Page 22
She realized she was listening so closely that she’d leaned all the way into his personal space. He smelled really good, like hay and whiskey. She could picture him with a set of bagpipes, wearing a kilt that showed off his hairy legs. The image made her smile.
“What’d I miss?” he asked. “Something funny about those arson stats?”
“No. Nothing. Go on. It’s fascinating. If we could actually narrow down the suspects to young white men below thirty, you’d be done with this job in a day. A lot of guys that age leave the island. Like my brother. He left at the age of seventeen and only came back this year.”
The effects of that second kir royale were kicking in. One drink relaxed her; two made her chatty. Three…well, she wasn’t going to let that happen.
“Noah, you mean?”
“Yes. He traveled, fished in Alaska, had some adventures. Got his heart broken in Thailand. Italy, too. And London, come to think of it. Anyway, he finally came back this winter because the old guy he used to deckhand for left him his farmhouse.”
“Sweet deal.” As Fergus listened, his gaze seemed sharper than she would have expected. None of this had anything to do with the fires, but he was still clearly interested.
“You’d think, but the place was a wreck. Rotted flooring, messed-up foundation, single-pane windows. Noah decided to fix it up and sell it. He invited me to live there with him and pitch in with the reno. I’m better at that stuff than he is. So that’s what we’re doing, but I’m starting to think he might stay. Dolores keeps sniffing around. She’s a realtor and she really wants that listing. But Noah keeps putting her off.”
Man, these kir royales must have an extra kick to them. She wasn’t usually this chatty, especially with a virtual stranger. There was something about the attentive way Fergus listened that made her keep going. She reminded herself that interview skills were part of his job.
“Dolores? What’s her last name?” He took out his phone to make a note.
“Ryan. Why, do you think she might know something?”
“She might have some insight into what connects the houses that were targeted. Did Dolores say Noah could make a good profit by flipping it?”
“Oh yeah. She said houses like that are going for half a million dollars. Can you imagine? On Sea Smoke Island?” She shook her head. “It’s terrible, actually, because no fisherman around here can afford that kind of price. Poor Noah, he doesn’t want to sell to an off-islander, or some corporate property firm, but no one local can swing it. It’s a real dilemma, so I guess he’s stuck here for now. I taunt him about it whenever I can,” she finished cheerfully.
“As sisters do.”
“Yup, it’s in the job description. ‘Must be able to tease and torment without mercy.’ Checkmark. Nailed it.” As she gestured with her drink, a few droplets rained on the bar. She wiped them up with her cocktail napkin and told herself to mellow out. Fergus was far too easy to talk to.
“You didn’t want to go travel with your brother?” Fergus asked.
“No, I did. But that didn’t happen. I had to hold things down here.” She pressed her lips together; she didn’t want to say anything more about that.
He waited a beat. A flicker in his eyes told her that he noticed her reticence, but decided not to push it. Good observation skills—another part of being a trained investigator.
She looked away from him, hoping to break the spell of his attention, and scanned the rest of the bar. Only a few other customers were drinking at this early hour, and she didn’t recognize any of them. They must be guests here. A couple sat cuddled together near the fireplace, and at the other end of the bar, a silver-haired man in a dark wool coat tapped away at his phone. Why bother to travel all the way out to Sea Smoke Island just to doomscroll?
Fergus’ voice brought her attention back his way.
“Can I show you something?” he asked. “It’s related to the case.”
“Sure. I’m not the actual constable, you know—”
He waved that away. “You know this island, that’s the important part.” He slid off the bar stool. He was so tall that he barely had to shift his legs at all to go from sitting to standing.
“Where are you going?” The kir royale buzz was making her brain move more slowly. She was getting caught up in little details like how freaking broad his shoulders were, and how his beard was coming in a dark auburn color, and how he had the far-seeing gaze of a seaman, just like the fishermen around here.
“Sorry, it’s in my room. It’s mounted on the wall, so it’s easier if you come up. But if you’re not comfortable with that…”
She considered the question, eyeing him carefully. The chances that a town- council-contracted investigator would behave inappropriately with the interim constable seemed low. He wasn’t being at all flirty any more.
The fact that she kind of missed that was her problem.
“It’s fine. Let’s go. But you have to be prepared for some gossip if we’re seen going up to your room together.”
“I can live with that if you can.”
“The truth is, you’d probably be good for my reputation.” She grinned at him. “Maybe I can move on from being the girl who got left at the altar.”