Page 94
I could practically feel the tension rolling off him as he watched me rip the tape and fold the sides back. I pushed past bubble wrap until my fingers closed around something heavy.
I pulled it free and stared at it.
It was a ceramic pie dish.
My brows furrowed as I turned it over in my hands. It was old-fashioned, with a faded light blue pattern around the edges and a few tiny imperfections on the glaze. Like it had been well used.
Something about it felt familiar. I ran my thumb over the rim, then froze. Suddenly, I was transported to my mom’s kitchen. My dad was there, handing me a vintage pie dish when I voiced that I wanted to learn how to make the dessert. He stood beside me as he helped me fill it with apple pie slices and cinnamon. I heard him declare that apple pie, his all-time favorite, only tasted good when made in this dish. A dish that broke a few months before he passed.
“This…” My breath caught, and my fingers tightened around the dish. “This is…”
I looked at Knox, my eyes wide. He was watching me carefully, almost holding his breath.
“This looks like my dad’s favorite pie dish.”
I felt my family’s attention on us as the words left my mouth.
“It does. I managed to track down someone who had one from the same set,” Knox said.
My throat clogged, pressure behind my eyes threatening to spill. My dad found it at a yard sale all those years ago, and when it broke, I was convinced I would never see one like it again.
I gripped the porcelain tightly, almost afraid if I let it go it would somehow disappear.
“I know it’s not the same as the one you had.” There was a tentative edge to Knox’s voice.
“Oh, honey,” Mom choked out. I glanced over to find her staring at my hands, eyes glistening.
“I’m sorry if I overstepped,” Knox said quickly, but I shook my head.
“You didn’t.” I handed the dish over to my mom, then turned to Knox. He opened his mouth to say something, but I cut him off by diving into his arms.
I buried myself in his chest, shoulders shaking as I fought back a sob. It was a gift I didn’t even know I needed, and it brought back memories of my dad. Memories I had let myself forget because thinking about him hurt too much.
Knox’s arms wrapped tight around me, chin resting on my head. I heard Sophie ask what was wrong, and the others quickly spoke up, giving me a moment.
“Thank you,” I whispered, my voice breaking against his neck.
He said nothing. He just held me tighter and pressed his lips against the top of my head.
The clatter of forks on plates, Sophie and Charlotte playing away in the living room, and multiple conversations at once filled the house. The craziness of Christmas had died down, and we were now seated at the table having our annual breakfast we always had after opening presents.
Knox’s hand rested on my knee as he held a deep conversation with my mom and Annie. It was hard to imagine what Christmas would have looked like without him. He blended in so well with everyone, like he was always meant to be a part of it.
It never felt this way with Connor on any occasion, not just at the holidays. Hell, nothing with Connor had ever felt the way it did when I was with Knox. It was hard to believe it’d only been two weeks since Knox walked into Maple & Mistletoe. And yet, I felt like a completely different person.
“You’re staring,” Jackson whispered at my side. I was looking at Knox, and I couldn’t help it. Not after he got me the sweetest gift I’d ever received. I’d only briefly mentioned it, not knowing he’d go and find an exact replica within days.
“Just a pretend relationship, huh?” Jackson said it loud enough for only us to hear.
This was so far past being a fake relationship. Clearly, he noticed that too.
“Just know,” he said, a small smirk tugging at his mouth, “you’re getting awfully good at pretending.”
That was the problem. I couldn’t tell if Knox was pretending or not. Because I wasn’t.
“Is everyone ready to find out the winner of Lynn-mas?” Mom asked, gaining everyone’s attention.
Knox squeezed my knee and flashed me a wide smile. I couldn’t let myself think about any of that. Not when we’ve had an amazing Christmas and bringing it up would only ruin it. I needed to wait until it was just Knox and me since Jackson was the only one here who knew the truth about us.