Page 88
“On the tape, what was happening? Did you try to kiss her?”
“I didn’t know what she was! Yeah, I tried to kiss her and she said ‘no’ and pulled away, but I knew she liked me. Why wouldn’t she? She knew who I was. Men like me don’t get rejected. I tried again. I pushed her to the ground and pinned her arms above her head and kissed her and …touched her. Him. That’s when I found out. I hit her. I was so angry. I hit her again and kept going. And then she fucking bit my ear!”
He clapped his hand to the mangled scar on his ear.
“There was a witness, right? Dennis Murphy?” Fergus asked.
“Dennis was laughing at me. He said, ‘you just kissed a dude.’”
Atwater didn’t seem to have any clue about where they were heading. He was steering erratically, one direction, then another. Was it time to tackle him and take control of the boat? None of the running lights were on, and the fog hovering over the surface was so thick they might not be able to see the buoys they were passing. What if they ran into one of those big green bell buoys?
But at this point, he didn’t want to interrupt Atwater’s confessional trance. This might be their only chance to hear his story, because clearly, the man didn’t intend for them to make it out of this alive. That was why he was spilling his guts. Confession could feel so good after a lifetime of crimes.
“I thought about what my friends would say if they knew. Boarding schools are brutal. If they got hold of this…I couldn’t let it get out. Ever. Ollie left me a note in the woods saying she wanted to explain, and to meet her that night. So I did. I waited for her in the woods, without Dennis this time. I ambushed her. Him. I punched him in his lying face, over and over. I knew she deserved it. I wanted to obliterate him. I kept thinking of Dennis laughing at me, and what my father would say. The shame if it got out. I wanted the whole thing obliterated, all of it, especially her. Him.”
Fergus wondered what it meant that he kept going back and forth from “he” to “she.” Maybe neither felt exactly right.
“So you beat her unconscious.” Coolly, calmly, Marigold kept the confession on track. “Then, even though it was stormy, you put her into a rowboat and pushed her into the current.”
“After I stopped hitting her, I felt bad. I mean, it felt good to hurt her, but she was so small, and I…I don’t know. I felt bad. I didn’t kill her. Him. He was still alive. He was whispering something under his breath. All I could understand was the word ‘selkie.’ So I knew that was what he wanted. He wanted to go back to where he belonged. The ocean. That’s where the selkies live.”
Fergus could just imagine what a psychiatrist would make of this story. Had Atwater created the selkie delusion to help justify his actions? For a fifteen-year old boy to commit such violence against another human being, one who hadn’t actually harmed him…there had to be something very wrong with him.
“So that’s what happened with Ollie,” he said briskly. “What about Tilly Trelawny in Cornwall? And Fleur Gaspard in Marseilles? Omar Shah in Morocco?”
“Some things aren’t natural,” he whispered, barely audible over the howling wind. “I had to. They called to me, they tempted me. Just like Ollie.”
It clicked. “You were attracted to them. And you couldn’t allow that.”
Atwater winced and shoved his hands over his ears, the gun now pointing toward the ceiling of the wheelhouse. “Shut up. It wasn’t like that. It was their fault.”
“How was it their fault?” Marigold asked. “They were just being themselves, right?”
Atwater scowled at a swell rolling toward them and didn’t answer. Was he starting to realize he was incriminating himself? Fergus had to keep him talking.
“They were all young, and they were all small,” Fergus said, assembling the victims in his mind. “That’s the one thing they all had in common. Some were girls, some were boys, but all of them were on the androgynous side, weren’t they? They didn’t fit in with standard physical definitions. Is that why you chose them?”
“I chose them because they called to me, just like Ollie! It felt so good to kill them.” Atwater burst out viciously. “I still think about how good it felt, and I count the days until I can do it again. I’m doing the world a favor and you all should thank me. Especially you!” He spun around and aimed his gun at Marigold, who was hanging onto a safety bar in the forward cabin of the speedboat. “You’re too fucking tall for a woman!”
Marigold froze, staring down the barrel of the gun, while Fergus’ blood ran cold. He calculated distance and timing and odds, and prepared to move.
Then, of all things, Marigold smiled ruefully. “You sound like my mother, minus the cursing. She doesn’t like that kind of thing.”
For a terrifying moment, Fergus feared that she’d pressed exactly the wrong button—the “teasing” button that would rush Atwater back to his days of being tormented at school. The man’s body quivered with tension, and Fergus readied himself to pounce.
Then Atwater laughed. It was a strange laugh, harsh and thin, as if it wasn’t a sound his throat was used to making. Marigold smiled winningly up at him, and Fergus saw that no, that was the button she shouldn’t have pushed. Her smile probably looked like Ollie’s…the girl he’d liked before his own fear turned him into a monster, unless he’d been one all along.
Fergus couldn’t hold off another second.
He launched himself at Atwater, grabbed his gun-wielding arm, and twisted hard until the man howled with pain and the gun clattered to the floor of the cabin. With no one at the wheel, the boat lost speed, and turned into a plaything tossed around by the wind and the waves. They plunged up and down, the hull slamming against the water, as if it might break apart, freezing spray crashing in over the deck.
Marigold was trying to climb out of the cabin, but every time she made progress, the ocean would rise up and knock her off her feet. That was fine with Fergus; he had the situation handled. He didn’t need complications.
“Perry Atwater, you’re under arrest for the murders of Ollie Olson, Fleur Gaspard, Tilly Trelawny, Omar Shah and the attempted murder of Ellie Burke. You have the right to remain silent!” He had to yell over the roar of the wind. “Anything you say can and will be used against you.”
Atwater might be a good foot shorter than Fergus, but he was fighting like a trapped rat. He twisted and wrenched his body this way and that. He’d gotten enough sea spray on his oilskin jacket that it was like trying to keep hold of a sea serpent.
Or a selkie trying to shed its pelt.