Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell
Page 24
His brother sighed. “Of course not, Teddy.” The bastard had the audacity to wink. “Not yet.”
Chapter
Nine
The store was as clean as it could hope to be, unless an actual exorcism was to be performed. After washing and repainting the walls, Maggie had helped polish the furniture, both newly acquired and left over from the studio. Bridgers had loudly objected to this, pointing out that every chair in the building had most likely played host to a corpse, a plausible suggestion that Tom had instructed Maggie to ignore. The dressmaker’s dummies were fully formed, silently awaiting orders to one side of the room, and the entire upstairs apartment had been taken over with bins of fabric, lace, and tulle. Tubs of buttons and ribbon were tucked into every corner, and Maggie was desperate to organize them but simply did not have the time. Bridgers had announced, rather arbitrarily, that the shop was to open on July 3rd in hopes that the crowd for the village’s Independence Day festival would be keen to investigate a new modiste. Maggie was privately unsure how common it was to open a new shop on a Wednesday, but Bridgers seemed happy, so Wednesday it was. The date gave them a scant two weeks to prepare everything, and while she was scrambling with anxiety to get it all done, the fact of the matter was that … Well, they were as ready as they could be.
She had stitched together most of three sample dresses that were going to be on display on three of the better dummies (not her best work, but better than she thought they would turn out). Tom had surprised them all—especially himself—by taking a shine to the detail work of stitching around button seams and gromets. His hemming was better than Maggie’s, which sparked both pride and outrage in her. Bridgers was hopeless with a needle but excelled at book-keeping and keeping his laborers fed and watered. Primarily, he was to be the face of the company, the loud, theatrical shop owner that charmed men, women, children, and various small animals.
Theo, apparently campaigning for kindest man alive, had come around frequently. He had helped with the repainting, the glass-cleaning (his thin strips of glue be damned; they were nearly impossible to get off), and the furniture polishing. Bridgers had asked him, multiple times and with increasing bafflement, if he didn’t have work to do at the butcher shop, and Theo always responded with a cheerful, don’t worry on it. Maggie suspected he was splitting his time unfairly and would soon face the wrath of his family, but she found it easy to ignore that storm cloud when he was kneeling on the floor swearing at a stubborn stain, or carefully regluing loose wallpaper, or smiling at her.
He was always smiling at her. Worse, she had started smiling back. It was a reflex, like a sneeze after dusting: his eyes crinkled, and her lips curled in response. His mouth, accursed thing, had become an obsession. She had found herself imagining it during the day, as she stitched together petticoats and scrubbed down walls—his infuriatingly full lips turning up, that dent under his eye appearing. His obscenely blue eyes looking at her warmly with his stupid brown curls falling into them. She was becoming weak; he was making her weak. This was, functionally, the opposite of what she had come here for: a fresh start interrupted, a clean slate marred with a face from her past.
Dread, thick and slow and tinged with a terrible quick heartbeat, filled her. Perhaps it’s time to consider what you want from the future, Tom had observed.
Apparently, she wanted a cheerful widower who sold dead animals and worshipped his daughter.
Maggie stood in the middle of the storefront, hands on hips, feeling the full weight of her own indecisiveness pressing into her.
Even if she wanted Theo—and she wasn’t permitting herself that luxury yet, not fully—he was a liability. The other brothers were, as well, really. Why they hadn’t simply taken out an advertisement informing the town that devil-worshipping occultists had moved in was beyond her, and she wasn’t about to shake the hornet’s nest by asking. She didn’t have many regrets, but she was beginning to bitterly resent Bridgers letting Theo slide into her tent, sit at that rickety table, and open a door she hadn’t known existed. Now she knew him, and she was at a loss.
Her own deceit followed her like an unwelcome shadow, coloring their every interaction; Theo, sweet and trusting, thought he knew who she was. And she, calculating, sad, and eternally tarnished, had misled him. She would never be a simple seamstress, or a good wife, or—she winced at the thought—a doting mother, because she was more than anything else a pure, unadulterated liar. It hung over her entire existence, a dark cloud of her own dishonesty spoiling any serenity she could carve out. If Theo found out about her, about Tom and Bridgers, about her distinct lack of connection to the spiritual world, he would turn on his heel and stride out of her life without so much as a backwards glance, taking that baby with him. If Theo knew, this thin shred of joy she had found would disappear, and the cloud overhead would consume her.
Theo was aware that Maggie was a lying, panicky person, but it was only recently occurring to him that she, in fact, did not know that he knew. It was becoming clear to him in phases, like a telescope slowly coming into focus: She avoided questions about her past or the rest of her family. She refused to talk about the séances or any aspect of spiritualism, deflecting even jokes about it. She never strayed from the story that Tom and Bridgers were her blood brothers. Any attempt at extracting any contrary information was met with a blank look and a change of topic. Theo had no desire to raise her hackles so he left well enough alone but, at some point, he’d have to inform her she wasn’t fooling anybody.
Well, not him, anyway. And certainly not Lou. Or Jake, whose idea to get a reading was what started this entire mess. David was staying out of the whole affair and had not mentioned it since their dinner.
The shop bell rattled, and Theo looked up from the books he was pretending to go over. Laura Barrow stood in the doorway, a questioning smile on her face, her halo of blonde curls falling out of its haphazard bun.
“Laura!” He came around the counter and gave his sister-in-law a tight squeeze, which she returned several times over. “How was your trip? Your mother feeling better?”
Laura patted his back before withdrawing to lean against the counter. “She is, thank you. Dad is going out of his mind with worry, but the doctors said that the wound didn’t sour so she should heal up just fine.” Laura’s mother, a capable pig farmer from Ames, had fallen off a ladder during a dizzy spell and landed directly on a pile of gardening equipment, breaking some bones and obtaining a rather terrible gash on her side. Laura had been gone for weeks to be with her parents, and David, while supportive of his wife’s journey, had spent every day of their separation moping.
“I’m surprised David let you out of his sight,” Theo said, grinning. “He’s been a raincloud since you left.”
Laura colored, her pretty, round face taking on a pink tinge. “Oh, what a load of rot,” she said, her mouth betraying her with a small, pleased smile. “He’s a great, silly man. At any rate, I came here to see what I can do to help, if anything.” She leaned forward and lowered her voice, despite their being alone. “David told me that Jake is becoming a bit of a nuisance. What with the God talk and all.”
Theo groaned. “He is beginning to take on a bit of an Apostle air.”
“And Lou being so cruel about your Miss Cruthers.” Theo looked down at Laura. She blinked innocently. “What?” she asked.
“Lou is just upset because she’s realizing that she isn’t very good at the job she assigned for herself, and she’s taking it out on Maggie.”
Laura’s brows lifted. “Maggie?”
“Miss Cruthers.”
“She’s a Maggie, is she?”
Theo gritted his teeth. Laura was adored by all the Barrows, but she was an unrepentant busybody. “Her name is Magdalene and she goes by Maggie.”
“And she’s teaching Lou how to sew.”
“She’s helping Lou refine her skills.”
“And Lou is angry because she is now realizing that she’s no good at sewing and none of her brothers bothered to tell her. She’s embarrassed that she had to learn from a stranger, who she seems to mistrust anyway. Something about the trip you took to Madison?”
“We never—”