AllFreeNovel
Share Us
I have no idea how we are going to work this next part logistically. There are five of us and only one of her. We all seem to be letting Tyler take the lead, given his experience, so I have to hope he knows what he’s doing.
I’m down for whatever. I’ll fuck her foot again if that’s what she wants. I fucking loved the feel of her toes and the soft sole of her foot rubbing against my cock. The added bonus was watching my cum ooze between her toes. I have no idea why I like feet so fucking much, but I can’t seem to make myself care that it might be wrong. Cherry loves what we share, and that’s all that matters.
My eyes are drawn to this Tyler dude. Like a lot. Not in a creepy way, but I get the feeling I know him. I’ve been listening to his voice, and at times it seems familiar, but other times it doesn’t. I’ve studied him from all angles tonight. I can’t see much of his hair, but the little I can see at his nape shows me it’s light and short, which narrows it down to like, a million possibilities. He has a blondish beard, and its short length either means he likes to keep it short or he has only recently been growing it. Again, a factor that doesn’t really help me figure out who the fuck this guy is. He’s a big guy. Tall, athletic and ripped, and maybe if I went to the gym or something, I might know him because it’s obvious he works out, like a lot.
Garrett’s gasp for air gains my attention as he finally releases Cherry’s hips, and she lifts off his face.
“You ok there, Monster?” Shaun chuckles, and Garrett nods, a huge grin spreading his lips wide.
Fucking hell. I’ve never seen him smile like that. He looks so playful right now. I love that Rhys brings this side out in him. She does that with each of us. She makes us happy and accepts us for who we are.
“Stay on your back, Monster Cock. Just shift to the edge of the bed.” Tyler instructs, and fuck, his voice sounds familiar. It’s not the first time I’ve thought it tonight, but I can’t for the life of me figure out who it belongs to, or even if it belongs to someone I know.
Garrett does as he’s told after Cherry climbs off him, and Cherry swigs down some water that Shaun offers her while Marcus holds her up. Her legs are trembling, but she’s not showing any signs of exhaustion yet. She’s utterly insatiable.
Marcus helps her move since she can’t move properly with the plug protruding from her arse. I can’t even fucking explain how hot that is. I want to tell Cherry what I’ve been doing at home at night. I want to let her know that I know exactly what that full feeling is like, but I don’t. I keep my mouth shut like the coward I am. Just like earlier today at the cabin when I turned into a moody bitch instead of just telling them how I feel.
I know Cherry accepts us and our desires, but there’s just something about admitting to wanting to be taken that way that has me confused and staying silent. I’m not gay, but if I were being totally honest with myself, I’d have to admit I’m not straight either. I think I might be bi. But then I don’t really know if that’s true either. I have these feelings when I’m with Cherry and the guys. Feelings that I’ve never had around other guys before, just these ones, and it only happened once the idea of sharing Cherry was put in my mind. I just want to know what it’s like to be… filled. Consumed as our girl keeps asking for. And when I took Bossi’s dick in my mouth earlier today, the feeling grew stronger.
Don’t get me wrong. I love fucking. I love using my dick and sinking into heat and claiming, but I also crave to be the recipient. Maybe that makes me sick. I don’t think Cherry would be put off by it, yet I still can’t voice what I want. I think it would actually turn her on. But my mates… if they knew my thoughts, would they think I’m disgusting?
“You sure about this Kitten?” Tyler asks again, and she nods eagerly, grinning as she walks awkwardly with the plug sticking out as her fingers find her clit.
“I’m so fucking horny, Skipper. I’m desperate to be completely filled.”
Fuuuck. My cock jerks again with the same need as Cherry.
Ty chuckles. “Ok. You asked for it.” He takes her hands and leads her to Garrett. “Since he really does have a monster cock, there’s no way I’m letting him take your virginity, so you’re going to climb on top and sink your sweet pussy down on him and sit there while he stretches you for a bit.”
Cherry moans. “Yes, Daddy.”
Tyler helps her manoeuvre over Garrett, and with the plug still in, Garrett grips his dick as Cherry slowly impales herself. Gritting his teeth, Garrett’s other hand moves to Cherry’s hip, his fingers digging into her creamy flesh, helping her until he’s fully seated. Her back arches, her head falling back as her dark silken hair flows down past the two perfect globes of her arse.
That’s it, I can’t take anymore. I give in and wrap my hand around Conan, giving him a good long squeeze.
“Ok, who’s going to take her virginity?” Ty asks, and the rest of us look at each other. “One of you three.” Ty points, and Shaun shrugs.
“I think it should be Caveman.”
“Me? Why?” Marcus looks confused, but excited at the same time, his hand pumping his dick a little faster.
“Well, man. Me and Barberian owe you this.” Shaun explains. “For being betraying cunts.” He points to our girl. “That sacred moment belongs to you and Kitten.”
I nod, knowing he’s right. Thisdoesbelong to Marcus. He loves her fiercely, and we hurt him in the most unbearable way. Sometimes I wonder why he forgave us, but mostly I’m just thankful he did. He’s one of my best mates. He didn’t deserve what me and Bossi did to him.
“It’s yours, man,” I say, gesturing my head to our girl, and Marcus slowly nods, his eyes lighting up with warmth and excitement.
“It’s yours Caveman. Come and take it.” Cherry purrs, and Marcus moves quickly, leaning down to kiss her. The action causes her to gyrate her hips, and Garrett groans as his monster dick takes the pleasure.
When Marcus breaks the kiss, Tyler slowly eases the plug free before pressing his big hand against Cherry’s shoulder, pushing her forward to lean her over Garrett’s chest. Her lips find Garrett’s, and I shift around to see Ty spreading her cheeks wider, the channel of her arse open and ready.
“Lube.” Tyler demands, and Shaun jumps into action, pouring lube over Marcus’ straining dick before pouring more over the crack of Cherry’s arse, pushing some inside her. She moans at the feel of his fingers moving inside her now open rose, and then he grins, pulling back to clap Marcus on the shoulder.
“Have fun.”
Marcus chuckles, and Tyler cracks a rare grin. I study him for a moment, something about Ty’s eyes seeming familiar. I can’t put my finger on it, though, and when he speaks, I decide to worry about that later.
“Ok, first, you’re going to slide in slowly. An inch at a time. Then when you’re in, you can fuck her slowly, so her body adjusts. After that, I’ll get you to make room so we can get Goldie Locks in on some action too.”
