AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 23

by Ali Lockhart

McKellen’s Tavern was on the corner of Stutton St and Grand Ave, a building so snug and crowded that it had always made Theo think of a rabbit burrow. The proprietor, Abraham Nethering, had purchased the property from Ned McKellen before the war, and had made half-hearted attempts to bring his idea of culture to the village by offering a variety of fare. The village responded predictably—we’d like some ales and steak-and-kidney pies, please—although his chicken curry had become a surprise staple.

The curry was what Theo poked at now. David cut into his roast, dipping it into the thin vat of gravy and taking a neat bite. He remained irritatingly quiet as he ate, waiting for Theo to break the silence.

“Lou’s stitching has improved,” Theo ventured, taking a bite of chicken. He washed it down with Abe’s brown ale, wincing. The man was a terrible brewer, but if you didn’t mind bitter beer that got you drunk too quickly, there was no better place in the village.

“It could hardly be worse,” David replied. Laura had returned two nights earlier, and he had been absent ever since her arrival. Probably showering her with poetic declarations of his eternal devotion, if Theo had to guess. His brother was obsessed with his wife; it would have been pathetic if Laura wasn’t equally starry-eyed. The brothers had chosen to get supper at McKellen’s to discuss sourcing lamb and mutton for the following year, but so far business talk had not reared its head. Theo had the impression that David wanted to discuss something specific that he was reluctant to bring up.

“She doesn’t seem to be enjoying her lessons with Miss Cruthers.”

Well, perhaps not too reluctant. Theo looked up at his brother, who was focused entirely on his plate. He was pushing the potatoes away from the gravy, lest they touch. David was the tidy one, never overbearing in his cleanliness but easily distressed if things were disorderly.

“Lou has never been one to enjoy being taught anything,” Theo said carefully. “You know she hates being at a disadvantage.”

“And how has that served her?” David asked, pointing at Theo with a forkful of meat. “How can she possibly learn anything if she’s so reluctant to admit that she isn’t all-knowing?”

“I don’t know,” Theo admitted. “I’ve never known how to navigate Louise and her …” His face twisted as he searched for the right word.

“Idiosyncrasies?” David suggested.

“That’s a polite way of putting it,” Theo replied, watching David methodically clean the gravy off the edge of his plate. “I think it’s good for her, to be trained in something. We’ve been too soft with her and it’s given her unrealistic expectations of her own abilities.” He shifted in his seat. Louise and her various perceived failings were a subject the brothers avoided—their parents had not particularly wanted a girl and made it clear in their treatment of her. Her brothers had spent their lives trying to make it up to her.

“I think she is also quite put out that it’s Miss Cruthers teaching her,” David added.

Ah. There it was.

“Why is everyone in this family so obsessed with disliking her?” Theo knew he sounded petulant, but he was annoyed, damn it, and the curry wasn’t very good tonight, and this beer tasted like chewing on a dandelion.

David looked up, quirking one brow. He wasn’t as accomplished at it as Jake, but he wasn’t bad. “I didn’t say anyone disliked her. Lou just doesn’t seem overly fond, that’s all.”

“The only person on earth Lou is overly fond of is Emmy, and that’s because she has round cheeks and can’t effectively talk back yet.”

David nodded thoughtfully. “She does have terribly round cheeks.”

“I had it out with Jake the other day over this,” Theo continued, stabbing at a piece of unsatisfying chicken. “He was standing on his soapbox again, preaching like a pastor about the sin of befriending your neighbors.”

David’s face soured. “I really thought he would be over this by now. He usually moves on from his interests so quickly, and this one certainly hasn’t won him any friends.”

“Jesus can be his friend.”

“Jesus wouldn’t want to socialize with Jake. He had standards.” David smiled. “You know I don’t object to anyone. Hell, you could hang around with bank robbers and I wouldn’t much care, as long as they’re kind to you.”

“I know.” Theo fiddled with his fork.

“It’s Lou I’m worried about. She keeps spitting poison about this woman, and I don’t know how to make her stop.”

“Why would you bother?” Theo sank further into his chair, mentally preparing to launch himself into a silent tantrum.

“Because you like Miss Cruthers and Lou needs to accept that.”

The annoyance evaporated out of Theo. “I don’t know how I feel about Miss Cruthers.” A lie so blatant that David paused in his chewing to shoot his younger brother a disappointed look. “I don’t know exactly how I feel about Miss Cruthers,” Theo corrected.

David shook his head. “No one would blame you. Sarah wouldn’t blame you.”

Sarah never blamed anyone for anything. “I don’t require Sarah’s or your approval for my romantic pursuits.” Damn it.

David didn’t respond aside from a smirk.

“Not that I’m pursuing her.” Theo shoved cold curry into his mouth.