Page 72
I huff out a laugh. “They asked me to play ‘Jailhouse Rock,’ which was kind of funny because I learned it before I went to jail. My mom was not amused.” I play a quick, playful run of the song. “But that’s the day I knew I was going to be okay. After that, I spent the next three years teaching women to play.” I shift my attention back to him. “So, to answer your question, I didn’t miss it. It ended up being my lifeline.”
Our eyes stay locked for a few beats. I look away first and press down another key.
Focus on the music, not the man sitting next to you.
The man who will destroy you.
The man you’ll destroy back.
Keaton places his fingers on the keys like he’s about to mess around, but then he actually plays. My head snaps up. It’s an actual song. And it’s good.
Adele’s “Hello” fills the room. I don’t move or speak. I don’t want to interrupt him. The song isn’t complicated, built on repeating chords, but it’s not something a beginner could pull off either.
When he finishes, I nudge him with my shoulder. “You can play?”
His grin reaches his eyes as he playfully scoffs. “You’re not the only piano savant.”
“Oh, really?” I challenge with a lifted brow.
“Are you calling me out?”
“Play something else.”
“All right.” He claps once, laces his fingers and cracks his knuckles. Then he pauses, reaches up, and turns his hat backward.
Holy. Shit.
I didn’t think he could get sexier.
I was wrong. So, so, wrong.
“Are you ready for me to blow your socks off?” he muses.
I’m ready for…something.
The sexual thought has me popping off the bench, putting the couch between us. “Weren’t we about to eat?”
His eyes linger on me for a moment, and I wish I could figure out what he’s thinking. He’s difficult to read. I hope he has no idea what’s going on in my head.
“It’s ready whenever you are,” he says, sliding off the bench. He passes me, leaning in. “You’re just afraid of me showing you up.”
“Yep,” I say. “That’s it.”
More like, I’m afraid if he plays another song, I’m going to straddle him on the bench and ask him to play me instead.
I grab a plate and spoon a generous heap and a couple of pieces of buttered sourdough. The way I’m shoveling food into my mouth isn’t exactly graceful, but it’s solving two issues. I’m starving, and eating with Keaton feels too much like a date.
My phone dings, and I glance down. I’m surprised to see Londyn’s name.
Londyn: 9-1-1!!! I’m going to kill Georgia! She’s threatening to cancel the catering next week.
That’s not good.
“Boyfriend?”
The question catches me off guard.
When I glance up, Keaton’s leaning forward on his elbows, hat turned backward. It throws me back in time to high school—baseball games, warm spring nights, him in the dugout between innings, his eyes sweeping the stands—when steel-blue eyes would lock with mine. Time would still, and in that beat of a single heartbeat, it was only the two of us.