AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Plus-One Pact

Page 4

by Lana Ferguson

“Why did you say that like a question?”

“I mean, I’m not sure it’s better, but I—”

“You didn’t know how to tell them, did you?”

“Okay, so maybe it was a little hard to bring up,” I admit, huffing out a breath as I press my fists to my hips. “We’ve been friends forever! I didn’t think about how weird it might be if we were suddenly. . . dating.”

Cole closes his eyes for a moment, like he’s praying for strength or something, finally bobbing his head as he seems to come to terms with things. He bends to pick up our bags, scoffing when I try to take mine from him, and then he’s marching up the steps to the front doors, leaving me to follow after him.

Part of me wants to ask if he’s really okay with all this; considering he’s been even quieter than usual lately, you might think it would even be decent of me to ask, but something has held me back. Maybe it’s just that this really is strange to think about.

Not that I haven’t thought about it.

Because let’s be honest, there were definitely moments in that first year of knowing Cole when I wondered if things might turn into more for us. He’s got a jawline that could cut glass, shoulders that look like they’re made for lifting things, and whenever those rare occasions pop up where he smiles . . . well. Not to mention he’s secretly the nicest guy I’ve ever known. I mean, one time he drove across town to bring me my purse, for goodness’ sake. Needless to say, I wouldn’t have been opposed to the idea, obviously, but Cole has never shown any interest in me like that. In fact, in the entire time I’ve known him, I haven’t seen him date at all. There have been one-off hookups here and there that he refused to give me details about, but never actual dates. Maybe Cole just isn’t cut out for dating.

I chase after him as he’s entering the resort, the doors barely having time to shut behind me before I hear a squeal from the other side of the room. “Emma!”

I beam at my sister as I catch sight of her bounding toward me, her hair bouncing behind her as she makes her way over. Katie has always been the exact opposite of me—blond where I’m brunette, short where I’m fairly tall, artistic where I’m more left brained—and there was even a time in my life when I used to be jealous of how perfect she always seemed to be. In recent years, though, I’ve come to acknowledge that she’s not better than me, just different.

Well, my therapist and I have come to acknowledge it.

“Katie!” I shriek, opening my arms as my older sister collides with my front.

“I’ve missed you,” she sighs. She pulls back, smacking me lightly on the arm. “You don’t visit enough.”

I chuckle. “No one told you to move to Colorado.”

“But David’s job is here,” she pouts.

I wave her off. “Yeah, yeah. I know.”

Katie turns her head and notices Cole standing there, her face lighting up all over again. “Cole! I’m so glad you could make it. When Emma said she was bringing you, I was a little annoyed that she found a way to duck out on another opportunity to find an actual date, but I guess I’ll forgive her since it’s you.”

“Oh.” I clear my throat. “Actually . . .”

Katie cocks her head. “Actually?”

“Cole and I . . . Well. You see, we’re—”

Cole must take pity on my floundering, moving closer and dropping his bag so he can throw an arm around my shoulders. He does it so naturally you’d think we’d been doing it forever, and sure, there are plenty of hugs between us, but he’s never just . . . held me like this. I feel an odd tingle in my shoulders where the warmth of his arm rests.

“We’re dating,” he says simply.

Katie’s mouth parts in surprise, her features completely blank with surprise for about three seconds before:

“Oh my God!” she squeals, jumping up and down. “I knew it! I knew you’d end up together!”

Now it’s my turn to cock my head. “You did?”

“Are you kidding me?” she scoffs. “You two are practically joined at the hip! I mean, you do everything together almost, and Cole is definitely hot, so I just assumed that you two would eventually take the plunge.”

There’s an odd sensation in my stomach when Katie calls Cole hot, but I can’t pinpoint what it is. I brush it aside, trying to focus on the dilemma at hand. I slowly wind my arm around Cole’s waist, feeling him tense slightly with the movement, but then he relaxes a moment later.

“That’s us,” I say with a nervous laugh. “Plungers.”

Katie squeals again. She does that a lot. “Wait till I tell David! Oh! Wait till I tell Mom and Dad!”

“Slow down there,” I laugh. “I’ll tell Mom and Dad myself.”