Page 57
“Grady asked me to the dance,” she told Noah.
“Did he, now? You sure you want to do that? It’ll put a target on your back. Every single woman on this island will be gunning for you.” He grinned. “I might have to go myself just to watch the show. You might want to bring a service weapon.”
“Well, Fergus asked me, too. Should I go with him instead?”
After an astonished moment, Noah threw his head back and let out a howl of laughter. “Now that’s what I’m talking about. Finally the men around here are waking up to the diamond hiding in plain sight. All they had to do was look up a little.”
She made a face at him. Of course he had to throw in a dig about her height. But underneath the teasing, she knew he was genuinely delighted by this unexpected situation.
“I might skip it,” she told her brother. “Especially if you’re going to be so annoying.”
“You’d better go. I don’t care which one you choose. Maybe both? Go as a polycule. That’ll get the island talking.”
She struggled to contain her laughter, but couldn’t manage it. After she finished laughing, she said, “You’re ridiculous. Who are you taking? You could have your pick…from all of Grady’s rejects, of course.” Teasing him back was required.
“I don’t know. There might be someone…but I’m not ready to talk about it.”
And try as she might, she couldn’t get him to say one more word about his mystery crush. Tickling didn’t work. Begging didn’t work. Insane guesses didn’t work.
“When Luke gets back, I’m going to lobby to bring back torture,” she threatened.
Laughing, Noah got to his feet and retreated, waving a throw pillow as a white flag. “I guess you’ll see for yourself at the dance. Or not.”
Over the next couple of days, while Noah was fixing her truck—he was more mechanical than she was—Marigold lined up facts like bowling pins and tried to make sense of them.
Fact: Dennis Murphy, Perry Atwater III, her brother Ollie, and an unidentified girl had been friends, until a possible sexual assault had sent them all away, in one way or another.
Fact: Money had been spent to keep it quiet.
Fact: Bjorn’s boat was seen out in a dangerous nor’easter on the same night Perry had disappeared, which could also be the same night Ollie had died.
Fact: Both Grady and someone with a drone had been looking for something in the cemetery.
Fact. Some had been operating a drone over the sandbar road that stormy night. Maybe aiming at her, maybe not.
Fact: Aunt Dorothy had wanted to show her sister something in the woods.
Fact: Aunt Dorothy had emptied out a safe deposit box before she died, but hadn’t changed its beneficiary to someone actually living.
Then came the theories.
Theory: The assault in the woods upset Ollie so much, he’d rowed into a storm and died.
Theory: Ollie participated in the assault, and felt so guilty he rowed into a storm and died.
Theory: Ollie witnessed the assault and was offered money to keep quiet. He’d refused, and gotten murdered instead.
Theory: Aunt Dorothy had some evidence that she’d kept in the safe deposit box. She’d removed it and hidden it either in the cemetery or the woods.
Either way, what was it, and where was it now?
So many theories, so little actual proof of anything!
No one seemed to have anything to say about the girl who’d been assaulted. The Atwaters had done an excellent job burying that information. Dennis Murphy was dead. Ollie was dead. Perry Atwater was jet-setting around Europe. Perhaps the girl was also dead. Maybe no one would ever know what had actually happened.
By the day before the dance, Marigold was more than ready for a break. But she had a problem.
Her standard date outfit involved slim cigarette pants, a flowy top, and ballet flats. That might do for an island dance—no one would really care what she wore anyway—but somehow she wanted to make more of an impression at this one.