AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Eggnog & End Zones

Page 102

by Lisa Suzanne

“So you’re the boyfriend,” her dad says, eyeing me carefully even though we literally met at the door like fifteen minutes ago.

I exchange a glance with Addy, and we both smile at the terminology we haven’t even used yet. “That’s me.” I toss my arm around her, and her father narrows his eyes.

“I realize you’re bigger and stronger than me since you’re an NFL star, so I’ll save the whole if you hurt her, you better watch your back spiel. But, you know, don’t hurt her,” he says.

“Oh, Scott,” her mom says, smacking him lightly in the chest with the back of her knuckles. She pulls me into a hug. “Ignore him. He’s just peacocking. We’re so happy to have you here for the holidays, Clay.”

I have no idea what peacocking means, but I nod and smile. “Thank you for having me. It’s a pleasure to meet you.” And then, because I’m hoping they’ll be the welcoming kind of midwestern family I think they are, I ask, “Are there any hotels close by?”

“Oh, nonsense, Clay. You’ll stay here with Addy. Just no funny business, you hear me?” Kathy says, and Addy turns tomato red since funny business has already been done…and will likely happen again if I have anything to say about it.

Truthfully, there’s nothing funny about what just happened.

But we’re both adults, and I’m sure her parents understand that. They did produce three of their own children, after all.

“So how do you think you’ll fare when you face my Packers in the playoffs?” Scott asks, and we launch into a conversation about how the Storm is definitely going to kick the Packers straight in the ass.

Kathy fawns over us, making hot cocoa and cutting the yule log as she makes a fresh batch of gingerbread cookies—apparently my girlfriend’s favorite, which I could’ve guessed since she made them for her students. She starts up a Christmas carol with just her voice, and everyone else joins in, so I do, too.

I’ve never sang in front of anybody, but if everyone else is doing it, my voice is just one more in the chorus. It feels like the start of a new tradition, and it feels like Christmas here with the snow falling outside—which I had a hell of a time navigating, by the way, to get here from the little airport just ten minutes down the road.

Bree won’t stop staring at me, but all in all, it feels like home here, as if I fit in here just as well as she fit in with my family. And that’s what it’s all about, isn’t it?

I grab my duffel from the rental car and haul it up to Addy’s room, and I return with the bottle I picked up on my way.

“Eggnog!” I say cheerfully. The stuff tastes like shit, but it’s tradition. “Do you have any brandy?”

Kathy makes a face like she might gag just at the sight of it, and Scott looks at me with horror all over his face.

“Eggnog?” Scott asks. “It’s a wonderful gesture, Clay, but everyone in this house hates the stuff. You’re welcome to it, though.”

Leave it to Mr. Larson to tell it like it is.

I glance over at Addy. “Wait…everyone in the house hates it?”

She has a horrible poker face as her eyes dart over to her dad. “Well, yeah. Kinda.”

“But you drank it! At my parents’ house, you had a whole glass!” I say.

She shakes her head and wrinkles her nose. “Honestly, Clay, I pretended to drink it and dumped it down the sink.”

I start to laugh. “I dumped mine down the sink, too!”

She freezes and her jaw slackens. “Shut up. You did not.”

“I did! I hate it, too, but my parents insist it’s tradition. I thought it was a tradition for everyone!”

She starts to laugh, and I join in along with the rest of her family. I dump the contents of the bottle down the drain, and then her mom brings over a batch of gingerbread cookies that’s cool enough to decorate.

I pick up one of the bottles of icing—the grocery store kind, not the royal icing Addy made at my place when we decorated gingerbread cookies for her students.

I already know what I want to say. I should have said it earlier when we were talking, but I couldn’t find the right time. Somehow, it feels more meaningful to do it this way.

I decorate my gingerbread man, giving it a smiley face first. And then, I write the words.

I push the cookie over toward Addison, and she glances at it…and then she drops the cookie she’s decorating. Her eyes connect with mine, and hers are wide.

“I love you,” I say softly.