AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Never Kiss A Grinch At Christmas

Page 46

by J.S. Cooper

I don’t say anything because I don’t want to embarrass Arabella, but this is definitely a conversation I need to have with her later.

“Oh, by the way, Arabella, I wanted to know if you’re going to have a plus-one for the wedding because, of course, Evan and I are going to invite you. I mean, we did go to high school together, and you did date each other for a little bit of time, even though he hurt you and even though you kind of embarrassed him when you sent that video of yourself kissing Jacob’s photo.” Erin looks at me with wide eyes. “But you might not know that story, hottie?”

I stare back at her because I very much know the story, but I’m not going to say anything to her.

“You know what, Erin?” Arabella’s tone lowers. “I think …”

“You think what? How sad were you in high school that you had to take a photo of Jacob from the yearbook, who admittedly was very handsome? I mean, he was on the football team and the tennis team, but to be caught kissing him and telling him you love him … oh, how embarrassing.” Erin looks at me. “I’m just so glad she has a real man now so that she doesn’t have to do silly stunts like that anymore.”

I stare at Erin, and then I look at Arabella. Her eyes flash at me, and I can tell she wants me to be quiet. And I try to be. I really do.

“Erin, I know you might still be stuck in high school, but Arabella has me now, and I think I’m on her mind a lot more than any random boy is.” I stroke the side of Arabella’s face, and I can see that she’s gobsmacked by my words.

The thing is, I’ve been in Arabella’s life since she was young. I was around when all the drama in high school happened, and the rumors started, and everyone made fun of her, saying she was a loser who couldn’t get a man and was so desperately in love with Jacob. But I also know the truth because she told Garrett that Erin was the one who had dared her to do the prank in the first place. And even though Arabella was never able to prove it, she was pretty confident that Erin was the one who had shared the video as well. Erin is a nasty piece of work, but for some reason, Arabella has never wanted to expose the full truth. I still don’t know why.

Evan runs his fingers through his hair, and I see him studying Arabella’s face and then her tight sweater. His eyes linger a little too long on her breasts, and I frown as I realize he’s not staring at her in pity or feeling uncomfortable for being there. He’s checking her out. I grit my teeth and place my hand on her lower back.

“So, Evan, what do you do these days?” I say, stepping in front of Arabella when he seems to be coming closer to her.

She steps back and grabs my arm. “Excuse me. I was right there.”

“Sorry,” I say. I pause as she pinches my arm. “You know, I’m sorry, Erin, Evan. Arabella and I have some things to do. We need to get our sweaters for the ugly sweater contest, and then we’re going to get our outfits for the inaugural dinner. So, congratulations on your second-place win. Your snowman was worthy.” I smile cordially at both of them.

When they go low, you go high. That’s what my dad always says, even though it’s killing me.

“Oh, yes, the ugly sweater contest. That shouldn’t be so hard for you, right, Arabella? I feel like you could wear what you have on right now.” Erin juts her chin out.

And for the first time, I realize that even though she has a beautiful facade, she’s ugly—really, really ugly. And as I see the flash of hurt in Arabella’s eyes, I realize just how much this is affecting her, and I so badly want to protect her. I so badly want to tell Erin off, but I know I can’t do that properly. Not if I want to win.

“You have a good afternoon,” I say and quickly pull Arabella away from Evan and Erin.

Arabella looks up at me but says nothing as we make our way to the car.

“You okay?” I ask her softly.

“Yeah. Why wouldn’t I be?” She licks her lips and stares over her shoulder, her eyes narrowed. “She’s such a bitch. I just hate her so much.”

“I know.”

“I totally wasn’t making out with a picture of Jacob because I wanted him.”

“I know,” I say.

“You do?” She stops dead and looks at me in surprise. “Wait, how?”

“Did you forget I’m Garrett’s best friend? That I was at your house all the time? That was a really big thing in your life at the time. And remember, Garrett wanted to go to school and beat up Jacob?”

“Oh yeah.” She laughs. “I forgot about that. He wasn’t even involved. It was Erin. She was the one who dared me to do it. I just did it for fun. I didn’t even know she was videoing it. I can’t believe she got away with it. I can’t believe she even brought that up again. She has to know I know she was involved, and yet she so blatantly wants to put it in my face. She wanted to embarrass me in front of you.”

“I know,” I say. “But you notice I didn’t care. You notice I didn’t question her?”

“Yeah, I guess you make a good boyfriend after all.”

“I guess I do.”

We get into the car and drive in companionable silence down to Main Street.

“You want to pop in and say hello to Lucy and see how the café is doing or go straight to the thrift store?” I ask her as I park.