Page 17
“Hopefully,” Whitney agreed.
With a click, the Christmas lights blinked on, blanketing them in warm, twinkling light. Whitney had been expecting it this time, but it still gave her an uncomfortable pinch in her chest. This might be the weirdest Christmas Eve she’d ever experienced.
Not the worst. Today was unusual but not terrible. As much as she and Liza were still finding their footing with each other, it was oddly comforting to spend Christmas with someone who shared her misgivings about the holiday.
“You can turn them off, you know,” Liza said. “I won’t mind, and neither will Lou or Rina.”
“I know.” Whitney sighed. “It’s just…silly. I don’t know why they bother me so much.”
Liza’s expression said she didn’t buy that for a moment.
“When I was a little girl, Home Alone was my favorite movie,” Whitney said. “And I do have a point in telling you this, I promise. I thought the McCallisters were family goals, like I know they’re also super messy, but there was so much love in those big, chaotic family scenes, you know?”
“Yes, I suppose there was,” Liza agreed.
“I was a lonely kid, so I would picture myself as part of the families I saw on TV, and I wanted to be a McCallister so badly. I imagined getting left behind with Kevin, and I just knew he and I would have had the best time together, causing trouble and pranking the bad guys.” She sighed, earning a sympathetic look from Liza. “I didn’t mean for this to be a pity party, honestly. I didn’t have a terrible childhood. It just felt like everything always revolved around Ruby, but the point I was trying to make is that this house reminds me of that movie somehow. Not in size or style, just the abundance of Christmas decorations, I think. Even though it’s a vacation home, I can picture festive family celebrations happening here, and I think that’s why it feels like a gut punch every time the Christmas lights come on. Like, I don’t belong here. I’m a stranger in someone else’s home on Christmas, and anyway, I’m rambling.” She gave Liza a rueful smile.
“By comparison, my childhood Christmases were pretty average,” Liza said, staring introspectively into her wine.
Whitney practically held her breath, silently begging Liza to tell her more. She knew she was too invested in Liza at this point, too interested in finding out more about her and the family she was estranged from. Whitney did this sometimes, developed unhealthy fixations on people, particularly people she was attracted to. Her therapist thought it was related to how she’d grown up, how starved for attention she’d been as a child.
“Do you have siblings?” she asked, figuring that was a fairly safe question.
Liza shook her head. “Just me. You didn’t pick up on my only-child energy?”
Whitney smiled. “Now that you mention it.” She watched the flames in the fireplace for a minute, wondering what else she could get away with asking. “Where did you grow up?”
“Fitchburg.”
Whitney felt her eyebrows lift before she could school her reaction. Fitchburg was more of a working-class town, though, and Liza seemed like someone who’d grown up affluent.
Liza chuckled. “Not what you were expecting?”
“No, I pictured you growing up somewhere like Lincoln or Concord.”
“Well, you pictured it wrong. I’ve developed a taste for nicer things now that I can afford them, but that isn’t how I grew up. My dad’s an electrician, and my mom waits tables at a chain restaurant.”
“Okay…wow. Not at all what I expected.”
“I’m what they call first-generation, the first in my family to attend college. My parents were so proud.” Her expression turned distant, her smile bittersweet.
“I’m sorry that changed,” Whitney said softly.
“Yeah, me too, but I’ve made peace with it…at least mostly.”
“Do we ever truly make peace with something like that?” Whitney pondered, returning her gaze to the fireplace. “Our parents aren’t supposed to disappoint us. We’re supposed to disappoint them, right?”
“Oh, I’ve definitely done that.” Liza’s laugh was harsh and without humor. “The divide between us had been growing for a while. I’m a perfectionist, and I channeled that energy into my career. They accused me of thinking I was better than they are, but really, that couldn’t have been farther from the truth. I was just trying to make myself proud. I wanted them to be proud of me too.”
“I’m so sorry,” Whitney whispered.
“I heard enough jokes and slurs about gay people while I was growing up that I kept dating men well into my thirties, even though deep down, I’d always known I like women.” She took a long drink of her wine. “I finally came out to them in 2019, and they didn’t say much at the time. I don’t think they knew what to say, honestly. I doubt it had ever crossed their minds that they might accidentally raise a lesbian.”
Whitney hesitated, wondering how Liza would react if she reached out and took her hand. In the end, she couldn’t help herself. She moved to the sofa beside her and tangled their fingers together in a gesture of support.
Liza didn’t look at her, but she also didn’t pull away. “Then the pandemic happened, and they went down an unfortunate rabbit hole about vaccines and masks. I’m sure you can imagine who they voted for. We argued about it, and my dad called me a…a slur I’d rather not repeat, and that was pretty much the end of our relationship. We speak occasionally, a phone call on birthdays, that kind of thing. But we don’t see each other anymore.”
“Sounds like their loss, and I’m so sorry they did that to you. No one deserves to be rejected by their parents for who they love.”