Page 33
“Winnie, are we celebrating, or am I making someone disappear?” Lettie’s voice took on an edge at my delayed response. She had stopped eating her toffee, instead staring intently at me as she lightly shuffled the treat in her hand, trying to keep the sugar from melting on her palm.
“No. No disappearing anyone,” I laughed. “Your loyalty is noted though.”
I paused what I was doing and legitimately thought about her question. What exactly was I feeling?
I had spent the past week talking to Cohen for nearly an hour each night at closing. Cohen insisted on helping wipe down tables as we played a game of twenty questions. Everything I learned about him only served to deepen my respect and attraction.
He loved peaches, but couldn’t stand nectarines. He was a good cook, but was utterly hopeless at baking. And most importantly, he had such a deeply personal relationship with God that flowed out into every area of his life.
I watched how kind he was to Bruno, how sweet he was with children that came into the shop, and how considerate he was to each person he met. He was intentional with every interaction we had, and something about that was refreshing. I never had to wonder where I stood or what he was thinking. In true Cohen fashion, he was an amazing communicator. It was such a stark difference to the few other men I had briefly dated, not a single one of them taking such initiative to get to know me.
So while we weren’t rushing into anything, I was well aware that both of us were mutually intrigued by one another.
My favorite part of the day had become my time in the evening with him. Whenever he walked into my bakery, his blue eyes sparkling and the dimple on his left cheek peeking out beneath his scruff, my stomach would do a little somersault.
“I like him,” I admitted softly, the words feeling strange out loud. When had I ever honestly uttered those words about a man? “He’s kind, loves God, and he knows butterflies, Lettie.”
Lettie raised an eyebrow.
“But?” she pressed.
I chuckled, stamping another box and setting it aside.
“But, I don’t know if I’m really looking for a relationship.” I shrugged, avoiding her gaze. “He’s a great guy. I just don’t think it’s fair to drag someone into my mess—”
Thwap.
“What was . . . Did you just throw toffee at me?” I sputtered. “Lettie!”
“Sorry, you were just being ridiculous. I couldn’t help myself.” She shrugged, flashing me a small smirk. “In all seriousness, though, he seems like a good dude. Don’t shut this down because you’re scared.”
“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” I mumbled, fiddling with a tab on one of the boxes.
Lettie rolled her eyes, tossing another nugget of toffee in her mouth.
“Yeah, okay,” she said as she waved me off. “Listen, all I’m saying is, you’re a solid girl, he’s a solid guy, and you’ve been praying for a break all this time. You’re always saying that ‘every perfect gift is from God’ and all that jazz. God sends you what you asked for and you’re going to try and ‘return to sender’ him?”
That stopped me in my tracks. Because I had been sharing my faith with Lettie for years now, and while I felt proud that something I had said stuck, I was also deeply convicted. Because how was she quoting the Bible back to me when I should be the one looking to it myself for answers.
My eyes drifted over to the soft pink scrap of paper taped on the counter next to my register.
Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom there is no variation or shadow due to change.
Maggie had left that specific verse in my tip jar just a couple of weeks before she passed. She’d known I was having a hard week missing my parents, and she stopped in to pray with me.
It had been a while since someone had prayed with me.
Until Cohen.
“Okay, fair point,” I finally conceded, but looked at her suspiciously. “But this coming from the woman who has quite literally sworn off men. Who will jump down a man’s throat if they even have the audacity to say hi? And you’re telling me that this man I’ve known for a week is a ‘solid dude.’ How would you know?”
I happened to agree that Cohen was solid, but something here felt off.
“He’s been by my bar quite a bit. I’ve been talking to him. Observing.” She shrugged nonchalantly. “He checks out.”
“He checks out? Lettie, what did you say to him?” I gaped, my face burning with embarrassment.
“Calm down. I just asked some basic questions and carded him to make sure he is who he says he is,” Lettie laughed, her smile only widening when she saw my horrified face.