Page 197
‘That’s the thing.’ Whitehead glanced from one of us to the next. ‘As far as I’m aware no one else knew about the secret at the back of A Christmas Carol. Only those at the Dickens Fellowship whom I engaged after drinking too much wine.’
‘And what about these encouraging letters from a separate individual?’ Tobias interjected, his gaze settling on the remaining pile.
‘Yes. Here.’ Whitehead bent over the desk and shuffled through the letters for a moment before handing one to me. The handwriting was far neater.
Mr Whitehead,
Persist in uncovering what is lost! I know that your family story is true.
Bring Merriweather back.
Neither letter was signed.
‘May I see that?’ asked Tobias.
He took the letter, then picked up the one I had been examining previously. He laid them side by side beneath the lamp, carefully aligning their edges. The rest of us watched him in silence. I had seen Tobias read handwriting before, but never with such speed and such stillness. At last, after studying the final lines once more, a wry smile crossed his face.
‘These are not two separate individuals, Mr Whitehead.’
Philip frowned, as though he had misheard him.
‘What?’
‘These letters are from the same individual.’
‘That cannot be right.’
‘I assure you, it is.’
‘How?’
Tobias touched the first letter with one finger, tracing the air just above the ink.
‘The threatening letter has been written in a deliberately distorted hand. Possibly with the non-dominant hand. But there are undeniable shared habits with the encouraging letter. Look here. The formation of the capital M. The spacing after a full stop. The pressure at the end of a downward stroke.’ He moved his finger from one page to the other. ‘The writer wanted you to think you were being pulled by one person and frightened by another.’
‘Why?’ Philip asked, confused.
Tobias shrugged. ‘Not a clue.’ He looked across at me. ‘Detective Forbes?’
My mind was still in The Scholar’s Rest cafe in Harrow, the remains of my tea cooling before me. I replayed the end of our meeting with the boy who it seemed more and more likely was the mysterious Alex Morcant. And … wait. Didn’t he …
‘Hang on!’ I cried, the thought arriving complete. I rushed up the spiral staircase to my filing cabinets. I rifled through my author drawer, until I reached ‘M’ for Merriweather. Searching through the file I had assembled, I soon found what I was looking for. ‘Huzzah!’
Tobias turned to Star. ‘Did he really just say huzzah?’
‘I’m afraid he did, yes,’ she replied.
I rushed back downstairs.
‘His essay! The page he dropped in the cafe! The boy, Alex Morcant! I have it here.’
Star’s jaw dropped almost to the floor. ‘Your ability to file things is beyond impressive.’
I bowed my head.
‘I thank you. I put it away after I found it in my coat pocket a couple of weeks later. We forgot to hand it back to Reginald Heaney. The stars have aligned.’ I crossed back to Tobias. ‘Here.’ I handed it to him. ‘Is this essay written by the same hand that produced the letters?’
It took Tobias a mere few seconds to confirm it. He glanced between the three pages and gave a single decisive nod. Philip Whitehead gripped the edge of the counter. Star went very still. I felt something cold pass through me.