AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

300 Days of Christmas

Page 104

by Emily Wright

Sienna stood, the stool legs scraping the floor. “I’m not asking you to pretend it didn’t happen. I want you to try and understand.”

“Understand what? How you never chose me? How I was never good enough?” Eva scoffed. “Trust me, I understand that perfectly well.” She blew out a breath, gripping the counter as her head started to pound.

I definitely should have stopped drinking.

“That’s not true. None of it.” Sienna frowned and stepped closer. Eva turned her head away. She couldn’t look at her without those old familiar wounds aching. “In the café, you asked me if I had any idea what it felt like to lose me. But Eva, do you have any idea what it feels like to lose you?” Sienna’s voice broke on the last word.

And dammit, now Eva couldn’t not look at her. Those glassy eyes full of hurt. Those beautifully sculptured lips, which she’d spent so long trying to perfect in her art, wobbled as Sienna tried to compose herself.

“I was lonely. Zoey was lonely too,” she said, and Eva shook her head. But Sienna grasped her cheek, turning her towards her. “We kissed, and that was it. Both of us found it wrong. It was a drunken moment that got caught on camera, that’s all.”

A tear slipped down Eva’s face, and Sienna smoothed it with her thumb.

“We’ve both made mistakes, Eva. We’ve both dated other people and ripped out each other’s hearts, and after all these years, mine still belongs to you.” Sienna’s dark eyes looked deep into her own. “Who knows if we’ll have this chance again? If you still love me, I’m asking you to fight. Please.”

“I did fight.” Eva’s lip trembled, her heart cracking open, flowing into the exposed wound in her chest. “I tried so hard, and it was never enough. I don’t belong in your world, Sienna.”

“That’s bullshit. Stop telling yourself that.” Her head dropped, and she exhaled sharply. “I should’ve never asked you to be a secret. I should’ve told my parents sooner too—and listened to my gut when my life stopped feeling like my own. There was so much pressure, and I didn’t always handle it well.” Her eyes landed on hers, passion blazing in her irises. “I can handle a life without netball, but I don’t want to live my life without you. We still have something, Eva.” Sienna reached inside the collar of her jumper and fished out a gold necklace. She clutched the sun between her fingertips. “I don't care what anyone else says. You belong with me. You always have, and you always will.”

She still wore her necklace?

That completely undid Eva. The last resolve she had slid away, and a sob escaped her throat, her heart crushing. It was too much. Sienna, here, saying so many things she wanted to hear. But it was too late. She’d finally moved on, and now this?

She couldn’t think. Couldn’t breathe. She squeezed her eyes closed, drawing a shaky breath through her nose. “I can’t, Sienna.” Tears slipped down her face. “I lost you twice already. I can’t do it again. I’m finally doing better. I…” She pressed her fists to her eyelids, but it couldn’t stop the hurt spilling out.

“Come here.”

Eva blinked through her blurry vision. Against her better judgment, unable to fight the feeling, she stepped into her embrace. Sienna pulled her against her chest, and Eva collapsed, tightening her arms, imprinting the feel of her on her hands. She breathed in her warm scent, the thump of her heart beat against hers.

Home.

But she couldn’t make a home in Sienna, not when she was going to tear it down and bulldoze the rubble. What am I doing? She couldn’t repeat the same mistakes.

“You should go,” Eva muffled into her shoulder. She pulled back, fighting against Sienna’s arms, fighting against the natural inclination of her muscles. She hadn’t been ready to let go, but she didn’t trust herself.

Sienna rubbed a hand over her cheek, like she was caught between what to do. Then without saying a word, she turned, her footsteps echoing across the wooden floor. Eva’s chest fractured with every movement. Deepened with each boot Sienna slipped on. In the tie of her laces. The swish of her coat as she wrapped it around her shoulders.

This was it.

“If you change your mind,” Sienna said. “I’m getting the 9:25 morning train.”

Eva shook her head, barely able to see through her blurred eyes. “Goodbye, Sienna.”

[133]

Year 4

31st December

Eva blinked, unsure if she heard Sienna correctly. “What?”

“Come with me to Australia.”

The sound of the New Year’s Eve party echoed from inside, her dad murdering Elvis Presley’s ‘Love Me Tender’ on the karaoke machine. Sienna had taken Eva by the hand and led her out into the car park outside, and now she was making no sense.

“I can’t come with you, Sienna. Even if you meant that.”

Sienna squeezed her hand. “I do mean it.”