AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Hard No

Page 31

by Lilian Monroe

“Start at the beginning,” I repeated in a whisper, then gulped. “Which beginning is that?”

“The one that puts into context why and how you killed Tony Costa, Caroline. That beginning.”

KNOX

She looked like a cornered animal that would lash out at any minute, even if I offered her safety and sustenance. But I watched her gather the threads of her courage and wrap them around herself like armor. I watched her drop her feet to the floor as she straightened her spine. Breath filled her lungs, and she closed her eyes for a long moment.

I studied the sharp point of her chin. The blunt ends of her hair. The way her nails curled around the edges of the window seat cushion, painted a shimmery black. I could still feel the way her body had pressed against mine, fitting against me like she was made for me.

A ridiculous thought.

Caroline was made for me in the way fire was made for water. We were all wrong for each other. She was steeped in secrets and lies, and I despised them with every fiber of my being. I could never trust her. I knew that, but I still sat here, waiting for her to tell me whatever half-truths she thought I would believe.

When she opened her eyes again, a different woman stared back at me. This wasn’t the snarky baker with the sharp eyeliner. It wasn’t the woman who smiled at everyone else and sneered at me. The woman I’d watched carry groceries for her elderly neighbor every day, then turn around and toss insults at me like she was Santa Claus throwing chocolates from a Christmas parade float.

I’d thought she was kind but brittle. That her secret would eventually destroy her, and I’d have to make sure my town didn’t suffer too much damage when she eventually imploded.

But I’d been wrong about her.

Sitting before me was someone hard and vicious and unbreakable. A beast hidden beneath a thin veneer of humanity. Strength and purpose and ruthlessness.

She was so fucking beautiful it stole my breath.

“I killed Tony Costa because he attacked my sister,” she said, voice calm, eyes burning. “Because it was his life or hers, and that shit stain didn’t deserve to exist after what he did to her.” Her chin lifted, challenge written in her blazing eyes, carved into her clenched jaw and the pointy tip of her chin. “I killed him, and I’m not sorry.”

TEN

CAROLINE

I killed him, and I’m not sorry.

It was the first time I’d spoken those words out loud, and the instant they were out of my mouth, I began to tremble. I tightened my grip on the window seat cushion to hide it, but there was no doubt in my mind that Knox saw. He saw everything.

Marswood Harbor’s keeper of secrets would extract this one too: I might be afraid of the monster inside me, but I would never deny its existence. He’d keep my reaction tucked away with all the other knowledge he hoarded, then turn around and use it when he needed leverage over me. Which, considering how the last twenty-four hours of my life had gone, would be soon.

His blink was slow. He leaned back, stretching his legs out as if the news of my being a murderer was as mundane as a mostly cloudy forecast. “I already knew that part,” he mused. “I was asking about the specifics.”

I snorted, letting my gaze slide to the side. “You probably already know the specifics,” I grumbled.

“Maybe I want to hear your version of events.”

My gaze snapped back to his. Suspicion filled me like dark smoke, infiltrating every corner of my body and mind. I shifted on my seat and licked my lips. Knox watched, his steady gaze never straying from me. Cataloguing my every move, assessing my every expression.

Telling him was foolish. I knew that, but I couldn’t quite fight the urge. After all, what other option did I have? I could run. Right now, when Enzo had retreated, was my best chance. But at some point since I’d bought the bakery and made a life here, I’d gotten soft. I didn’t want to live in motels for a night or two at a time, constantly looking over my shoulder. I didn’t want to be on edge every hour of the day. I didn’t want to jump at shadows.

I wanted my bakery and my polka-dot couch and Thursday night trivia at the local dive. I wanted friends and laughter and people who liked me despite my prickliness.

Foolish, foolish woman. I’d made this trap for myself and stepped right into it. If I was going to save myself—and protect my sister—I had to be honest with him. I wouldn’t tell him everything, obviously. Only the relevant facts. I wasn’t completely stupid.

I swallowed, my throat raw and tight. Then I forced the words out: “Tony was dating my sister. I never liked him, but she seemed like she was in love and I didn’t want some guy to put a wedge between us. They dated for two years.”

Until the night everything changed.

I closed my eyes against the memory, but it was right there in vivid detail, painted on the backs of my eyelids. Without opening them, I forced myself to tell the man I hated about the worst night of my life. “Lanie called me in a panic. I could hear Tony yelling in the background. He was swearing at her, and he sounded deranged. I’d never liked him, but that was the first time…”

I couldn’t put words to the chill that had gone down my spine. The bone-deep terror that had gripped me when I heard the fear in my sister’s voice.

“She’d just found out she was pregnant, and she was so excited. It was early, and it was an accident, and she hadn’t told him yet. My first thought was that he’d found out about the pregnancy and hadn’t taken it well. I don’t remember the drive to her house. It was short; she only lived around the corner. By the time I got there, he’d broken down the bathroom door and dragged her out. They were in the living room. He was standing over her, and she was crying. He looked up when I walked in, and his eyes…” The words froze in my throat. I shook my head. I forced myself to open my eyes so I could look at Knox. “His eyes were black. I’ve never seen anything like it before or since. As soon as I saw them, I knew…”