Page 104
This was my moment to tell him everything. I knew with absolute certainty that if I didn’t take it, I’d always regret not doing so.
“I told you because…” I took a deep breath. “Because I don’t want to lie to you anymore.”
“Aubrey—” Knox started, but I stopped him.
“Please. I need to say this.” If I didn’t, I never would.
He dipped his head, telling me to continue. I took a step back, putting some space between us. My feet seemed to move on their own as I tried to find the courage to say the words.
“I know this whole thing started as a lie. We agreed to fake date until Christmas, but then being around you every day, it started to feel real. And for the first time in months, it felt like I could breathe again. Like I could just be… me.” My throat tightened. “I wasn’t pretending to be okay. I wasn’t trying to convince everyone I had everything figured out. I was just happy.”
I paced five steps to the left and then back, hands moving in front of me as I talked. The whole time Knox stood there silently.
“Suddenly, it was like I was fourteen again with this giant crush on you. A crush I thought I had gotten over. But there you were, around my family, acting like you’d always belonged. Or helping out here at the bakery when I never asked, all because I hurt my wrist. And that old crush kept on growing until I couldn’t tell what was pretend or real anymore.”
I stopped pacing and looked at him.
“I didn’t mean to go back on our deal. I really didn’t. But Knox…” My hands gripped the sides of my apron as I finally let out the words I’d been holding back. “I don’t want this to be fake anymore. I want you. All of you. No pretending, no walking that invisible line, no worrying about anyone else.”
I met his grey eyes, my chest tight, shoulders bunched up near my ears.
“Because Knox…” My voice trembled. “I’m falling in love with you.”
My declaration hung in the air.
My heart was in my throat as the two of us stared at one another. Knox didn’t move or say a word, his expression blank. Immediately, the sting of rejection hit me. I shouldn’t have said anything. This was a bad idea.
“That… you don’t have to say anything. In fact,” my hands fluttered in front of me, my face hot as my eyes looked everywhere but at him, “forget I said anything. Erase it from your mind.”
His lack of words was an answer in and of itself. Stupid me for thinking he felt the same way. I blinked rapidly so the tears that built in my eyes wouldn’t fall. I would not cry in front of Knox. I had a little bit of dignity left.
“You can go. I need to finish these cookies.” My voice sounded far away to my own ears as I stepped around him and toward the oven. The cookies weren’t done but maybe if I stood with my back turned, Knox would leave and spare me any further embarrassment.
With my back facing him, I reached up and acted like I was twisting the dial.
“Aubrey.” Knox’s big hand came up and flipped the off button to the ovens. I opened my mouth to protest when he grabbed my wrist and tugged me away from them before forcing me around to face him.
“Knox, don’t—”
“No. You got to say what you wanted. Now it’s my turn.” His tone was firm and gravelly. “I’m starting to wonder if I need to get you some glasses.”
“What?”
“How have you not noticed how crazy I am about you?” He shook his head. “You are all I see. All I think about. I can’t walk into a room and not search for you. Hell, I can’t even be away from you for more than a few hours.”
Knox took a step closer. When I moved back, he followed until my lower back caught the edge of the counter.
“Aubrey, there hasn’t been any pretending about this for me. Not since the first day.”
My breath caught, hope flaring between my ribs.
“I agreed to be your boyfriend because you needed someone to play the part, but I also selfishly agreed so I could have an excuse to be around you. I’d told myself to keep my distance from you for years, but having the chance to be with you, even if it was fake, well, I was going to take it.”
His hand came up and cupped my jaw, his thumb brushing against my cheek.
“I’m falling irrevocably in love with you.”
I heard the words, yet my mind couldn’t seem to comprehend them.