Page 43
Something inside me broke open.
“I know it’s been a long time, and I have no real claim on you whatsoever. But when I’m around you, everything in me keeps telling me you’re mine.”
Fuck. I really hadn’t expected to say that.
Delaney stopped and faced me, expression incredulous. “You broke up with me.”
“I know that.” I jammed my hands in my jeans pockets. “I was trying to set you free. So you could—”
“Don’t you dare say you did that for me.” She poked me hard in the chest. Moonlight caught in the tears in her eyes. “Don’t repeat those lies. You didn’t let me go for some noble reason. You knew I’d be gone for months at a time at school, and you didn’t want to go without easy access to sex. I was just a convenient hole to fill.”
I reared back like she’d slapped my face. “How could you ever think that? I never treated you that way. I loved you.”
“Then why did you kiss her?” Delaney pointed at the distillery, the source of music and voices following us down the street. “You kissed Brenna. That night by the lake. Don’t deny it. I saw you.” A tear escaped and careened down her cheek. “I saw you with your mouth on her the same day you broke up with me.”
Damn. I’d figured she knew about that, but not that she’d seen. “I wish I could deny it.”
“Maybe you slept with her that night too.”
Shame flooded me.
Delaney stared at me, and what I was feeling must’ve been clear on my face, because a look of horrified shock marred her features.
“Oh my God,” she whispered. “You fucking asshole.”
“It was a mistake.”
Delaney wiped at her face. “It doesn’t matter. I don’t want to talk about any of this. You’re the one who forced it. Please just leave me be.”
She started down the sidewalk again, and I kept following a few paces behind.
Memories were twisting like a windstorm in my head.
Getting drunk by the lake that night because I was fucking devastated. I’d already regretted breaking things off with Delaney, even if I’d known it was for the best. I had stayed stoic in her art studio with her, but afterward, I’d been falling apart.
I’d wanted to go right back to Delaney’s place and beg her to take me back. But I couldn’t let myself do that. I couldn’t. Because it would’ve been selfish, tying her to me when she deserved so much more than she’d ever gotten in Wildrose.
“I didn’t know you saw anything,” I said. “I never knew. I never would’ve meant to hurt you that way.”
She kept walking like she couldn’t hear me, but the street was quiet now that we’d left the central business district. My voice carried plenty.
“I didn’t want Brenna. She was just there, and…” Okay, fuck, that sounded awful. “She could tell I was upset, and she came on to me.”
“Please don’t tell me this,” Delaney begged.
“But I need you to understand. In my messed-up head that night, I had to do something to break us all the way through. So I couldn’t run back to you and change my mind. You were supposed to go live your big, exciting life and forget about me. Even if there was no way I could ever forget about you.”
Her steps slowed, then stopped. “My big, exciting life. Not exactly how it turned out. Sorry I didn’t meet your grand expectations for me.”
A lance of pain shot through my stomach. I’d been trying to shove down the guilt and longing, the mess of things I didn’t want to feel, but that wasn’t working.
“That’s not what I meant. I was a stupid eighteen-year-old kid so deep in love he didn’t know how to handle it.”
“So in love that you slept with someone else?” Delaney looked at the line of the mountains against the night sky.
“I am so sorry.”
“I shouldn’t care anymore.”