Page 58
"You recognized the car?"
"I'd made half the payments on that car." She laughs, but she isn't amused. "He got out and left the headlights on, so I could see him. He was drunk. He had a gun in his right hand."
"What kind of gun?"
"A handgun. It was black. I don't know guns." She takes a breath. "He stood in the yard and yelled my name. Then he yelled that Reid had found me, and I was stupid to think Reid wouldn't find me again."
My pen stops before it keeps going. "Those were his exact words?"
"They're close enough that I'd swear to them. He held the gun up toward the window so I'd see it, and he said it was Reid's. He said Reid told him he'd need it."
I underline that line twice. Reid's complaint never had a gun in it at all. Now I have a witness who heard Nolan say the gun was Reid's. It's a drunk man's word, shouted across a yard. She heard it, and she'll swear to it.
"What happened next?"
"Bryan came out of the trees across the road." She says it calmly, as if it's an ordinary fact. "He'd been out there every night since I came. I never asked him to. Some nights I'd look out after midnight, and I couldn't see him. He'd told me he'd be there, and I believed him."
I keep my eyes on my notebook. The afternoon I moved into his room, Bryan told me he'd parked where he could watch my cabin every night I slept there. If I look at him now, I won't get through the next question.
"Could you hear what Bryan said to him?"
"Never. Bryan's voice doesn't carry. I could hear Nolan, though. He yelled for a long time. Then he went quiet, and then he yelled again. I got down on the floor under the window. Something hit the side of the car hard, and when I looked again, Nolan didn't have the gun anymore. Bryan had it."
"How long was Nolan there?"
"It felt like all night. It was probably an hour. The car went back down the road fast after that, and Bryan knocked on my door. He told me somebody would come for me in the morning and I should pack. He sat on my porch steps until it got light with a rifle across his knees."
The fire pops. I write RIFLE ON STEPS. ALL NIGHT. and then I ask the question I've been waiting to ask.
"Tell me about the second morning."
"I was in the back bedroom, packing. Bryan told me to stay back there, down and away from the windows. Then I heard Nolan's voice out front. I never heard a car. He walked up the road."
"Was he drunk again?"
"No. He sounded sober, and that scared me worse. He was calm. He told Bryan he wasn't leaving without me. He said he'd come back for what was his."
That answers half of the question I wrote in my margin the afternoon I moved into Bryan's room. He wouldn't tell me why Nolan came back, because it belonged to her.
She takes longer to start again. "Bryan told him to go. Nolan told him to get out of his way. I went into the bathroom, because I couldn't stand not knowing, and I could see part of the yard from that window. Nolan swung first. He hit Bryan in the side of the head. I watched him do it, and then I got back down on the floor and stayed there."
"Did you see anything after that?"
"No. I heard it."
I wait. Elise breathes on the other end of the line.
"At first I could hear Nolan," she says. "He was swearing and shouting. Then he was making sounds that weren't words, and after a while he quit making any sound at all." Her next words come slowly. "It kept going after that. I put my hands over my ears, and I could still hear it through the wall."
I'm pressing so hard that the pen digs into the paper.
"How long did it go on after he went quiet?"
"I don't know. It went on long enough that I wondered whether Nolan was dead. Then it stopped.
"The door opened, and Bryan came into the kitchen. He didn't look at me. He went to my sink and washed his hands. He kept washing them long after they were clean."
At the window, Bryan hasn't shifted his weight once.