Page 81
“Madame took her time sending you,” she said.
“It was Mrs. Sisson who sent me. Madame’s still at her grandmother’s.”
In the carriage, she pulled the soft wool blanket up to her chin and waited for her teeth to stop chattering. A river of children poured from the tenements to make their way to school. Hetty saw her sisters’ twin faces in the crowd—distinct to her but identical to the world at large. All the children stared at the brougham like it was a beacon of good repair and wealth in the midst of their neglected chaos.
“Please, Paul,” Hetty said, leaning forward. “Can we give my sisters a ride?”
She slid down the window and waved. Lizzie and Jane burst toward the carriage with Christmas Day excitement. Hetty scooched over, and they piled in as many friends as they could fit. Paul drove toward their public school, the children leaning their heads out the windows, drinking in the freezing air as Milo—harness bells ringing, white mane streaming—trotted through the cold and crowded streets.
Mariah talked Granny into coming with her to Tartarus. “But what if Isabelle comes back?” Granny said.
“She’ll guess you’re with me,” Mariah promised, “and she’ll telephone for you to come home.”
Granny nodded. She always forgot about the telephone. They waited until midmorning, when Whitten would be at work, and brought Fossette with them since the dog was no longer in danger. In the foyer, they were greeted by Gowler and two police officers. One of the officers was a woman, which astonished Mariah and Granny.
“Madame. These two”—Gowler fumbled for the correct plural—“officers… want to speak to you. Which I don’t think you should do alone. I’d like them to wait in the library until Mr. Whitten can get here.”
Three years ago, when police arrived unexpectedly, Mariah had stood at the top of the stairs, watching Isabelle faint into Mr. Watson’s arms. She could not wait for Whitten to hear what these two had to say.
“Thank you, Gowler. I’ll speak to them now.”
“If you must,” he said, with uncertain firmness. “But I am telephoning Mr. Whitten.”
Mariah expected Granny to insist on coming with them, but she went upstairs without a word.
The police matron was a tiny woman with a warm, motherly demeanor. Her name, Mariah found out when they were seated in the library, was Mrs. Goodwin. The other one, Officer Donahue, stood by the fireplace while Mariah and Mrs. Goodwin faced each other on opposite sofas. Fossette sat in Mariah’s lap. Mrs. Goodwin reached out as if she meant to take Mariah’s hand but the distance was too great. Instead she clasped her own hands together and said, “We’re sorry to intrude, Mrs. Whitten. And we promise discretion. But we’ve come to ask about a child. A little girl.”
Mariah petted Fossette a bit too ferociously while she listened. She had been braced for bad news about Isabelle or an interrogation about Smythe’s fall. She hadn’t expected those words, a little girl.
Charlotte Norman. That was her daughter’s name. The baby had never sounded like anyone in particular. Charlotte Norman was a living, breathing someone.
Yesterday afternoon, Charlotte Norman had been stolen from her perambulator in Washington Square Park. The nanny hadn’t seen a thing; in fact, she’d rolled the empty carriage all the way home, believing Charlotte was napping inside, before she lifted the hood to find an empty mattress.
Mariah could see Jay’s long-legged strides across the grass. Scooping up the child with one arm, closing the hood with the other.
You should want to move heaven and earth for her.
Her. Charlotte Norman. Missing. Hadn’t Charlotte Norman been missing since the day she was born? Now she was found and lost, all at the same time.
Mariah could tell the police: My mother is missing too. She could tell them about Jay, and the note that had been left for Granny. An army of officers would rush to Horatio Street, or Southampton. Mariah knew they wouldn’t find Isabelle, or Jay, in either of those places. They were already gone.
Mrs. Goodwin was a mother, too, Mariah could tell. They looked at each other with solemn eyes, and Mariah reminded herself the sympathetic demeanor was meant to extract information.
“I never knew the child’s name until this minute,” Mariah said. She moved to the other couch to sit beside Mrs. Goodwin, Fossette still in her arms.
“When the Normans told us she was adopted,” Mrs. Goodwin said, petting the dog’s sleek little head, “the mother seemed the best place to start. We found out your name from their lawyer.”
“I’ve never seen her, not since her birth. I’ve tried to put all that behind me.”
Officer Donahue interrupted. “The Normans’ nanny tells us there’s been a blond woman sitting in the park, watching the child.”
Mariah touched her own dark hair as alibi. The words braced themselves behind her teeth: I know who took that child. And she could guess where they’d gone, too, the same place she had thought of, when Jay implied Mariah should be his accomplice. The house at Sebago Lake didn’t belong to the Bishops anymore. But this time of year it would be deserted. A familiar hideout, nobody to see them come or go. The perfect place to stop awhile and make a plan.
Mariah returned Mrs. Goodwin’s motherly gaze with a daughter’s vulnerability and said: “Mr. Whitten would not want anyone to find out about this piece of my past.”
“Nobody will ever know it from us,” Mrs. Goodwin said.
Mariah waited for her to ask about the father, but she didn’t. Possibly she assumed there were multiple candidates. Or else only mothers went mad and stole back babies.