AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Outside the Night

Page 48

by Blake Pierce

"Three victims, three completely different painters," Isla said. "Kelsey built up a surface out of a hundred small, hedged corrections. Calloway drew like a sign painter, because he was one, and everything he made had a hard edge in it somewhere. Swann laid down short dry strokes and came back at them, and a Carol Swann painting is a stack of careful decisions like a stack of coins. Three hands. Nothing in common."

She tapped the three finished passages.

"And the finished parts are all the same hand, and it isn't any of theirs, and it isn't his either." She turned around. "It's hers. Same color relationships. Same green under the ice instead of glazed over it. Same long single loaded stroke with no correction anywhere in it. Same quality of light. Faye Oyelaran has now looked at all three of those photographs on a laptop in her office with me on the phone, and she was quiet for a long few seconds and then she said, that's Margaret's water."

"That's one opinion from one gallerist," Channing said from the back.

"Yes, ma'am. I've got Gwen Lindahl looking tonight and I want a conservator from the Minneapolis Institute of Art in this building tomorrow, and I want it on paper from somebody who can survive cross-examination."

"Keep going."

Isla wrote three words on the board.

NOT FINISHING. CORRECTING.

"We've had this wrong since Monday. We've been saying he finishes their paintings, and he does, but that's the mechanism and not the point. He isn't completing Dana Kelsey's picture. He's replacing the last twenty percent of Dana Kelsey's picture with his own, done in the manner of the best painter this lake has ever had, on her canvas, on top of nine months of her work, and then he's putting her signature back on it in her own mark because a signature goes down last and he is scrupulous."

She looked around the room.

"Every one of those three is an argument. It's the same argument three times and it goes: here is what you did, and here is what it should have been, and I could do it and you couldn't. And the reason he's getting better and the reason the interval is closing from thirty hours to sixteen is that he's a man who has found a way to make the argument at last, after twenty-nine years, and every time he makes it, it works."

"Twenty-nine years," Channing said.

"Full scholarship at eighteen. Expelled at twenty for something the college will describe to us in one line. And then a man in rented rooms who filled two hundred and some sketchbooks in twenty-nine years without missing a week and wrote twenty-two pages fourteen months ago asking for a hallway and got two lines back."

Isla put the marker down.

"Here's the part I've been standing on for twenty minutes and I want it said in front of everybody.

"He hasn't picked these three because he hated them. He picked them because they got what he wanted. Kelsey had the story and the following and the show in April. Calloway had a Minneapolis gallerist driving up on a Tuesday night to look at his best painting. Swann had fourteen paintings in the hallway of the building where he was once an eleven-dollar-an-hour assistant, and a review in the paper on Sunday that said she knew when to stop." She let that go by. "But they're not the point either. They're practice, and they're demonstrations, and he's using them like Douglas Pell uses a sixteen-by-twenty board in front of eleven people."

"For what?" James said in a low voice from the side of the room, and he already knew, and he asked it so that everybody else would hear the answer out loud.

"For her."

Isla put the photograph of Margaret Rogers in the middle of the board, and the room got very quiet.

"Eleven sketchbooks in a row on that shelf with her initials on the fore-edge. Hundreds of pages of studies after her early paintings, annotated. And I've read one page of it in plain view for eleven minutes and it is not a fan, and it is not a student. It's a man who thinks he's the only person alive who has actually seen her work, and it's a man who's furious with her for stopping in 1977, and both of those at once."

"Restoration," Channing said.

"That's the word out of his proposal. A section about work being restored. Pell read it three times fourteen months ago and couldn't make it mean anything sensible and neither could I until four fifty-three this afternoon." Isla put both hands on the back of a chair. "He believes she abandoned the only real work anybody on this lake ever made. And he believes he's the one who can put it back. She is not going to be another demonstration, ma'am. She's the whole argument. She's the canvas the last three were rehearsals for, and if he gets to her, he doesn't stop after her, because there isn't anything after her."

She made herself say the rest.

"Four ways I could be wrong. One: the finished passages could be an approximation of a whole generation's manner and not one woman's, and I'm the wrong person to judge that, which is why there'll be a conservator here tomorrow. Two: the Rogers studies could be twenty-nine years of ordinary devotion, and half the painters in this state have copied her. Three: this is a profile built in six hours on a man we have never spoken to and cannot presently find, and I built a profile in six hours once before." Isla did not look away from Channing when she said it. "Four: I want this to be true, because if it's true I know where he's going, and I have never in my life been given a case where I know where he's going, and wanting it is exactly the failure mode I have."

The radiator ticked. Down the hall a printer started.

"Noted, all four," Channing said. "Now tell me where she is."

"That's the problem." Isla straightened up. "Margaret Rogers is eighty-seven years old. She hasn't given an interview since 2009. Faye says she's owned the same place at the mouth of the Lester since 1968 and that there's a boathouse behind it she uses as a studio, and Faye also says she spends winters with a niece in St. Paul and she doesn't know if she's gone yet this year, because nobody in this town has Margaret Rogers's phone number except about four people and Faye is not one of them."

"And?"

"And Faye said something else." Isla picked up her notebook and read it off exactly as she'd written it, because she'd made herself write it down before she let herself react to it. "She's been working again. Since the spring. Something big, the first one in years, and she's been telling people she doesn't know if she can get it finished."

Nobody in that room needed it explained.