AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 65

by Ariana Kemp

As their voices faded and the storefront grew quiet again, my skin instantly started crawling. I rubbed my hands up and down my arms to try and banish the sensation, but it did nothing to relieve the itch.

I glanced at the clock, and my heart sank. It was only eleven o’clock—I still had a whole day ahead of me.

I stared at the door and willed someone to walk through it so I wouldn’t be left with the wretched silence anymore, but I had no such luck.

It was going to be a long day.

“Tis so sweet to trust in Jesus,

Just to take Him at His Word;

Just to rest upon His promise,

Just to know, “Thus saith the Lord.”

Shepherd’s voice carried through the courtyard, his rough timbre blending effortlessly with the chirping crickets and crackling fire. His fingers picked the soft melody on his guitar, his eyes fixed on the flames ahead of him. Carl and Stryker lay at his feet, Mable nestled right alongside them. The lab had found a second home trailing after the quiet man and his dogs. With everything going on lately, I hardly saw her outside of bedtime.

I leaned farther back into Cohen’s legs from where I sat in the dirt in front of him, enjoying the lazy path his fingers traced along my upper back. I turned the stick I was roasting my marshmallow on, letting the hymn’s words sink in as Shepherd continued.

“Jesus, Jesus, how I trust Him.

How I’ve proved Him o’er and o’er;

Jesus, Jesus, precious Jesus.

Oh, for grace to trust Him more.”

I pulled my hoodie’s sleeve over my hand as the heat of the fire became unbearably warm, my marshmallow only halfway to golden perfection.

Dinner with everyone had been so restorative—healing even. The last time I had dinner at the table was when my parents were still alive. And even then, it was tense and filled with awkward silences and outbursts.

Sitting around that same table, saying grace as we held hands, and then having a meal filled with laughter and warmth, soothed a part of my heart that had ached for a long time. Even Lettie had hung around to roast marshmallows and listen to Shepherd sing hymns.

As we sat next to the fire, I did my best to fight back the raging anxiety bubbling underneath my skin. Any time the sun set, everything just felt bigger and scarier. My fear thrived in the dark, always lurking at the corners of my mind, waiting for night to come.

I tried my best to remember a verse to combat that feeling, any passage to tether me to reality.

God was good.

He loved me.

He wanted what’s best for me.

And even knowing all of those things, for the first time since I had given my life to Christ, I didn’t trust him, and that was terrifying.

A careful hand slipped beneath my hair and settled on the nape of my neck, squeezing gently. I looked up behind me to see Cohen, his concerned gaze trained on me and head tilted in question.

“Okay?” he asked softly, thumb brushing small circles along the side of my neck.

“Yeah.” I forced a smile. “Why?”

“Your marshmallow.” He nodded to the fire, turning my attention to where my stick was still in the fire, marshmallow burnt to a crisp.

“Oh.” I swallowed, pulling my stick out to rest against a rock. “I was just lost in thought. I didn’t know Shepherd could sing like this. It’s beautiful.”

The lie tasted bad in my mouth even as I said it.

What’s worse was the way Cohen frowned, obviously not believing me. I offered him what I hoped was a convincing smile and turned around, focusing on that steady hand resting on the back of my neck, grounding me.