AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Yule Be Hearing From My Lawyer

Page 3

by Caroline Frank

My alarm is set for 4:45 A.M., because I tell myself that if I’m going to spend the next two weeks in a room with Alex Whitlock, I’m going to be the first in that room.

Always.

TWO

ALEX

She glances at me for exactly as long as it takes to be annoyed and then looks away, and I spend the rest of the meeting trying to get her to do it again.

And that’s the whole thing. That’s my deep, dark secret. Three years of law school and four years of legendary office arguments, and Marisol Santana will not look at me unless I give her a reason. So I give her reasons. I tip the chair back because it makes her jaws set in an expression of resolve that runs an electric current through my entire fucking system. I say “or” because it means she has to look at me when she bites back in frustration, her eyes blazing with a determination I find incredibly sexy.

I know what I’m doing. I’ve known what I’ve been doing with Marisol since the beginning. I know it’s wrong and there are probably a million better ways to get her to see me, but I can’t stop. I don’t know how to stop. I’m scared to stop.

“Happy Holidays,” I say, when Constance is done blowing up our December, and Marisol shuts her binder with a snap that may as well sound like a gavel. A verdict has been reached: she’s not happy about this. And I get it. I mean, I’m not happy that I have to compete with her for a job that I really, really want, either.

Marisol is flawless. She very rarely ever loses, and when she does, she recovers almost immediately, seeing the loss as an opportunity for growth rather than a setback. Most of the time, anyway. There was that one night where⁠—

But I stop myself from going down that road before I get too far along.

I can’t help my smile when I watch her in her seat, clutching the damn binder to her chest. It looks like it weighs about twenty pounds. And of course it has tabs, each one a different color. I’d bet my entire life savings—which honestly isn’t that much—that there’s even a legend in there somewhere explaining what each color means. I imagine the amount of time and attention she put into it, and it does something to that spot in the middle of my chest that constantly aches for her.

She’s wearing that charcoal blazer today, the one with the notched lapels—the one that drives me crazy, even though there’s nothing particularly sexy about it. Just that it’s so damn her it hurts. Her hair is in that low twist that never moves, and in her hands is a pen with her initials on it that I know for a fact was a gift from her mother because she told Priya who told Daniel who told me because he tells me everything and then complains I don’t listen. And while it may be somewhat true—I really don’t care about the mini herb garden that he’s got going on in his apartment or the latest guy he’s been dating—when it comes to Marisol Santana, I’m always listening.

The meeting ends and she’s out the door before I can even say another word. I sit there for a moment, staring at my blank legal pad, and I think co-lead. Eleven families and a boiler and a judge in Queens, and the two of us working together for once.

Constance, you terrible, beautiful woman.

It happened my first year at Penn Law on a crisp October morning. Our Legal Writing class professor assigned us a brief on a personal jurisdiction problem that everyone in the section treated like homework, and I treated like it was going to be read by the Supreme Court. Because that’s the thing no one knows about me: despite my academic achievements, I’m not actually naturally good at things. I’m good at looking like I’m naturally good at things, which is a different skill altogether. I’ve worked hard for every single one of my achievements, and that’s exactly how I tackled the assignment. The brief took me four nights of work, and I was extremely proud of it. I almost sauntered into the classroom that day feeling like I’d won. Like an idiot.

Our professor decided he wanted to workshop the assignment, and confident asshole that I was, I volunteered mine, thinking there was no way there could possibly be anything wrong with it. He pulled it up on the screen in front of the entire class with an expectant smile and opened the floor up for discussion.

And then this girl in the second row—brown hair pulled into a bun so tight it looked like something designed by an engineer, a blue blazer that accentuated her waist and curves in a way that almost made my mouth water—raised her hand and took my entire assignment apart. Not cruelly but with a surgical precision so sharp it barely hurt. In front of the entire class, she pointed out the sentence where my argument turned on itself. She explained where the citation error was on page four, a pin cite to the wrong page of an opinion, and she said it the way you’d point out that someone’s shoe is untied. I laughed in front of the class and shrugged it off, because that’s my whole act. It doesn’t matter; it comes easy.

But it mattered. It didn’t come easy. It never does. My successes are a byproduct of hard work and persistence. So I went back to my carrel that night, and sat there with the brief, feeling about an inch tall. Maybe less.

At around eleven that same night, someone slid a piece of paper under the carrel door.

It was the citation. Just the citation. The right pin cite, the right page, written out in blue ink in handwriting so neat it looked typeset. No name. No note. But she didn’t have to write anything to let me know it was her. No one else in the program would’ve bothered, and no one else would have gotten it exactly, perfectly right.

I still have that piece of paper in my wallet. I’ve had it for seven years. It’s gone soft at the folds from rereading it multiple times since then. It’s moved through two more wallets and one flooded apartment, and I’ve never, not once, told her about it.

The first late night is on Tuesday.

Priya leaves at six with a “good luck, you two” and a smirk that has me rolling my eyes. Daniel leaves at six-thirty and stops by the conference room to ask if we need anything and, when Marisol says no without looking up, mouths twenty bucks on her to me and leaves. The fellows are gone, and Constance’s office lights go off at seven-fifteen. Then it’s the two of us and the snow and the hum of the building and the wreath on the supply closet, and I would like to say I get all my work done but it’s hard having her this close to me. Her vanilla-bergamot scent fills my brain, melting it faster than the salt on the sidewalk melts ice.

I’ve got the affidavit up on my laptop screen and the HPD portal on my iPad, and every four minutes I look up at her. But she doesn’t notice.

Marisol has the binder open. She’s got the pen with the initials in her right hand, furiously making notes in the margins of the documents while holding a highlighter between her teeth. Her hair hasn’t moved all day, though her blazer is off and hanging over the back of the chair making me fear for my life. And because she’s wearing a crisp white shirt with the sleeves cuffed exactly twice, which makes me look at her wrists for longer than I should, and for some reason, that slays me.

And then I notice it: a tattoo on her left wrist—a faded outline of a heart, something she might have gotten ages ago—which I’ve never, in seven years, noticed once. And I notice everything.

“Tattoo,” I mumble like an idiot, because I can’t help myself or my shock. My absolute delight at learning something new about her. It’s my favorite thing in the world to educate myself on all things Marisol.

She looks up at me, eyes red—the first sign of exhaustion I’ve seen on her face in a while. “I’m sorry?”

Fuck.

I clear my throat and realize I’ve messed this up and need to try that again. “You have a tattoo.”