Page 249
“Ciarán.”
Saying his name even hurts.
“Oh, he’s not coming.” His eyes flit to Abbie, then back to me. “Luke is heading home to see family tomorrow, so he’s having dinner with him then coming during the week for dinner with me and Noah.”
My heart sinks.
“He left something here for Rose. For her birthday and Christmas. It’s in my room, take it before you go.”
I nod, feeling numb.
The others take their seats while Gabe brings out several plates of steaming food—glazed ham, tender-looking turkey, glistening vegetables, and a massive bowl of mashed potatoes with butter melting down the sides. Once everything is on the table, he sits to my left. Noah sits opposite him, with the others filling the seats to my right.
It looks amazing. I have no interest in any of it. But I fill my plate, nonetheless.
“Is Santa all set?” Theo asks.
“Yup. He’s bringing a chalkboard easel and enough art supplies to run a school. A few smaller bits she asked for too.”
“She’ll love that,” Gabe says warmly from beside me.
Noah dollops a massive pile of potatoes on Theo’s plate. “You heading off tomorrow?”
“Tonight actually, after this. Me and Ren said we’d get a head start on the long drive.”
I zone out as they talk, eating the food on my plate that I can’t even enjoy. Abbie hardly says a word through dinner, just a little about the play at the school she teaches. No mention of Paul, which is odd considering she hasn’t stopped talking about him for months.
Before I know it, dinner is over. Abbie and Theo leave, and I say my goodbyes, making sure I get my hug from Gabe.
I fucking need it.
“Oh, Rose’s stuff,” he says when we separate, then disappears into his room and returns with a large pink canvas bag. “Here you go.”
My heart races when I take it. “Thanks, I’ll see you both during the week.”
“Later,” Noah calls out, waving with yellow rubber gloves on.
That gets a small chuckle from me. “Later, domestic goddess.”
He cackles.
Gabe walks me to the door, and I can’t help but ask, “What’s up with Abbie?”
He frowns. “She and Ciarán had a big fight a few weeks ago. Neither will tell me what about, she’s been pretty miserable since. But Ciarán…” He shakes his head. “Whatever happened that day, he’s been inconsolable. He seems so lost. Heartbroken.”
My fingers tighten around the handles of the pink bag.
Heartbroken.
For weeks I’ve been replaying every second of that afternoon, trying to understand how the man who built a swing for my daughter and agreed to spend Christmas with us could look me in the eye days later and tell me I meant nothing.
I knew he was lying.
I fucking knew it.
But knowing it and hearing Gabe say Ciarán has been falling apart are two very different things.
Something had happened.