knew this abstractly before I needed it to be true, and now I know it the way you know things that live in the body: completely, from the inside. People bring food, sit with you, and say I’m so sorry. And the I’m so sorry holds you up for a while, not because it changes anything, but because it acknowledges that the thing is real. That the loss is real. That you are not imagining it, causing it, or failing to put it in proper perspective.
No one brings food for this.
What they bring instead, when they bring anything, is a question wearing the costume of concern.
Have you tried reaching out?
Have you considered that there might be another side to the story?
I’m sure he’ll come around.
These things have a way of working themselves out.
Each sentence subtly implies the same assumption: if parents act correctly, the child will come back. It suggests that the child’s decision is always a logical reaction to parental shortcomings. Additionally, it hints at the possibility that there's an untried approach—perhaps a specific combination of words, gestures, or respectful silences—that might reach my son.
I taught English for twenty-six years. I know what subtext is.
Connor is not dead. I remind myself of this sometimes, whether on the dock, on the path, or in the car, because a part of grief can forget it, and that forgetting is a cruel form of inhumanity. He is alive, healthy as far as I know, and working at the state's top research institution. His son—my grandson, whom I learned about from a neighbor’s phone screen—is growing up in a Knoxville home with two parents who choose to remain silent every day.
That’s what I can’t explain to people who haven’t lived it. The active quality of it. A death is a past-tense event. It happened. It is over. You carry it forward, but it doesn’t keep happening.
This keeps happening.
Every day. Every hour. Every minute. Every moment.
Every morning that goes by without Connor calling is because he chooses not to. Every birthday that passes without a text, every Christmas, every Father’s Day, every Mother’s Day, every random Tuesday when I see something funny and reach for my phone and remember—there is no sending it. The number is there. The impulse is there. I have to stop myself every time. And Connor, one hundred miles away, isn’t stopping himself because he isn’t thinking about it at all, or he is thinking about it and has decided this is still what he’s choosing.
There is no funeral for this. There is no date I can point to and say, “This is when I lost him.” I know when the text arrived, but that isn’t when I lost him. I’ve been losing him in stages for nearly three years, maybe longer, maybe since the morning after his wedding, when he called to say they’d arrived safely at the hotel. I heard something in his voice that I told myself was newlywed happiness, and I’ve wondered about it ever since.
They are not wrong that it’s a problem. They are not right that it has a solution.
I've been sitting on the bed for a long time when I hear Walt come in.
He didn't arrive from the dock; he came in earlier. I heard the back door open. He's been in the garage, which is typical for Walt when he's working through something he hasn't confided in me. The familiar sounds—drawer opening and closing, the whir of an electric device, and moments of silence—suggest he's carefully measuring or contemplating.
He stands in the doorway of the bedroom with sawdust on his shirt and a small wooden frame in his hand.
I look at it.
“For the photograph,” he says. 'The one of Connor at seventeen. I thought—you've been moving it around. I thought maybe if it had somewhere to go, it could stay there.'
I take it from him. It's a simple frame, unfinished wood, with the corners joined carefully and sanded smooth. He made it this afternoon while I sat on the edge of the bed, holding our son's photograph.
He watched me move that photograph from drawer to drawer for months without saying anything. He built it a place to land.
“Walt,” I say. That is all I say, because there are approximately forty sentences that I could finish with, and none of them are adequate.
“You don't have to put it anywhere specific,” he says. “Nightstand, desk, wherever. I just thought it should have a frame.”
I put the photograph in the frame. I set it on the nightstand, where it had been when I found it this afternoon, where it was when I didn't have a frame for it, and where it will stay now that I do. Connor at seventeen, with the trophy and the failing grin, framed in a piece of wood his father cut and sanded on a Thursday afternoon while I sat with the grief of him.
Walt sits beside me on the edge of the bed. We look at the photograph together.
“He looks like you,” Walt says.