Page 88
I’m ready to go fucking feral, ready to turn this entire house into a place nobody responsible for hurting him walks out of, and the urge is already crawling into my hands when Victor gives me the signal to wait. I manage to stay where I am even while every instinct in my body screams against the decision, furious at the restraint and even more furious that I’m expected to stand here looking at Matthew tied to a chair.
“I have nothing to be grateful to you for,” Matthew spits.
There’s no weakness in his voice, nothing to suggest that being here has frightened him into submission, and that defiance only feeds the rage already moving inside me because, even now, after everything they have done to him, they haven’t managed to make him cower.
Victor leads me farther into the room and shoves me forward for effect, and I let the force carry me, stumbling just right to make whatever performance we are putting on believable, while every part of my attention remains fixed on Matthew.
He doesn’t look at me. His eyes are moving around the room, to his father and the men around him and practically anywhere else they can land, but never once do they come in my direction. I don’t have the luxury of examining whether he can even stand to look at me after everything he learned tonight because I might lose the focus necessary to keep both of us alive.
Macaulay Senior lets out a harsh laugh that immediately shifts my attention to him.
“Oh, how the mighty have fallen,” he snarls. “I warned you of his charms, and you ignored it. But you can both continue whatever deviant desires you have in the afterlife.”
I allow myself to imagine exactly how easy killing him would be, how quickly I could get close to him if Victor gave me the signal, which part of him I would reach first and how little time everyone else in the room would have to react once I decided he was done breathing.
“Just do it already,” Matthew says. “You think I’ll beg you? I have nothing to live for anymore. Take me out of this misery.”
Whatever calm I found in imagining Macaulay dead disappears the second I hear those words. The pain that sears through my chest is nothing like I’ve felt before.
Nothing to live for.
The sentence lodges itself inside my head and refuses to leave, because he means it. But I will spend every day I have left giving him reasons to stay, reasons to wake up and keep going, reasons to understand that whatever this night has taken from him doesn’t get to take the rest of his life with it.
And if he needs to hate me while I do it, then he can hate me, just as he can curse me, fight me, refuse to forgive me, and spend years making me pay for every lie I told him—because I can live with every single one of those things as long as he’s alive to give them to me.
And if anyone standing in this room believes they’re going to take even that away from him, then they’re about to discover exactly how much violence I am willing to put between Matthew and Death.
Macaulay’s phone rings, and he checks the screen before leaving the room without a word, while I look toward Victor to see if this is finally the moment we move, but he gives the smallest shake of his head. Either time is actually moving slowly, or this situation has warped my sense of it, because it feels like Macaulay is gone for far longer than he really is before he returns to the living room.
He takes a gun from one of the men in black ski masks and walks to where Matthew is tied up. “You can keep your life if you shoot him,” he says, pointing at me.
I already know this is what he planned because Victor told me, so there is no shock in it for me, only the cold awareness that everything is moving exactly along the path we expected, but this is all new to Matthew.
“You’re sick,” he barks.
“I’m the sick one?” Macaulay fires back, his voice rising. “I tried to help you, Matthew, but you’ve decided this way of life is what you want. I got rid of the last man you were parading around, but you still didn’t learn your lesson. And then you were impudent enough to threaten me?”
“Oh my God, Matthew!” Marcus’s voice comes from the doorway, and every head in the room turns as he rushes to his brother. “What the fuck is happening here, Dad?”
Macaulay stiffens, and I watch the change happen across his face almost instantly, the brief surprise giving way to calculation as he realizes that his pride and joy is now standing in the middle of everything he has probably been trying to keep hidden, and whatever story he thought he controlled has suddenly become something he has to explain.
“It’s just a small misunderstanding,” Macaulay says, with such nonchalance that the former me would have admired the sheer fucking audacity of it. He gestures to the men in ski masks. “You can go inside. I’ll call when I need you.”
The eight men nod and leave.
“Just a misunderstanding?” Matthew shouts, lifting his head from his brother’s chest, his face twisted with fury and disbelief. “He sent someone to kill me.” His voice breaks, but he keeps going. “Our own father paid to have me murdered. And I-I . . .” He stutters, struggling to get the sentence out. “I’m so stupid, I fell in love with my killer.”
The venom in the last sentence makes me know, with such crippling certainty, that I have lost Matthew for good no matter what I say now. It doesn’t matter how many times I tell him that the mission stopped mattering long before he ever knew it existed. I don’t think there’s anything I could do that would make him look at me and see Anthony Benson again instead of the man who was sent to end his life.
I want to say something.
I want to plead my case, to tell him that I’ve walked away from every terrible thing I used to do. That I would keep walking until there was nothing left of that man if that’s what he needed from me.
I want to tell him that I would do anything he asked, take whatever punishment he decides I deserve, and spend as long as it took proving that what I feel for him is the only honest thing I have ever felt.
But my mouth refuses to work.
The words are there, trapped somewhere behind my teeth. I can’t force a single one out while a crushing pressure builds beneath my ribs and tightens around my chest until every breath I take feels shallow and my entire body aches with the effort of staying upright, leaving me unable to do anything but stand and watch Matthew look at me like I am the worst thing that ever happened to him.