Page 5
“Noah,” I manage to mutter.
She pauses with the coffee halfway to her lips. “What?”
“You called me Sheriff. My name’s Noah.”
Something shifts in her expression, a small softening around the edges. “Noah,” she repeats, and the sound of it leaving her mouth does things to my chest I’m not ready to name. “All right. Noah. What do you do to relax?”
I think about it, knowing I need to get my head out of my ass if I have any hope of winning over Charlotte. “I read,” I say finally. “Mostly history. Civil War stuff, some biographies. I’ve got a stack of books on my nightstand that’s about to become a structural hazard.”
“You read.” Charlotte’s whole face lights up. “Well, that’s definitely something we have in common.”
She leans back against the booth, cradling her mug, and the smile she gives me is different from the ones before, slower, less guarded. “Although, I usually read cozy mysteries or the latest fantasy romance.”
I file all this information about her away.
“So, tell me about your family.” I want to know all there is to know about her.
“There isn’t much to tell.” She sits back in the booth and stares at me. “I’m not too close to my parents. They divorced when I was seventeen, and I always felt like a piece of baggage passed back and forth between them. As soon as I graduated from high school, I moved to New York City for college and never looked back.”
My heart squeezes in my chest, thinking about her unhappy childhood. “Do you have any contact with them?”
“Not much. I mostly just get texts on my birthday or holidays. What about you, Noah? Tell me about your family?”
“I’ve lived in Smitten Harbor my entire life. My parents were both high school teachers at the high school, and my younger brother plays hockey in the NHL.”
“Really?” Her eyes spark. “What team does he play for?”
“The Houston Lonestars.” I let it drop, just a little. There’s pride in it, sure.
Her lips part, impressed. “Wow.” She lets the word linger, the air between us taking on a new current. “I’ve never met anyone with a professional athlete in their family. What about your parents? Are they still around?”
“They’re on the road. Well, on the sea, technically,” I say, grinning at the image. “When they retired, they hit the bucket list hard. Right now, they’re on a cruise bound for Australia.”
“Nice,” she breathes.
I glance around, noticing that the retirees have moved on to arguing about the town council’s new parking ordinance, and Millie is refilling coffee at the counter with one eye on our booth. The whole diner feels like it’s holding its breath, waiting to see what happens next. I don’t give a damn about the audience, but I can see Charlotte noticing them, the way her gaze flicks toward the window seats when someone laughs too loud, the slight tension in her shoulders when the doorbell chimes again.
“You okay?” I ask.
“Fine.” She sets her mug down. “It’s just, I’m still getting used to the small-town thing. Where everybody knows everybody and your breakfast is a spectator sport.”
“You want to leave?”
“No.” She says it fast, then seems surprised at herself. “No, I don’t want to leave. I just need a minute to adjust.” She takes a breath, and I watch her shoulders drop half an inch. “Yesterday, Millie told me that it’s impossible to keep anything a secret in this town.”
“She’s not wrong.” I push my empty plate aside. “Smitten Harbor’s been the same two thousand people for most of my life. Everybody knows everybody else’s business. Plus, they’re all curious about you.”
“Because I’m new to town?”
“Yes, and you’re…” I stop myself before beautiful lands on the table between us. “You’re interesting. People are curious.”
She gives me a look that says she heard what I didn’t say. “Interesting,” she echoes. “That’s a very diplomatic word.”
“I’m a diplomatic guy.”
“You’re a terrible liar, is what you are.”
I grin, and it feels strange on my face, wider than I’m used to. “Fair enough.”