AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 14

by Ariana Kemp

“Oh, she’s confident,” Cohen laughed, that megawatt smile appearing for the second time since I had met him, and it was no less breathtaking. “I see you, baker girl. Let’s do this.”

My cheeks hurt from smiling as I tapped my fingers on the counter, thinking through my approach. I had to make these questions count.

“Favorite music genre?” I said slowly, my eyes narrowing as I watched him mull it over for a moment, slowly nodding to himself.

“I listen to a little of everything, but I pride myself on being a movie score buff,” he chuckled. “Most of the time, I have a movie soundtrack playing in the background while I work, or even while I’m at the gym. Drives my buddies nuts.”

Well, if that wasn’t adorable.

“Interesting,” I hummed. “Okay. That begs the question: movie or book?”

“Book before movie. I always have a worn paperback tucked in my truck or nightstand. I am a sucker for a solid movie adaptation, though. Case in point, Project Hail Mary.” He leaned his hip against the counter, grinning. “Last question, Winifred.”

I was having a hard time computing how rough and ruggedly handsome this stranger was, and yet he was kind and a bit nerdy too. Heck, he knew butterflies.

“How do you know so much about butterflies?” I settled on, already grabbing what I needed to make his drink. I was pretty sure I had his order locked down.

“I’m one of five kids,” he explained, his eyes lighting up at the mention of his family. “I have one older brother and three baby sisters. The youngest, Annie, is about ten years younger than me. So when I was fifteen, she was only five.” He smiled fondly to himself, shaking his head at some unseen memory. “She was obsessed with butterflies. Forget Barbies or playing house, she was always outside catching caterpillars and butterflies, trying to identify them. Since there was such an age gap between us, it was hard to connect with her like I did with my other siblings. Studying butterflies was an easy way to show that I cared about her. It became our thing.”

Cool, cool, cool.

So now he was handsome, nerdy, and he learned about butterflies for his baby sister.

How was this man real?

“That is adorable,” I hummed, putting a lid on his drink so he couldn’t see the contents. “I love that you intentionally put effort in to show her you loved her. Not a lot of older brothers would make time for that, especially at fifteen.”

“Our parents raised us well.” He eyed the drink on the counter, silently asking permission, and I pushed the beverage forward to him.

“I’ll be in town for a few days,” Cohen continued, his dimple prominently on display as his smile slowly grew. “What time does your shop open tomorrow? I think I’m going to need some more coffee and butterflies to get me through the week.”

A swarm of those said butterflies was set loose in my stomach.

“I open at seven and close at five,” I grinned. “I’ll have fresh coffee and a butterfly pop quiz waiting.”

“Game on.” He smirked, maintaining eye contact as he took a small sip of his drink, a bit of froth catching on the shadow of a mustache on his upper lip. His smirk grew into a full-blown smile, and he slowly shook his head.

“Café au lait,” he nodded, taking another sip. “Best I’ve ever had too. I really like the caramel notes in there. You’ve got my number, baker girl.”

The man had good taste. I didn’t even try to hide my delight at his compliment.

“I roast the beans in-house, and I try to come up with new flavors every month. Let’s try two for two.” I slid a small plate his way, and Cohen glanced down, immediately groaning and settling his hands on his hips. On his plate was a single sour cream donut, as plain as could be, but one of my most popular items that I sold out of daily. I had saved one for my drive home this evening, but two questions in, I knew in my gut this was his pastry. I didn’t understand why, but judging by his reaction, I’d hit the nail on the head.

“How did you know?” he asked incredulously. “I rarely eat sweets, except for a good sour cream or cake donut. I thought I had you for sure.”

I watched intently, waiting for him to take a bite.

When he did, his eyes widened, and he hummed in delight.

“Shoot, Winifred. What’s in this . . . cocaine?” He covered his mouth as he spoke, the polite action speaking to the manners his mama had drilled into him. His hand shot across the counter in a mirror to my awkward handshake offer from before. I laughed in surprise, this time dusting my hand off on my skirt and placing it in his.

“Bloody brilliant,” he said in a mock British accent, shaking my hand with that same gentle firmness as before. “Best doughnut this tent has seen yet.”

My laughs dissolved into giggles, Cohen’s laugh soon joining my own as he released my hand.

“I’m so sorry. That was awful,” he winced. “Must have been the drug donut.”

“You made my night,” I wheezed, wiping at a couple of stray tears. “That was awful.”