Page 135
“You must be Keaton?” She beams, rushing toward me, catching me off guard. She sticks out her hand as I scramble to my feet. “I’m Aria.”
I study her hand for half a second too long. Five perfect fingers with hot pink nail polish. There’s a freckle between her thumb and index finger.
Wrenlee clears her throat and pulls me out of my fixation.
Stop being weird, Keats, and take her hand.
“Hey, Aria,” I manage, sliding my much larger hand into hers, swallowing it whole.
She grips it tight, and it makes me proud.
“My dad says you’re a fireman. That’s so cool. I sat in a firetruck once.” Her face lights up. “How long are you visiting?” She turns to Wrenlee, wagging her brows. “Is he just a friend?”
She giggles when Wrenlee’s eyes go wide.
“Aria Grace,” Lucas says firmly.
She giggles harder. “What? Wrenlee needs a boyfriend.”
Wrenlee presses her lips together, stifling a laugh. “No, I don’t.”
Yes, she does.
“Get over here and show me what you’ve been working on for the past couple of weeks,” Wrenlee snaps, walking over to the piano.
Lucas doesn’t say a word, just holds his hand out for me. I take his hand. A silent understanding passes between us. And then we sit and watch.
“I learned this while you were gone.” Aria settles on the bench, placing her hands on the keys. She scoots to the edge so her foot is able to reach the pedal.
I can’t pry my eyes away from her. Not even for a second. Her small fingers glide over the keys with ease as she plays. No sheet music. No pauses. No mistakes. I recognize the melody, but I can’t name it. She plays with ease like Wrenlee used to when she was growing up. When I’d secretly watch from the hallway while Brody thought I was going to the bathroom.
She’s incredible.
And she’s my daughter.
This is harder than I ever imagined. How does Wrenlee do this? Heat burns behind my eyelids, and I blink hard, forcing it back, but the emotions coil around my throat, making it hard to breathe.
Wrenlee must sense my panic. She glances over, head tilting slightly, concern flickering across her face.
I quietly blow out a breath and push off the couch, careful not to draw attention. I need air. I slip out the back door as music notes continue playing. A summer storm has rolled in, dark clouds pressing low overhead. The air is thick with humidity. Thunder rumbles off in the distance.
I drag in a breath. Then another. It doesn’t touch the ache crushing my ribs. It’s one thing to find out I have a child. It’s another to have to accept that I’ll never have her. I thought I could do this.
The door opens behind me. I turn as Lucas steps out, closing it gently. He doesn’t say anything at first, just stares off at the darkening sky. Then his brown eyes meet mine.
We’ve met a handful of times in the past when their families would get together for reunions. Hell, he even bought Brody and me beer when we were sixteen one summer. Thought he was the coolest guy alive back then.
Who would have guessed that one day he’d be raising my child?
He shifts his weight, rubbing his jaw. “I know this isn’t—”
“Did you know she was mine?”
He shakes his head. “Well, not until her trial.”
Right. When I admitted that I had taken her virginity.
“When Wren was in prison, she wrote to us and told us you didn’t know.” He swallows hard. “And man, I’m sorry. This isn’t fair to you.” He exhales. “But she’s happy. She’s loved. Every single day.”