AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 40

by Ariana Kemp

“Caesar wrap, please,” I breathed, blinking a couple of times before quickly turning away from him to try and hide the pesky tears that were pricking my eyes. “Thank you, Cohen.”

It was a wrap. A measly wrap and yet my tenuous grip on my emotions slipped. I refused to give in to the urge to cry, staring at a small butterfly doodle on the wall, as I battled it back.

“Happy to help,” he murmured, and I could see him out of the corner of my eye, straightening up to his full height and grabbing the light lavender box and treat bag I had given him.

“Can you flip the sign to ‘closed’ on your way out?” I asked, my blasted voice quivering. “I’m going to take my lunch real quick.”

Silence. More silence. More wretched silence.

I turned to glance at Cohen who was watching me, his lips tugged down in a small frown.

“Please, Cohen,” I said once more, well aware that I was pleading.

He nodded though he didn’t make any move to leave yet. Instead, he took one step closer, his head dipping down to meet my eyes, even as I took a tentative step back.

“Thank you for letting me take care of you,” he murmured softly, his voice a smooth rasp that washed over me, but his words felt like an attack. “I enjoy doing things for you. It makes me genuinely happy, and I don’t expect anything in return.” He offered me a small smile, rapping on the counter twice in his signature goodbye. “I’ll see you tonight, baker girl.” With that, he turned on his heel and left, flipping the sign to closed as he did.

And then there was silence. Too much silence.

10

COHEN

“Well, I can see why you’re taken with her.” Adler grinned, reclining back against what was quickly becoming a familiar booth to me. “She’s sweet.”

He quickly held up his hands in surrender when I eyed him with mock seriousness. I knew without a doubt that he would never do anything to jeopardize my relationship with Winnie—that wasn’t Adler.

“Don’t you worry another hair on your graying head,” he teased, dodging when I chucked a fry at him. “Besides, I’ve got my eye on someone else.” His gaze tracked across the room, settling on Lettie making a drink behind the bar.

Huh.

“She’s good at reading people,” Shepherd grunted, bringing my attention back to the other men at the table. “Don’t get that way without a reason.”

I’d actually been thinking through that myself the past few days. Winnie was perceptive, and she seemed to be constantly watching those around her and understanding minute details about who they were and what they needed.

On the flip side though, she was scary good at masking her own feelings. Every now and then I would catch her staring off with an indecipherable look, but as soon as I caught her attention, she would genuinely smile again, any traces of the previous emotion erased.

I wasn’t sure what to make of it.

“I’ve told you about her parents.” I popped a fry in my mouth, thoughtfully chewing. “My guess is she got really good at reading her parents’ moods and adjusting to keep the peace. Would make sense with how unstable her father was.”

The men hummed in agreement.

“I imagine she was the glue that held their home together, always taking care of her mom and dad,” I continued. “Then they passed and now she takes care of everything and everyone on her own.” Old habits die hard.

“She seems like a gentle soul,” Adler offered, taking a sip of his water. “You’re good for her—for each other. You could use some taking care of too, you stubborn lug.”

“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” I chuckled, both Shepherd and Adler leveling deadpanned stares at me.

“I’ve tried countless times to help you with this property search, and it’s like talking to a fence post.” Adler pointed an onion ring at me, his eyes sharp as ever. “We all want to help. Jonny was our friend too—and you’re hogging all the work.”

Guilt settled heavy on my shoulders in a familiar weighted vest of responsibility. Taking care of all of this felt like the one thing I could control, the one thing that drowned out that quiet voice in the back of my mind whispering I should have done more to help Jonny.

“Let us help, Chaos,” Shepherd rumbled quietly, settling his elbows on the table and clasping his hands together. “This isn’t all on you—never was.”

I nodded, not quite ready to verbally acquiesce.

“How was Declan when you all handed in your notice at the same time?” I asked.