AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Caught in Your Spell

Page 9

by Loni Ree

NOAH

Two days pass and I don’t stop thinking about her. Not once. She occupies my mind pretty much twenty-four fucking hours of the day. My lips are still tingling from the kiss I left on her cheek, and my heart tripped in my chest when I found a new Civil War biography waiting on my desk in the station. Inside the book, I found a note from my girl.

Noah,

I hear this is a must-read for all Civil War fans.

C.

I’ve been reading it in the evenings after my shift, and I have to agree that Charlotte hit the nail right on the head with this one.

On the third evening, I’m at my desk finishing a report when my cell rings. The screen says SMITTEN HARBOR PUBLIC LIBRARY, and my thumb hits accept before the second ring finishes.

“Stafford.”

“It’s Charlotte.” Her voice is tight in a way I haven’t heard before, the briskness flattened into something thinner. “Can you come to the library? There’s something I need to show you.”

I’m already standing, reaching for my hat. “I’m on my way.” My usual calmness is nowhere to be found. Fuck.

The drive takes four minutes, and I spend every one of them running through possibilities I don’t like. The library’s windows are lit when I pull up, the October darkness settling early now, and I can see her through the glass before I reach the door. She’s standing behind the circulation desk with her arms crossed, and she doesn’t look up when I push through. The reading room is empty, and the lights are on fully. The quiet has a different quality than it did on Monday afternoon. It’s the quiet of a place that’s been holding its breath.

“Back here,” she says, and leads me into the staff office without preamble. It’s a small room with a desk, a filing cabinet, a coat rack, and a window that looks out onto the side yard. She’s got a piece of paper laid out in the center of the desk like evidence, which is exactly what it is.

I pick it up. The paper is cheap, the kind you’d tear out of a spiral notebook, and the handwriting is blocky letters in black ballpoint.

WATCH YOUR BACK, LIBRARIAN. YOU DON’T BELONG HERE.

I read it twice. The third time, I’m not reading; I’m controlling the thing that wants to unspool in my chest, the thing that is not professional and not useful and entirely about the fact that someone put these words on paper and left them for her to find.

“Where was it?”

“Tucked into the book drop.” She’s standing with her back against the filing cabinet, her arms still crossed, and I notice she’s wearing a sweater the color of cranberries with the sleeves pushed up past her elbows. “I found it when I was closing up. The bin was overflowing, and I was sorting returns, and there it was. No envelope. Just folded in half and shoved between two picture books.”

“When did you last check the drop?”

“Around two. So, sometime between two and four.” She uncrosses her arms and tucks her hands into her back pockets, and the gesture is so carefully casual that I know she’s working to keep it together. “That’s not all. The last few days, I’ve felt like someone’s been watching me. Not all the time. Just when I’m walking to my car, or when I’m alone in the reading room after hours. I told myself I was being paranoid, the new person in a small town, everyone’s curious, but then I found this.”

I set the note back down on the desk, careful not to smudge anything even though the thing’s probably got a dozen prints on it already. “You should’ve called me before now.” Fuck. The thought of her being in danger sends rage flowing through me.

She lets out a breath that’s almost a laugh and not at all amused. “I was sure you’d think I’m crazy.”

“I know you’re not crazy. I’m going to take this to the station and have it tested.” I pull my phone out and take a photo of the note, then another of the book return bin where she found it.

“Stay in here while I take a look around outside,” I tell her. The drop is a metal slot built into the wall beside the front door, and anyone can reach it from the sidewalk whether the library is open or not. There’s no camera. There’s never been a camera because this is Smitten Harbor, and the worst thing that’s ever happened to the library is a teenager drawing mustaches on the historical society portraits with a Sharpie. I take notes while she talks, and I don’t tell her that the lack of a camera is a problem I’m going to fix, or that I’m already making a list of everyone in town who might have a grudge against a woman who’s been here less than two weeks. I don’t tell her any of that because, right now, what she needs is a sheriff who is calm and methodical and not the man who wants to put his fist through the fucking wall.

“I’ll have the note tested at the station,” I say when she’s finished. “We’ll run it for prints, but it might take a few days.”

“Okay.” She’s still got her hands in her pockets, but her shoulders have dropped half an inch, and I’ll take it.

I look at her standing there in the cramped little office with the cranberry sweater and the copper curls that are starting to escape whatever she used to pin them back, and I want to do about six things at once, most of them inadvisable. What I do instead is shift the ground. I need to know she’s okay, and the one way to do that is to have her in my home.

“Come to dinner at my house.”

She blinks. “What?”

“You said you’d think about it. You’ve had two days.” I keep my voice level, but I let her see that I mean it. “Gull’s Nest is fine, but Millie will have half the town knowing our business before the check arrives. My place is private. You drive yourself over; you leave whenever you want. No police work. We don’t talk about the note; we don’t talk about the investigation. We talk about anything else.”

She studies me for a long moment, and I can see her running the variables. The note is still on the desk between us, ugly and unresolved, but I’m not asking her to pretend it doesn’t exist. I’m asking her to let me feed her dinner in a room where no one is watching.