AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Yule Be Hearing From My Lawyer

Page 1

by Caroline Frank

ONE

MARISOL

The absolute worst part about Alex Whitlock is not that he’s in this meeting. It’s that, even when there’s a small snowstorm going on outside, he’s still the first thing I notice when I walk into the conference room this morning.

The snow started at seven-thirty A.M.—at least that’s what I’m told over small talk at the beginning of the meeting. It comes in sideways off the Hudson, throwing itself at the conference room windows like it has a score to settle against every person working in the building, but I barely acknowledge it, too frustrated by his presence.

I try not to let myself get wrapped up in him the way I always do. Focus on my surroundings as if I were nearing a full-blown panic attack, noting how the whole eleventh floor of the New York Immigrant Justice Center smells like burnt coffee and stale donuts.

I hold onto the scent—it’s comforting, in a way. It’s a reminder of hard work, early mornings and late nights, and winning.

Someone’s hung a wreath on the door to the supply closet, put up tinsel garlands in the kitchen, and tied paper snowflake chandeliers from every smoke detector in the office. The last one is so obviously a fire code violation, but, if I’m being honest, sort of charming, too. It makes the fact that it’s December and I have a hearing calendar the length of my arm slightly better.

Marginally.

It’s hard to feel the holiday spirit when I’ve been working my butt off on a rough case, but then I remember our organization gets to be the light at the end of the tunnel for so many seemingly hopeless cases, so I smile in spite of it all. It’s difficult but fulfilling work, and I wouldn’t have it any other way.

I have my binder open in the meeting, while I pore over every single document and page of notes I have on it. There’s no denying the secret dopamine rush I get every time I look at it—it’s impeccably organized. I’ve color-coded it to perfection, adding tabs to separate each section to make finding information that much faster. Blue is procedural history. Green is the lease. Yellow is all contact information. And red is everything the new owner has done since he took possession of the Ninety-Second Street property in Jackson Heights, including turning off the boiler.

The whole organizational process took like forty minutes, but I’d die for this binder.

And just like that, my heart rate has gone down.

God, I love organization.

“He says the boiler failed,” Constance is saying from the head of the table. “Which is an interesting thing for a boiler to do on the exact morning the deed was recorded.”

Constance Sodokoff has run this organization for nine years and has the specific kind of calm that comes from already having seen the worst version of every story. Her silver hair is pulled back into a tight bun, her reading glasses balancing precariously on the tip of her nose. Though not intimidating at first glance, my boss has a way of making the most experienced lawyers tremble in the courtroom and the negotiation table. After years of hardcore litigation, the NYIJC was founded as her passion project.

“Eleven families,” she continues. “All rent-stabilized, all there over a decade. The Duartes are the anchor. Yesenia Duarte, her mother, and her daughter. Fourteen years in that apartment. Her husband signed the original lease in 2012, and he passed in 2019. And now the new owner’s position is that because the husband’s name is misspelled on the lease—one letter, a z for an s—the lease was never valid, the succession never happened, and everyone in the building is a licensee who can be removed on ten days’ notice.”

All because the initial document said Alfonzo instead of Alfonso.

I shake my head in disappointment over the general greed of mankind. I swear this world sucks sometimes.

“That’s not a position,” I say. “That’s a typo with a lawyer.”

Across the table, somebody laughs, and I don’t have to look up from my perfect binder to know who it is.

I look anyway, though. I always look. I can never help myself, and that’s the problem. It’s been the problem for seven years. And for reasons I don’t even want to think about, it has gotten immeasurably worse since last December.

Alex Whitlock is sitting across from me with his chair tipped back on two legs like some teenager in detention, his Oxford shirt untucked—again. His dark hair—which, from what I can tell, he must cut himself once every couple of months in a dark room with no mirror—has grown out past his ears again. It’s infuriating how disastrous and adorable he can look at the same time. I hate it. In his left hand, he holds a legal pad with nothing written on it, as per usual. Alex never writes anything down yet always seems to remember every minute detail of every conversation we have ever had. That might be the single most infuriating fact about him, and I have a ranked list.

“Santana’s right,” he says, which is a sentence I’ve heard him say maybe four times in my life, and every single one of them was a trap of some kind. Or at the very least laced with sarcasm. “It’s a typo with a lawyer. Which means the lawyer’s going to be fast, and the typo’s going to be in every filing. So the question is how many typos we want to fight at once.”

“One,” I say. “We fight the one. We file an Order to Show Cause on the Duartes by Wednesday, we get the New York City Housing Preservation and Development complaint on the boiler tomorrow, get a judge to look at an eighty-one-year-old woman on an oxygen tank in an apartment with no heat, and we let the other ten families ride the Duarte ruling.”

“Or,” Alex says.

“There’s no or,” I say, steeling myself for what’s about to turn into an argument.

“There’s always an or.” He lets the chair drop forward onto four legs and straightens in his seat, finally sitting like an adult. “Or we take the week. We go out there, we sit in eleven kitchens, we get eleven affidavits, we file one consolidated answer with eleven signatures on it, and when the judge sees it, she’s not gonna be looking at one family with a tough situation. She’s gonna be looking at a landlord who bought a building and tried to empty it before Christmas. That’s not a typo. It’s a pattern. And judges hate patterns.”

“Judges hate late filings even more,” I say.

“It’s not going to be late if the hearing’s on the twenty-second, Santana,” he tells me, practically rolling his eyes.

“It’s on the twenty-second of December, Whitlock. Do you know what a courthouse looks like the week before Christmas? Half the clerks are out, the other half are angry they even have to work, and if we walk in with a stack of eleven affidavits and a story, we’re getting adjourned into January while the boiler remains unaddressed. The tenants will be frozen to death by then.”