AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Two Wrongs

Page 77

by Sam Mariano

The condom adds a different layer to things. I know I’m the one who insisted on it—for practicality’s sake—but it didn’t occur to me until this moment as I rub the lubed-up condom along my slit…

The last time someone fucked me with a condom on was the night I was raped. Sure, technically Tor put one on the night Tim was murdered, but that “wasn’t really sex” and we were in a rush just legitimizing our alibi, so it didn’t register.

This does.

I swallow, debating changing my mind and telling him to take it off, but it’s too reckless. Maybe I’ll look into birth control tomorrow so we don’t have to use these for much longer, but for tonight… we need to be safe.

“You okay?”

My gaze jumps to his handsome face. I force a little smile and nod, fitting the head of his cock just inside me.

Pushing away those ugly stray thoughts of anything but us and this moment, I sink down onto Tor’s cock. He fills me inch by inch, stretching me as I take him deeper. When I get him all the way inside me, I stop for a second, soaking up the feeling of just sitting completely on his cock.

Then I start to move.

As I do, I start to moan, and the noisier I am, the firmer Tor’s grip gets on my hips. I’m so glad we have this house to ourselves because I don’t want to be quiet. I arch back a bit, grabbing his thighs behind me for balance. One of Tor’s hands finally leaves my hip so he can touch my tits, jutting out in this position, barely contained by the flimsy lace of this nightie.

“You’re so fucking beautiful,” he rumbles as he squeezes.

He makes me feel fucking beautiful.

I keep riding him, letting go of one thigh so I can rake a hand through my hair. I feel restless and wanton, bouncing on his cock while he plays with my tits.

He sits up a bit, bracing a hand on my back, guiding me into the position he wants me in so I’m cradled, still with his cock inside me. He pulls me closer, tearing down the material over my tits so he can suck on them.

“Oh god,” I sigh, sinking my fingers into his hair.

His grip on me tightens, then he shifts, laying me down near the foot of the bed. He hovers over me, lifting one of my legs and draping it over his shoulder. He repositions his cock, then drives into me. I gasp, my eyes opening wide and my thighs trembling. This angle feels completely different, and I grab beneath me for purchase, my fingers tangling in the sheets as he pounds into me over and over.

“Oh my god,” I whine breathlessly. “Tor.”

The breath is sucked from my lungs for a different reason when he covers my mouth. My heart sinks, my eyes flying open. Suddenly, the ceiling of this room fuses with the identical one down the hall, and for a split second, I’m thrown back to last year, when another cock was inside me, another hand clamped down over my mouth.

Tor holds my gaze, but when he says, “Shh,” my heart stops.

Of course he can’t know that’s what his brother did to me, but I know.

Panic starts to build in my chest. Tor shoves into me harder, and breathing becomes increasingly more difficult.

I tell myself to relax. This is Tor, not Tim. It’s okay. I’m okay. I’m not being attacked. Tor cares about me, and I care about him, and this is nothing like that. It’s not his fault he… did the same thing.

“Shh,” he says again, but I’m not making any noise. Maybe he sees the panic in my eyes. He moves his hand, pushing his thumb into my mouth. “Suck.”

Heart hammering in my chest, I do as he says. My body still feels off, but as I hold his gaze, sucking on his thumb the way I would his cock, I feel myself returning to this moment.

Once he’s satisfied, he pulls his thumb out of my mouth and asks, “You want to be on top again?”

“Yes, please.”

Tor cradles my face tenderly, looking down at me, and when he brushes a thumb near the corner of my eye, I realize he’s catching a tear.

I didn’t realize I was crying.

He doesn’t mention it, but he pulls his cock out of me and lies back down.

A bit shakily, I climb on top of him.

This time, he lets me set the pace.