Page 50
“No.” He must know how relieved my laugh sounds about the topic because he joins me. “He’s always been encouraging whenever I told him about someone I was interested in, or if he saw someone he deemed eligible. We have this ritual where, when I get let down—and there’ve been plenty of those times,” I scoff, rolling my eyes so he knows I’m not bitter about it, “we watch rom-coms together. Even when I lived in Boston, he’d video call me so we could watch online at the same time together and make comments about the movie.” Did I really just admit that out loud? Duck pajamas, crying, and now my rom-com marathon breakup fetish. I might as well tell him about the first time I jerked off at this rate. “It’s silly. I know.”
“Nah, that’s cool…that you have that.”
Now I know I’m being humored. I think baby just told his first lie.
“Yeah, you seem like a rom-com kind of guy. I knew you’d understand.”
Chuckling, he knocks his shoulder into mine. “I don’t mind them. It’s not that I don’t like romance.”
I thought he might elaborate, but when he says nothing, I know my joke put my foot in my mouth. Crap. Should I tell him the jerk-off story now?
“Things just don’t always…line up for me at the right moments,” he says, surprising me, squinting across the pond as he speaks, “and that can be frustrating or confusing for someone…normal.”
Wait. What?
“You think you’re not normal?”
Sputtering, one of his brows hikes up. The self-deprecating smile on his face is one I never want to see again. “I know I’m not normal.”
“What’s normal?”
Sucking in a breath, he turns his head and gazes off into the distance. A cloud of vapor plumes in front of him a few seconds later. The muscle in his jaw shifts when he presses his lips together and frowns. Clearly, it’s a tough question for him, but I refuse to hear sad things today. I’ve already got enough sadness on my plate. If he tells me something depressing, I want to know now so I can fix it right here by the water. We’re going to be the ‘jolliest bunch of assholes’ on this side of the suburb for Christmas Eve if I have anything to say about it.
“Caffeinated soda.”
Okay, he mumbled that, and there’s no way I heard him correctly. “What?”
“I’m diet non-caffeinated in a caffeinated world.” He lets out a frustrated sigh. “I like caffeinated soda. I enjoy it and want it sometimes. I just…don’t need it as often as everyone else or under the same circumstances as they want it. I don’t understand caffeine addiction. I feel normal being non-caffeinated, even if I sometimes like…watching caffeinated soda. But if there was a soda contest, where people came to judge the attributes of soda, and they shook up every can, I probably wouldn’t fizz like all the other sodas because I need to be shaken a certain way.”
I think I got most of that. Probably not all of it since I’ll now be self-conscious drinking soda around him, but…yeah. He needs a gentle reply for sure.
“I don’t think that makes you abnormal. I think it just makes you…”
“What?”
“Rob.”
“Just Rob,” he chuckles. “Sounds like a T-shirt.”
Okay, maybe I could have put that better. “I just mean, you have a heart, and feelings, and a great personality. You have just as much to offer as all the other sodas. Someone might really like your brand of soda.” I’m still flattered and floored that he shared his whole soda analogy with me, but, God, how can he not see that?
“Yeah. They line up outside the convenience store for it.”
Shaking my head in wonder at his amusement, I see all the armor now. I can see right through it like crystal-clear freaking soda.
“I would.” The words fall from my lips before I even know I’m admitting them. Like every rom-com I’ve ever watched, his gaze darts to mine the second I avert my own. Holy shit. Say something, Dylan. “If my dad didn’t elbow me out of the way, I mean.”
As he laughs at my self-save, I take calming breaths and do my best to act like I’m the biggest comedian on the planet. We head back to the house, commenting on things like the squirrel nests in the trees and how the sky is starting to look cloudier with the wind picking up. The entire time, I mentally kick my own ass for letting his adorableness make me word vomit.
Way to make it awkward when he has to enter the fake boyfriend battlefield in a few minutes. I’ll give him credit; he’s being super cool by not saying anything about it.
With each step that takes us nearer to the house, however, it becomes difficult to swallow. There’s yet another secret trying to hatch, as if I don’t have enough in my life right now. Maybe it was the reality check from the guys at Gametronics last week or Rob’s soda confession, but there’s one truth I can’t pass off with excuses and sound judgment anymore. I don’t want to be Rob’s friend. Whatever I feel about him is so much more than a crush. It’s whatever the next level is that comes after a crush. A Donkey Kong smash?
Oh, my word. I’ve gone Full Dylan even in my head now.
The door to the house opens, and my steps falter, making me snag my hand on my coat pocket. Dad’s wearing a sweater, but it’s way too cold for him to be stepping out on the porch with that cough he’s had. He waves at us and hollers that the food is ready. I try to raise my hand to wave back, but it catches on something. Glancing down at my gloved fingers, I find Rob’s wrapped around mine. He’s holding my hand.
My feet stumble over themselves as he continues forward, but I scramble when he glances back to see if I’m okay. I’m the one staring now, gawking dazedly as he waves to my father. Did he take my hand because he saw Dad, or could it be that he…