AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Sweet Hearts

Page 253

by Laura Kain

“I fucked up,” I admit, needing to share even a part of it with him. “With the guy. I messed it up so bad.”

“What happened?”

“Everything was so good. He was good to me. So sweet and funny and caring.” My hand shakes in his. “Then I pushed him away. I said horrible things I didn’t mean because I was scared and didn’t think I was good enough for him. I kept telling myself it wouldn’t last.”

More tears pool in the corners of my eyes, falling over the bridge of my nose.

“I was so in my head. All the shit I already thought about myself. Thinking about all the ways he’d eventually realize he’d made a mistake choosing me.” I grip Gabe tighter. “And I believed it. Everything about him is perfect for me, and I threw it all away because I was scared.” My tears don’t stop now, fat droplets streaming down my face.

Gabe hugs me to him. “It’s okay. I’m here.”

That makes me cry harder. I wrap my arms around him and bury my face in his chest.

“I said cruel things I didn’t mean because I knew he wouldn’t leave unless I made him believe I didn’t want him.” I sniffle, my tears disappearing into Gabe’s sweater. “I miss him so much; everything hurts all the time.”

I miss them. Not just him. I miss little hands against my face. Cuddles on the sofa. Nonsense conversations I somehow learned to understand.

I close my eyes, and I’m back in Aiden’s bed, Rose tucked against me while he launches himself on top of us, barking like a dog until she’s screaming with laughter.

His hair beneath my fingers.

His weight against me.

The happiness in his eyes.

Home.

I want it back.

All of it.

“I love them,” I whisper.

“I know,” Gabe murmurs into my hair, hand rubbing soothing circles into my back.

I put some space between us, looking up at him. His eyes are warm and soft on me. And suddenly I’m so over loving people silently because saying it out loud makes them feel easier to lose.

“And I love you. I’m sorry I never said it back before.”

His smile is proud and blinding and so perfect I feel my own mouth curve in response. The first smile since I left Aiden’s apartment that day.

“I know you do.” He brings my hand to his heart. “I feel it, and that’s more important than any words. I’ll always love you, C. You’re my best friend, and nothing could break that. Whatever happened with Abbie, we’ll figure it out,” he says easily. “And for what it’s worth, I bet this guy knows how you feel too. I’m sure if you two talk, you can work it out.”

I want to believe him so badly.

“I want to be happy,” I tell him. “I want to get him back. But Gabe, I really was horrible.”

He hums. “Sometimes we make mistakes, act out of fear, and do things we regret. But it’s what we do after that matters. How we can work on things going forward.”

“You really think so?” I ask hopefully.

Nodding, he looks unsure for a second, then says, “I want to tell you something. But I don’t want you to freak out or worry because I mean it when I say I’m okay. I’m doing really well.”

Pulse pounding, I say slowly, “Okay.”

He stares at me for a long second, searching. And whatever he finds on my face is enough for him to continue. “That day after Kyle came to the store, I was in a bad state. Seeing him triggered me, and I was spiraling. My thoughts turned so dark.” He takes a deep inhale. “The next morning, I left Noah in bed and went for a run. When I got to the lake, I was so overwhelmed. It was like every bit of fear and emotion I tried to push down for so long attacked me.”

My breathing turns shallow as he continues in a whisper, “I went in. Into the water. For a split second, I just wanted it all to stop. Then when I was in there, I panicked. Regret consumed me, because I didn’t want it all to stop. I wanted the hurt to stop. But I realized I wanted my life back. All those moments with you and Abbie. With my brother and niece. With Noah.” He lets out a disbelieving, wet laugh. “I almost walked away from so much love. Because I was scared of my past.”