AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

’Tis the Season to be Spellbound

Page 9

by Harper Wynn

“Jesus,” Belle whispered. She pushed another beer toward him. “Did they…I mean, was it, like, a bad place?”

“No one put their hands on me, if that’s what you’re asking.”

Belle sighed through her nose. She stayed quiet, waiting. But Carter didn’t have anything left to give. If he kept digging at wounds, they’d open again.

“It’s late.” It wasn’t, but he said it anyway.

Scarlet whistled. Belle tapped her long, coffin-shaped fingernails on her beer bottle. He saw it in her eyes, the urge to call him on it, to push at him, to pry at his skin until he showed her what was underneath. His chest ached with everything he hadn’t said. Truth under truth. The dirty parts.

“And I have work in the morning,” he added. “Since I broke Adrian’s store.”

Belle’s lips split into a warm smile. “Don’t forget to come by for breakfast.”

Carter nodded. “Wouldn’t miss it.”

Brisk night air nipped his cheeks, the kind only mountains could make. Belle’s attention stayed steady on his face. The flickering lightbulb sent shadows skittering across her faux fur hood and pale blue mittens. She didn’t hesitate, just threw her arms around Carter’s shoulders and held onto him.

“You didn’t deserve that,” Belle whispered. “None of it. You know that, right?”

Ten years. He flattened his hand on her back and drew her closer. You know that, right? Truthfully, he wasn’t sure. “I’m sorry, Belle.”

“Me, too,” she said. “Add me on Facebook. Follow me on Instagram. Text me. Let’s not… Let’s not let this happen again, okay?”

“Yeah, okay,” he said.

Belle let him go. They stood there, watching each other, searching for splinters from broken hearts too old to mend. Her boots crunched through fresh snow. She didn’t look back. She never had. Carter remembered nights spent in this creaky old cabin, drinking wine on the roof with the girl she used to be, and watched her walk away.

“What do you think, Scarlet?”

Wrapped in a black button-down and surrounded by flat, exotic greenery, Carter was a shadow against the wallpaper in the upstairs bathroom. Scarlet’s long talons clicked porcelain as she stood on the back of the toilet. She snapped her beak at a fake plant and cocked her head, one round eye fixed on him.

What the hell was he supposed to wear? He huffed, gathering a deep breath until it bulged his cheeks. The person in the mirror wasn’t the man Carter ever thought he’d be.

Three new outfits from catalogs Carter couldn’t pronounce had been waiting for him when he arrived home a month ago. Three shirts with crisp collars and silver buttons. Two pairs of black pants, one pair of designer jeans, and a thin leather belt. The Oxfords had looked wildly inappropriate next to his combat boots, two different versions of the same man sitting side by side in the walk-in closet. But the three years he’d spent in captivity had broadened his shoulders and filled out his arms, and most of the clothes he’d left behind were unwearable. Ginger and his mother had tried to polish unpleasantries from Carter’s image by making him look like the rest of them. Rich, and primped, and privileged.

“The boots are fine, right?” He shifted back and forth, flexing his feet in the battered Doc Martens he’d worn since high school. Nerves lit under his skin as he gave his reflection a once over. The scar on his cheek carved a line through blond stubble. Blurred ink fit behind his ear, a mistake he’d made after too many beers on his eighteenth birthday. Light glinted off the buttons on his shirt, left untucked over new jeans. Slowly, he raked his fingers through his hair.

“All right,” he said softly, and smoothed his hands down the front of his shirt.

Once Scarlet bounced onto the wooden branch in her cage, Carter rinsed out the coffee pot and turned off the stove. He fed the lovebirds, Ozzy and Sharon, seeds out of his palm and re-filled the finches’ feeders, trying not to think of last night. The way Belle’s throat bobbed as she listened to ghost stories from a past he wished he could wipe clean. How she’d pressed her whole body against his and held onto him. As he locked the door and stuffed his hands into his coat pockets, he wondered if there was enough time to re-learn how to be the person he’d wanted to become in this sleepy, little town. For once, he wasn’t looking for a way out.

Pine scented the air, chilled by freezing fog that’d crept through Briar hours ago. As the engine rumbled and ice turned to droplets on the windshield, Carter thought about consequences. He thought about Grayson, who’d climbed into the passenger’s seat on his nineteenth birthday and left hickeys on his neck right before Carter got into a fist fight with a stranger. He thought about Ginger’s hands on his face—sit still—as she dabbed antiseptic on his split lip.

The truck lurched forward. Muted sunlight glistened on frosty branches. Behind the movie theater where he parked, prints peppered the ground, all hooves and paws. Footsteps echoed as he crunched through fresh, white powder. Sometimes, like this, Briar fit around his heart perfectly. A house cat prowled back and forth in front of a window, watching a plump squirrel clean its whiskers on the lid of a trashcan, and steam billowed from the chimney attached to The Crow’s Nest at the end of the block. Warmth unfurled in his chest, moving restlessly through stiff bones as the bell jingled and he stepped inside.

Belle arranged pastries in the case attached to the counter: baked apples shaped into rose buds, and maple doughnuts sprinkled with bacon bits, poppy seed bread topped with lemon cream, and savory gouda scones draped in thinly sliced turkey. She peeked at him through the glass.

“Good timing. The muffins are still warm,” she said. “You want fig jam with yours?”

“I’ll take it if you’re offering.”

“Matcha latte?”

Carter nodded.

They sat at a table near the counter. Carter spread seedy red jam over the muffin on his plate and waited, slowly shrinking under Belle’s watchful gaze. Words jumped into his throat, jumbled pieces of a story he didn’t know how to tell. He kept his mouth shut, arranging sentences in different orders, looking for the right one in a sea of wrong.

I went to prison. It was our only choice. They left me.