Page 73
He opens the oven and reaches in for a sheet of soft white pillows, only stopping when I yell out “Sky, no” and grab his hand. I hand him an oven mitt, and he gives me the softest, sweetest smile before removing the hot sheet pan with his hand protected. I stop the blaring alarm and he gives me a dopey smile of gratitude.
He’s thrilled with the pillows he pulled from the oven. “Perfection!”
“What do you have there?”
“Meringues! They are nice and fluffy, almost as perfect as you, Becks.”
“Oh my, yes, they look, erm, quite fluffy and very white?” I’m unsure how to best compliment a meringue.
“Yes, thank the heavens Hailey is a genius and sent a hand mixer. I don’t have the fortitude to whisk meringue, mash potatoes, and whip cream by hand.”
“You said we were having a quiet Christmas with the American delicacy of peanut butter and strawberry jam. You said crunchy Jif is the one acceptable peanut butter. Jif and jam you said.”
“I lied. While Jif and strawberry jam is a delicacy, that’s not what we’re having.”
He waves at the mess on the island with flair. “What you have here are the makings of a proper British Happy Christmas, Becks.” He points at each pile of mess on the island. “Meringues for Eton Chaos as my gran calls it but probably Eton Mess to you, future mince pies, sponge for trifle, Brussel sprouts with bacon or lardons, whatever you want to call them—stop snitching, Becks!” His wooden spoon makes a soft thwack against my skin as he warns me off the crispy pieces of meat.
“Your family Christmas menu and for me, my mom’s homemade mandarin orange cranberry sauce with pecans, and pretzel biscuits with butter and strawberry jam. Uh, sorry about the dough in your hair, but I promise these biscuits will be worth it.” He points at the pretzel biscuits and I steal one, slather it with butter, and wolf it down while he puts another pan of them in the oven. He turns to the stove to stir something and I steal a second one.
“I don’t understand. Why so much effort for just the two of us?” I’m not complaining, it sounds delicious.
“You told me about your best Christmas, and this is everything you said you ate, except Yorkshire Pudding.” He grabs his FedEx envelope from the corner of the island and pulls out a sheaf of paper. “Hailey says ‘I found out the oil had to be smoking hot to make proper Yorkshire Pudding. Knowing you are hours from a proper burn center, I elected to omit the Yorkshire Pudding ingredients and recipe from your order. Instead I wish you both joy and good lubrication. I hope you have a magical Christmas. I’ve tried to approach this from the perspective of someone trying to make a gourmet meal while camping in a tent, but Catherine assures me that it’s not that bad.’”
He looks up from the letter. “Sadly, I don’t have an entertaining puke story that rises to the level of Mr. Hopplet, but I could make something up. Or steal the one from The Goonies.”
“Hailey, your assistant at work? She did this?” What does she have to do with this unhinged mountain of food?
“Yes, she sent the recipes and put together the grocery list for the hanger people.” He waves the sheaf of papers from the FedEx envelope.
“Still confused.”
Sky smiles. “There isn’t much in the way of Christmas shopping here on Gould Lake and I wanted to make it special for you. I used the satellite phone to enlist an elf for some Christmas magic.”
“You decided to recreate my favorite Christmas?” I must have a tone. He loses his cheerful bounce as though I’m disappointed or angry. He couldn’t be more wrong.
“I thought you might like it… I didn’t mean to overstep.” He moves toward the stove, as though he’s trying to not let me see all of the pots and pans bubbling and simmering. I step closer to him.
“Sky, did you get groceries delivered to the middle of the Canadian wilderness by seaplane so that you could recreate a meal that took a full staff of professional cooks to make when I was a child?”
“When you say it like that it sounds weird,” he says, and starts to wipe off the stove.
“Schuyler, this was the best Christmas I’ve ever had the second I woke up, when I thought I was having peanut butter and jam.”
“You can still have that if you like.” He’s trying to shrink away, as if he wants to make himself small. Less. I need to make him understand.
I sag onto my assigned stool, the one that keeps me as close to him as possible without being in his way when he’s cooking for us. “No one, and I mean that, no one has ever done something like this for me.”
“I still haven’t, so don’t get too excited, there is a real possibility of burning it and I can’t run out for more ingredients. I hope Hailey sent good recipes.”
He’s not making eye contact with me as he scrambles to tidy up.
“You don’t understand. No one has ever taken the time.” I mean, our staff—many of whom are practically family—have certainly put on some amazing meals for my birthdays, but to cook it themselves because they like me? No one.
“As someone who has never had a partner acknowledge my birthday and or Valentine’s Day, I wanted to do better for you. Merry Christmas, Becks. You’re worth a thousand Christmas meals. But I know this is a lot. Too much.”
He’s not too much. I’d like to horsewhip the people who told him that. Everything about him is just right, from the way he takes my hand to how he takes care of me.
“I love every morsel of it,” I say, and hope he’ll hear my sincerity. “Every bit, Schuyler.”