AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Yule Be Hearing From My Lawyer

Page 20

by Caroline Frank

I don’t let go of his hand.

Behind her desk, Constance takes off her glasses and looks out at the harbor with the expression of a woman who has already seen the end of this story and is just waiting for the two of us to catch up.

NINE

MARISOL

Every year, Constance rents out the back space of The Dutchman, a restaurant on Stone Street, for our holiday party. This year’s is a bit late into the season—December 23rd—but by some miracle, everyone is in attendance.

Priya decorates the space, I pick out the set menu for us a couple of months in advance, and Daniel makes a playlist and runs the karaoke machine all night. There’s a tree by the door with ornaments made from old case captions and yogurt lids and paperclips—an idea I’m sure Priya stole from one of her favorite TV shows. On the table, right by the platter of cookies and persimmon bars, is a pot of mulled wine Constance brought from home, which I make sure to hit as soon as I walk through the door.

I’ve been Deputy Director for twenty-six hours. Everyone’s hugged me. Priya cried. Daniel gave me a mug today that says “World’s Okayest Boss,” and then, quietly, an envelope containing what he described as “my cut for the year.” Constance made a speech about how proud she was of the work we do every day, and how this organization has exceeded her expectations in every possible way. Yesenia texts me a picture of a radiator with a thermometer on top of it reading seventy-one degrees, and I looked at it in the bathroom for a full minute with my hand over my mouth thinking This is why I do this.

And the whole time, across the room, I’ve been watching Alex Whitlock be happy for me.

Not in a performative way, either. I’ve watched opposing council congratulate me on my wins through their teeth over the last four years. This is something else—something different.

Every time I search for him in the crowd, I find his eyes on me, as if we’ve suddenly become magnetized. Though now that I think of it, we’ve always been—our charges have just changed, pulling us together this time instead of pushing us apart.

I find him leaning against the bar in a ridiculous metallic green sweater with a Rudolph reindeer on it, a bright red nose lit up right in the middle of his chest, and damn him if he doesn’t look absolutely perfect. He’s laughing at something one of the fellows said, but flits his gaze to mine before going back to his conversation. The grin that spreads across my face every time I catch him doing that is inevitable. I think it’s safe to say I’m pretty far gone for Alex, too.

“She was always going to get it,” I hear him say to Daniel, pride in his voice. “She’s always been the better candidate.” He doesn’t say it with any tightness or a hint of resentment. Never speaks of me with a shadow over his eyes or suggestion that he’s being gracious about it. No. Alex is legitimately proud of me.

And it makes me insane.

Because I’ve been waiting for the catch, for the other shoe to drop, for twenty-six hours, but nothing’s come up so far.

At ten-fifteen, I watch him put his drink down and go through the door marked EMERGENCY EXIT ONLY. With a deep breath, I count to thirty, place my drink on the table closest to me, and follow him out.

It’s snowing. Of course it is.

It’s as if the Fates have decided it’s time for a do-over of last year and the exact same conditions need to be repeated for maximum success.

The fire escape is nothing more than a metal grate two stories over an alley that smells like the restaurant’s kitchen fryer, with a railing that’s been painted so many times over it’s soft. Alex stands at the far end of it with his hands on the cold metal bar and no coat, looking at the snow coming down between buildings. When he hears the door clang shut behind me, he doesn’t turn around.

“It’s the same night,” he says, his voice almost a whisper.

“I know.”

“One year. To the date. I checked.” Now he turns, finally facing me, but with a look in his eyes that causes my chest to yawn open and ache for him in a way I haven’t fully let myself since this whole thing between us started.

“You want to talk about the board?”

“I want to know why you’re not angry with me.” My heart takes off on a sprint, while I wait for an answer, scared as I may be to hear it.

He looks at me like I’ve asked him why the sky isn’t green. “Why would I be angry?”

“Because you wanted it, too. The job. Don’t—” I hold up a hand when I see him move. “Don’t shrug at me. Don’t do the thing you always do. Don’t act like you don’t care. You’ve been in this race with me for four years—seven if we count law school—and you’ve put in the same amount of hours I have. You’ve worked yourself to death these past couple of weeks, waking up at four A.M. and going to bed at ungodly hours of the night. You stood up first in that court room for the first time in your life, and you lost, and you shook my hand like—like it was good news, and I have been waiting for you to be a human being about it, and you won’t, and I need to know what the catch is, Alex, because I can’t⁠—”

“There’s no catch, Marisol.”

I exhale, pinching the bridge of my nose and squeezing my eyes shut as I try to calm down. “There’s always a catch.”

“Not with you.” He says it simply, the way he would talk about how it’s snowing right now—just a fact. “There’s never been a catch with you. That’s the whole fucking point, Marisol.” He throws his hands in the air, his cool finally starting to slip. I feel the energy of his frustration practically vibrating off him as it begins to build.

I stand there with the snow coming down on my hair and shoulders, looking up at this man who has driven me to the brink of insanity in more ways than one.

“You were the better candidate,” he says. “That’s not modesty. I’m not good at that, and you know it. I’m good at looking modest, which is different. But I’m telling you as a matter of record: you were the better candidate. You’ve been the better candidate since October of that first year of law school, and every single fucking time I’ve sat across a table from you for the past seven years I’ve known it. And yes, I’ve argued anyway, because—” He stops. He puts his hands back on the rail with a deep inhale. “Because arguing with you is the best thing I’ve ever done. Do you understand that? I’m smart. I know I’m smart and capable of great things. I’ve been smart my whole life and it’s never cost me anything, and then I met you and it cost me everything, every day, just to keep up. Every brief. Every closing. Every time you took me apart in a meeting I went back to my office and got better. Because you made me, because there was finally somebody worth being better for.