AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Games We Play

Page 4

by Lyra Asher

When we were kids, those damned blue eyes fucked me over everytime she looked my way, and twenty years later they still had the same affect on me. The first second I locked my eyes with hers at only five years old, I knew I had found magic.

They were vivid and bright, framed by her black lashes, creating a contrast between the dark and light of her. Back then, green had been my favorite color; until I saw those glacial baby blues and my taste—my entire world—shifted under my feet.

Scarlett’s skin was still the deep shade of olivey-tan that I remembered, along with her pitch-black hair that she wore in loose waves down her back … and that dress.

Double fuck.

It was tight enough that it shaped her curvy silhouette, showcasing every dip and crevice, making my eyes wander across her form. The small golden horn necklace her grandmother had gifted her still hung from her neck, the weathered chain resting against her collarbones.

Scarlett was more than just beautiful, she was the kind of gorgeous that sucked the air out of the room whenever she entered. With her small roman nose, high cheekbones, and deep, lustrous skin, she was vaguely threatening in her allure, but also otherworldly. If you looked up the word ‘angel’ in the dictionary, Scarlett Antonia Alessandro’s photograph would be printed alongside it with a description of her fiery beauty—all that was missing was her golden halo.

This woman before me still looked like my Scar, but different.

I could still see the little girl that over-watered plants because she didn’t know when to stop giving. The one whose frown always marred her exquisite face, but still went out of her way to help others. The very same one whose small ear I’d tuck dandelions behind in an attempt to make her smile—but even that wouldn’t work sometimes. I’d have to resort to teasing just to get her out of her shell, because at least her lashing remarks were better than her sadness. Her face was so forlorn that she resembled a fallen angel.

An angel so damned sweet that she could make even the devil yearn for heaven.

Those blue eyes were still lit with that blazing fire, guarded and ever-watching as she took me in. They assessed me with fierce intelligence, studying my every move with sharp perception. It made my chest ache, the way she almost always waited for the other shoe to drop.

I’d only seen Scarlett cry a handful of times in my decades of knowing her, so I tried to hide my shock at seeing her like this. She still looked beautiful with her mascara-stained cheeks, wobbly chin, and reddened eyes.

My heart was pounding like a sledgehammer, chest straining as my fists began to curl. I fought the urge to reach out to her—I knew she wouldn’t accept my touch of help. Scarlett was strong yet dangerous in her way of independence. Even while falling apart at the seams, she kept her head held high, those crystalline eyes glaring at me like a love language just for me.

She knew what it was like to hit rock bottom, knew that state of mind by name, but she also knew how to get back up time and time again. How to scratch and claw her way up the tunnel and back into the light. Only she didn’t need help, didn’t need someone to save her. So my reaching out would only result in harsh words and cat-like scratches up my arm.

My heart continued to beat faster the longer we stared at one another and I didn’t know why I was nervous or why my palms were sweating. I knew that I would see her. I was attending her mother’s funeral, so that was a given. But finding myself alone in a church classroom with a disheveled Scarlett clutching a flask like a lifeline was the last encounter I expected.

My hands continued to ache to reach out, to touch that angelic, smeared face, but I knew her limits and my own. A muscle ticked in her jaw and for the flash of a second I thought I saw a crack in her armor, her gaze mirroring the longing in mine. But as quickly as it came, it left, replaced by the cold, hard mask she chose to hide behind.

So I settled for all that she would give me … an argument.

“Bullshit apology?” I lifted both eyebrows as she crossed her arms over her chest, pushing up her ample cleavage that I had to actively keep myself from looking at.

“Did I stutter?” Her hip jutted out next before she flicked up her hand and examined her polished onyx claws. That was her way of either ignoring or insulting me—most commonly the latter, judging by the way she studied them like they were more interesting than me.

Hot-blooded little Scarlett Alessandro.

Although she wasn’t so little anymore with her long, tanned legs and crimson smile. She had always been feisty in her childhood, but her wit and snark only grew as she played the callous hand she’d been dealt by fate.

By the time we got to high school, some would have considered her downright bitchy, but I always enjoyed her demeanor and witty remarks—especially that wicked grin that would light up her entire face right before she eviscerated your existence.

She was cutting yet sweet, incredibly intelligent, and dreadfully alluring. She had no qualms with saying what was on her mind, no hesitation in her voice when stating her direct opinions. Scarlett was a strong and guarded woman with an icy exterior, but underneath the Titanic-sized iceberg, I knew she was a big ball of mush.

My sweet angel would go out of her way to make anyone feel comfortable, to make them feel welcome, wanted. She could make you feel like you’re the center of her universe—unashamedly so. She was a bleeding heart for puppies and kittens and children, but wouldn’t hesitate to give me a dead arm for the last chicken nugget.

At our best, we were childhood friends, but at our worst, we were rivals that turned even the most menial of tasks into a competition.

Since we were old enough to talk, we had competed against one another in academics, sports, freaking pingpong at the rec center, and, well, anywhere else there could be a winner. She was a dedicated rival who always kept me on my toes, waiting for her next move. If it wasn’t for her lighting a fire under my ass in high school with her taunting, then I probably wouldn’t have gotten that scholarship to Princeton that ended up paving the way for my successful hockey career.

She also knew all of my childhood secrets … except for one.

That I have been madly in love with her since I was five years old.

Cobalt blue eyes—darkening from their usual icy shade as her temper rose—shot daggers my way while Scarlett waited impatiently for my response.

Smothering my smile, I shrugged my shoulders nonchalantly and gave a pointed look at the flask dangling in her hand. “Maybe you slurred …” Scarlett’s nostrils flared in fury at my accusation, but she was the one clutching it like a string of pearls.

I knew I shouldn’t be egging her on.