AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Light It Up

Page 92

by Jennifer Bernard

Atwater’s upper lip curled in contempt. Fergus could see how he’d lured those club kids into his orbit. It wasn’t just his money. There was something fascinating about his contradictions—the upper-class silver-haired exterior and the darkness lurking underneath. The ennui of someone who never had to work versus the shame of someone who’d been bullied. And now…a kind of eerie melancholy.

“You wouldn’t understand, cowboy. Once I got out to Sea Smoke, I…I missed Ollie. I saw her everywhere. She was calling to me. I wanted the selkies to take me to her and end this tedious world.”

“Sounds like the selkies rejected you, too.”

Atwater turned his head to the wall and that was that.

Later, Fergus joined Marigold and her family in the kitchen of their house on Stony Hill Road. Marigold wanted them to hear about the Water Killer investigation from him, the man who knew the most about it.

So many tears were shed during that conversation that he worried for Rhoda’s mental health. But Marigold insisted he tell it all, and by the end, Rhoda was clutching her husband’s enormous hand and clinging to Marigold with the other.

“We loved Ollie so much, but we were so terrified every moment of her life. So afraid that people wouldn’t understand, that they’d hurt her. We tried so hard to get her to…be like other boys. But she wouldn’t. Couldn’t. She did things her way.”

“His way…eh, never mind.” Bjorn’s big shoulders slumped. “We were just afraid for her. That’s all. It’s a small community here and people judge. They judge and they gossip and they condemn. It’s better now, but then…We did the best we could. We stayed to our end of the island. We kept her out of school. She didn’t mind because all she cared about was books. She ran around in the woods and she seemed happy until she was twelve or so. Then she met those boys.”

Tears streamed down Rhoda’s face. “Ollie was never a regular kid. She was…different. Her imagination…she was so magical. Like a wood fairy. She was tiny, like me.”

Marigold rubbed her mother’s back to soothe her. “So she had none of those pesky Viking genes?”

“They’re not pesky. I was wrong. You’re just fine as you are. I’m sorry I⁠—”

“It’s okay, Mom. I like being tall. It’s who I am. But maybe Ollie was just fine the way she was, too.”

“I never wanted her to change!” Rhoda cried. “Neither of us did! We loved her. But she was getting older, and she was changing already, and—” She pressed her lips together.

Staring at her mother, Marigold drew in a sharp breath and slowly rose to her feet. A truth was surfacing in her mind, just like that face rising through the gray ocean water.

She laced her fingers together and rested her hands on top of her head. “Oh. My. God.”

“What?” Noah looked around, confused, and caught Fergus’ eye. He shrugged, letting Marigold work it out for herself. He had a theory, a very wild one, and he thought maybe she’d just hit on the same one.

“You said she was changing already. That’s because she was hitting puberty. That night…Ollie survived, didn’t she? Dad, you went out on your boat and found her. You brought her into Harbortown. You saved her life. And then you took her somewhere so she could have a future.”

Bjorn’s big shoulders hunched as he met his wife’s gaze. A wordless communication passed between them; probably one of those infamous silences Marigold complained about.

“Yes,” he finally said in a croak like a winter crow’s. “She survived. She was half dead when I found her, but she survived. We didn’t know what to do after that. We couldn’t go to the police. The lawyers told us how it would go, that Perry would say he panicked because Ollie was a boy, even though he only found out because he was assaulting her. It would have been too humiliating for Ollie. We all talked it over…Ollie, us, Dorothy. We decided this would be a chance for Ollie to have a new start and a real future.”

Struggling with emotion, he swiped away a tear of his own. Rhoda clung to him, trembling.

“Dorothy had a friend, a wonderful woman who wanted a child. She came to the hospital and we loved her immediately. So did Ollie,” whispered Rhoda. “We knew Perry Atwater was an evil boy. So much money, so ruthless, so vengeful. We couldn’t allow him to know that Ollie was still alive.” Tears flowed down her cheeks, but she seemed unaware of them.

Bjorn picked up the story. “We took all the money the Atwaters gave us and set up a fund for Ollie. She needed hormones and she couldn’t get that on Sea Smoke. We were afraid Perry would come back to the island just like he had all the other summers. So we decided to tell everyone here that Ollie had died. In a way, it was true. That boy killed her innocence and her trust. Broke her heart.”

Fergus couldn’t imagine how hard it must have been for them all these years, knowing their child was alive, but telling no one. They’d chosen that path out of extreme worry and fear. Was it the right choice? It wasn’t his place to judge.

“Did you have any contact with Ollie after that? You just…let her go?” To Fergus, it sounded as if Marigold meant to use a different word. Maybe “abandoned”?

“We sent her letters to a post office box we rented. We asked her not to write to us because the postmistress here might put two and two together. But sometimes she wrote anyway, under a different name, of course. We thought about moving off the island, but Ollie didn’t want us to. She said she wanted to come back someday, once it was safe. Then for a few years in her twenties, she stopped communicating because it was too painful. She was angry and questioned our choice. I don’t blame her, but it was hard. So hard. Sometimes I thought I wouldn’t survive it.”

“Didn’t you ever think about just telling us?” Noah was trying to keep his voice even, but they could all hear the pent-up emotion.

“We did.” Bjorn’s deeply lined face showed every bit of the stressful long years of secret-keeping. “Several times. But our top priority was keeping Ollie safe, and the two of you safe. Telling you could jeopardize all of you. Maybe that was wrong. I don’t know. If it was, I hope you can forgive us.” He and his wife linked their hands together on the tabletop. “We did the best we knew. You two always had each other and you seemed happy.”

“But we never talked about anything!” Marigold cried. “I always knew something wasn’t right.” She broke off, glancing at her mother, as if expecting her to bolt from the kitchen. But Rhoda didn’t budge.

“I…struggled,” she said softly. “I’m deeply sorry, Marigold and Noah. Deeply.”

After another long, tension-packed moment, Marigold let out a whoosh of a sigh. Fergus read many things in her expression—sadness, questions, but mostly compassion. “Okay. Okay. Well, what about now? Are you in touch with Ollie now? Can we meet her?”