AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Light It Up

Page 72

by Jennifer Bernard

“Yes, but all of those are now solved and had nothing to do with any serial killer. I just don’t know how Sea Smoke is connected to all those drownings, that’s all. Our drownings are all fishing-related, or—” She broke off abruptly and stared at Fergus.

She saw it in his eyes.

“Ollie,” she whispered. “You think Ollie was…” She shuddered so hard her Italian roll shook in her hands. “Oh my God. You think Ollie was a serial killer’s first victim?”

“Maybe.”

No, no, that couldn’t possibly be true. “Everyone said he disappeared during a storm. That he rowed out on his own and got swept out to sea. No one said he was murdered.”

“There might have been more to it than that.”

“You’re saying everyone’s been lying all this time?” Noah demanded.

“Or they didn’t know,” said Fergus. “It was covered up. The truth was buried. Buried at sea, you could say.”

And for a sickening moment she was back in her gray ocean limbo, that face swimming toward her, begging her for help.

31

“Are you okay?” Fergus scooted his chair closer to Marigold, who looked suddenly white-faced. His arm was around her before he even knew it.

“Yeah, I just…sorry, I’m still a little wonky.” She passed the back of her hand across her forehead and drew in a shaky breath. “Go on.”

He shared a glance with Noah, who shrugged, then checked the time on his phone. “Can we continue this later? We should get to the dock. I booked us a water taxi.”

Marigold trembled, an involuntary tremor that probably infuriated her.

“No. I’ll get us a room here in town,” Fergus said. “I don’t think she’s up for that trip yet.”

When Marigold didn’t argue, he knew he was right.

But Noah had to get back for a shift the next day, so he pushed back his chair and said goodbye. “You’ll watch over her?” he asked—or ordered—Fergus. His expression said he’d be willing to go mano-a-mano with an FBI agent if he didn’t.

Fergus just nodded, since the question didn’t need to be asked. Nothing was more important right now than protecting Marigold.

After Noah had left, Fergus fetched Marigold a glass of water and watched while she sipped it.

“I hate this,” she grumbled. “I never even get sick. I get a cold like once every five years. My whole family got Covid and I didn’t. I don’t like this feeling.”

“You’re not sick. You went through a traumatic experience.”

As if to accentuate the point, a car backfired on the brickwork street outside d’Amato’s, sending Marigold jolting out of her chair. Slowly she sank back down. “Ow.”

“It was like that for me after I was injured in Afghanistan. Don’t for a second think it makes you weak. It’s your nervous system reacting. You have no control over it. But it does get better. Just takes time.”

“I feel like I don’t have time. The person who killed my brother is…what, maybe back on the island? How is that even possible? I know everyone on the island, or at least mostly.” Sweat dotted her forehead. She swiped her hand across it. “God, I’m a mess. I must look terrible. How far is that hotel room? It has a shower, right?”

“You look fine, better than fine,” he assured her. “When you opened your eyes, I never saw such a beautiful sight.”

“Beautiful?” She scrunched her face at him skeptically.

“Gorgeous. Bonnie, as my Scottish granny would say. You’re a bonnie lass, Marigold Olson.”

“And you’re a shameless flirt.”

“No.” He shook his head. “I’m dead serious right now. I might be a charmer when it suits my purposes, especially when I’m undercover in a new territory, but I’m telling you what I think.”

Color was seeping back to her cheeks. “Maybe you’re the one with the vision issues.”