AllFreeNovel
Share Us
“Why yes, of course,” she murmurs. “Why wouldn’t I be? I met my sister for coffee and then got really, really tired, so I came home for a nap. But oh shit,” she blinks, staring out the window at the night sky. “I was supposed to show up at your house, wasn’t I? And I missed it.”
“No, it’s fine,” I soothe. “It’s not a big deal. You missing it, I mean. It’s just that, sweetheart, Pam came in your place,” I state in a slow voice while looking deep into her innocent blue gaze. “Did you know that?”
Paisley shakes her head, looking stupefied.
“She what?”
I nod.
“Your identical twin sister showed up on my doorstep, pretending to be you. She drugged you with sleeping pills, honey, so she knew you’d be out like a light. Then, she tried to tempt me—”
“What?” Paisley cries, sitting up with a bolt then. “Pamela did what?”
I hold her tight, looking straight into her eyes.
“Pamela tried to seduce me, and this is going to be difficult to hear, but I have to be upfront about what happened. Pamela lifted her skirt, and because it thought she was you, I put my dick into her pussy. But the moment I did so, I knew it wasn’t you, honey. You’ve never been with another man before, so your cunt’s molded to my shape. Meanwhile, that other woman’s pussy was strange and sloppy and I can’t even describe it. I knew it wasn’t you, even though she looked and sounded just like you.”
“You slid your cock into my sister’s pussy?” Paisley whispers with a horrified look on her face. “Oh god, no!”
My expression is tense and regretful.
“I did, because it all happened so fast, and I genuinely thought Pam was you. But I pulled out immediately after that first stroke, and forced Pamela to tell me what she’d done. Then I rushed here immediately. I’m so sorry, Paisley,” I rasp. “Forgive me. I hope you understand, but it was a genuine mistake. I should have been more careful, I know, but I really thought she was you. I’m sorry, baby girl.”
Paisley’s eyes are wide and bright, her mouth open in circle of horror and shock. But then it snaps shut as tears begin to roll down her face.
“Oh my god,” she sobs, burying her face in her hands. “Oh god, oh god.”
“I know,” I say in a broken voice, running a big hand up her back. “I’m so sorry, baby.”
But then Paisley puts her hands down, and her expression is one of a vengeful angel.
“I’m going to kill that bitch,” she rasps. “What a conniving slut! Pamela wanted to steal you away from me, and actually had the temerity to drug me and then come on to you! She knew I was going over tonight, and probably found your address on-line!”
“It is available through the city’s database,” I confirm in a low tone. “Everyone’s address is.”
“Still, I’m going to kill that bitch,” Pais says with a murderous look on her face. “Sister or no sister, Pamela’s going to die.”
I sit back on my haunches for a moment.
“I know how you’re feeling,” I begin in a low tone. “But let’s just try to focus on the good for a moment. You’re alive, you’re in one piece, and I’m so glad I got to you, Pais. I love you, honey, and I was sick with worry that something terrible had happened given the fact that you were involuntarily drugged by your sister.”
“I’m going to kill that bitch,” Paisley continues to fume, like she hasn’t heard my words. But then the pretty blonde looks up, blinking. “Wait, what did you say?”
I take her small hands in my own.
“I said that I love you, and I’m glad that you’re okay,” is my hoarse reply. “I would die if the woman I loved came to any trouble, and just in case there’s any doubt, that woman is you, Pais. I love and adore you, and I’ve never had such a scare in my life before.”
Suddenly, Paisley is crying again while burying her face in my shoulder.
“What is it, sweetheart?” I ask, tipping her tear-stained chin towards mine. “What’s got you so sad?”
“It’s just that I love you too,” she manages in a blubbery voice even as the waterworks continue. “I adore you so much, Brad, and thank you for coming to save me when you thought I was in danger.”
I lean forwards for a tender kiss on those pink lips.
“It’s the least I could do,” I growl. “I worship you, honey. But I wanted to be honest and truthful too because now, my dick’s been inside your twin sister. I wish it hadn’t happened, but it did, and I regret it. Still, can you forgive me for that? I would do anything to change it.”
My heart hangs in the balance but Paisley merely nods and slings her arms around my shoulders again.
