AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Caught in Your Spell

Page 11

by Loni Ree

“No,” she says, and something in her voice shifts, something that makes my pulse kick once and then steady. “You’re really not.”

She stands up and I stand up because I was raised to stand when a woman stands, and then we’re facing each other in the narrow space between the table and the counter, and neither of us is pretending. She’s close enough that I can smell her shampoo, something floral and clean, and close enough that I can see the tiny freckle at the corner of her mouth, and close enough that when she reaches up and touches my jaw I stop breathing.

“I’ve been thinking about you, too,” she says. “In case that wasn’t obvious.”

“It wasn’t.”

“Good. I’d hate to be predictable.”

She’s the first to kiss me. I let it happen. Her mouth is soft, faint wine lacing her breath, and when my hand finds her waist, she makes the smallest sound, like something soft and secret breaking loose. I keep my hand there, just resting there, letting her decide how far this goes. I’m not going to push ahead. But then her fingers wind into the front of my shirt, and she tugs me in. The calm, careful beginning drops away, and suddenly it’s hungry, the two of us leaning in and catching fire. Her mouth opens beneath mine. My hand slips to the small of her back. She arches into me like she’s been waiting for this, like she was only ever waiting for the go-ahead, and I realize she never even needed it.

She’s warm and solid and real, and I want to lift her onto the kitchen table and keep kissing her until neither of us remembers what we were worried about. But I don’t do either of those things because she asked me to let her choose and I meant it.

She pulls back first, breathing hard, her cheeks flushed and her lips parted and her hand still fisted in my shirt. “Okay,” she says, and her voice is a little ragged. “Okay. That was.” She stops. Swallows. “That was a lot.”

“Was it too much?”

“No.” She shakes her head, and a curl falls across her forehead, and I want to tuck it behind her ear but make myself wait. “It wasn’t too much. It was exactly the right amount. That’s the problem.”

I almost smile. “Is it a problem?”

“It’s a complication.” She lets go of my shirt and smooths the fabric with her palm, and the gesture is so unexpectedly tender that it lands somewhere behind my sternum. “I came here for a fresh start, not a relationship. I had a whole plan.”

“Plans change. I’ve never dated a woman in Smitten Harbor because I didn’t want the town gossips in my business.” He stares into my eyes, and I can see the truth in his words. “But now I couldn't care less if they know how much I want you.”

“Oh.” She steps back, and I let her go. The space between us is both six inches and a thousand miles. “I should go home. It’s late, and I have story-time in the morning… and I need to think.”

“I understand.” I don’t want her to go. Every instinct I have is telling me to ask her to stay, to tell her she doesn’t have to think, that I’ll make this easy for her, that I’ll be whatever she needs me to be. But that’s not what she asked for. What she asked for was room to decide. “Will you come back tomorrow? Dinner again. Same time.”

She picks up her bag from the counter and looks at me for a long moment, and I can see her weighing the question. Then she nods. “Yes. I’ll come back.”

I walk her to the door and out onto the porch, and the night air is cold and clean and the stars are out, the kind of October sky that makes you understand why people live in Maine. She stops at her car and turns around, and I kiss her again because I can’t not. I kiss her until we’re both breathless. Her hands are on my shoulders and my back is against her car door, and when we finally break apart, she’s laughing, a low surprised sound that I want to hear every day for the rest of my life.

“Goodnight, Sheriff.”

“Goodnight, Charlotte.”

She gets in her car and drives away, and I stand on the porch and watch her taillights until they disappear. Then I get in my truck. I don’t think about it. I just turn the key and pull out onto the road and follow her, staying far enough back that she won’t see me, close enough that I can keep her in sight. She takes the route to her little house on the east side of town, and I wait at the corner until I see her headlights turn into her driveway and her porch light come on and her front door open and close. The lights go on inside, warm and steady, and I sit there for another minute, two minutes, making sure nothing moves in the dark around her house.

Then I drive home. It’s a five-minute drive, and I spend it thinking about the way she said my name and the note in the evidence locker and the fact that someone in my town thinks they can threaten her. They’re wrong. I’ll find them. And tomorrow night, she’s coming back to my house, and I’ll make her dinner, and I’ll wait for her to decide what she wants. Whatever it is, I’ll give it to her.

But I’m not letting anyone take her away from me. Not now. Not ever.

CHAPTER FIVE

CHARLOTTE

The six-thirty light through my kitchen window has gone thin and gray by the time I grab my purse and keys. I’ve changed twice. First into jeans and a sweater, then out of the jeans and into a dress, then out of the dress and back into the jeans because I refuse to act like this is something it hasn’t become yet. The sweater is deep green, soft at the cuffs, and I bought it three years ago at a shop in Portland that smelled like patchouli and old paper. It’s my favorite. Noah gets the favorite sweater.

I drive the five minutes to his house with the radio off. My hands are steady on the wheel. That surprises me. I expected nerves, the kind that make your palms slip and your breath go shallow, but what I feel is something quieter. Anticipation with teeth. The road unwinds past dark houses and porch lights just coming on, and I think about the way he kissed me last night at my car, the way he waited for me to decide. I’ve dated men who talked a good game about respecting my choices and then spent the whole evening nudging me toward theirs. Noah isn’t that. He’s something I don’t have a name for yet.

His house glows warm against the October dark when I pull up. The porch light is on. I park behind his truck and sit for a moment with my hands on the wheel, looking at the square yellow window, the shadow that moves behind it. He’s in the kitchen. I can see his shape through the glass, broad and unhurried. He’s not watching for me. He’s doing something ordinary, filling a glass or wiping down the counter, and that ordinariness settles something in my chest. This is just dinner. Pizza and a movie. Two people who want to see each other again.

I get out of the car and walk to the door. Before I can knock, it opens.

“Hey.” He steps back to let me in, and the smell of warm dough and garlic rolls out rushes out with him. “Right on time.”

“I’m a librarian. Clocks are kind of my thing.” I step past him into the living room, and he takes my jacket before I can shrug it off myself. His fingers brush the back of my neck, and I stop breathing for half a second. Just half. Then I’m fine.