AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Never Kiss A Grinch At Christmas

Page 41

by J.S. Cooper

“Oh, this is my girlfriend, Arabella. It’s nice to meet you.”

“Hi, I go by Penny or Penelope,” Penny says with a warm smile as she looks over at me. Her eyes narrow as she stares at me for a moment and then looks over toward Erin. “You guys are the cutest couple. Sooo cute. I was telling David that if I didn’t want us to win, I’d want you two to win because you’re just so gosh-darn adorable.” She pauses. “Don’t let Erin hear me say that though. She’s my bestie and would be so jealous.”

“Thanks,” I say, trying not to gag. “And you guys look picture-perfect.” Which is true, even though I didn’t want to say anything nice to a friend of Erin’s.

“Oh, everyone says that. It’s like we were meant to be, but I guess when you’re the co-captain of the high-school cheerleading team and your boyfriend is the quarterback of the team—the football team, of course”—she giggles—“then everyone just expects you to get together. And, well, we fell in love in tenth grade, and we’ve been together ever since.” I kinda remember them, but they hadn’t been that memorable back in the day.

“Yeah, it’s kind of like TV shows and movies are made about us,” David says.

I try not to roll my eyes. This shit cannot be for real.

And then it dawns on me that David is the David who was best friends with Evan in high school. The David who tried to convince me that if I loved Evan, I would blow him under the bleachers. I clench my hands and take a deep breath, ready to go off on him. And then I remember Penny, the co-captain of the cheer team, and I try not to roll my eyes. She and Erin were definitely cut from the same cloth.

Steele looks at me, studies my face, leans over, and pinches my butt. I stare at him, and he chuckles as he pulls me into him and unclenches my fist.

“I have to admit that Arabella and I have a kind of different story. She certainly wasn’t a cheerleader, even though I did play football, but we still enjoy being together, even if we did come together originally because Arabella was so horny for me.”

“What’s that?” I swallow hard as Steele winks at me.

I see David’s eyes widen, and Penny laughs.

“Well, I shouldn’t be saying this. I mean, not here and right now,” Penny says. “But David and I, we like to partake in fun events that may or may not include other couples.”

Steele and I both freeze and share a secret what-the-hell smile.

“I’m not sure I know what you’re saying,” I say.

Penny licks her lips. “Well, we’re in cabin number nine, if the mood so takes you to come over. You know there’s a hot tub here. I’ve heard it fits six people, but that just means it’s got plenty of room for four.”

“Yeah, I don’t⁠—”

“Well, thank you for inviting us,” Steele says as he wraps his arms around my waist. “My darling here is very jealous, and she doesn’t like to share. And to be quite frank, I don’t like to share her either. Our loving is just too good, isn’t it, hon?”

“Yeah, our loving is all night long. We don’t have any energy to bring anyone else into the bedroom.”

“Pity.” Penny looks over at Steele and shakes her head. “It sure would’ve been nice to have two football players at one time.”

My jaw drops, and Steele laughs.

“Well, you guys, good luck with the snowman contest.”

“You too.”

Steele grabs my hand, and we walk off to the side.

“Oh my gosh, did they just ask us to swing with them?” I stare at him, and his eyes are laughing as he looks at me.

“I guess that gives a new meaning to Christmas fun.”

“It’s disgusting. This is a challenge for couples. Are they serious? I should report them. I should⁠—”

“I think we’re the last people who should be acting holier than thou, darling,” he says, giving me a look. “We don’t want to bring undue attention to ourselves, seeing as we’re not exactly here for the most legitimate of reasons.”

I nod slowly. “Still, that’s insane. How is she going to invite us to be in a threesome when we’re here, trying to win the best couple of the⁠—”

“Honey, firstly, I think it was a foursome,” he says, grabbing me by the waist and pulling me into him. “And secondly, we need to play it cool. And honestly, if they’re propositioning other people, it means they’re not going to be much competition for us. We need to focus on being the best we can be.”

“I just think that’s absolutely ridiculous. If we were really together and she was propositioning you, I would slap her face.”