AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Hard No

Page 32

by Lilian Monroe

I couldn’t put a voice to it. To the horror of the moment, the animal knowledge that those black eyes had awoken inside me.

Instead, I rooted myself in the present and stared into the deep blue eyes of the man who’d been a familiar annoyance for four and a half years. The gigantic protector of the town. The man who smelled divine and made my silky floral bathrobe look like Thom Browne tailoring. The man who would end this nightmare, once and for all.

Knox held my gaze, and I knew he understood why I’d stopped talking. He took that burden off my shoulders and said what I couldn’t: “You knew he was going to kill her.” His voice was level. Nonjudgmental. But folded in every syllable was a deep understanding. Somehow, incomprehensibly, it comforted me more than anything else might have done.

I nodded. “I just…reacted. I rushed at him. He let go of my sister, and I crashed into him. Lanie was in the way, and he tripped over her. He fell backward and hit his head on the corner of the brick fireplace. It had this raised hearth that was about a foot high.” I gulped. “And that was it.”

I stopped talking. The story was the same one I’d told the cops that night, when I’d been shivering despite the blanket wrapped around my shoulders. They’d looked at me with pity, but I didn’t see any of it reflected in Knox’s eyes.

“It was an accident,” he finally said.

The cops had said that too. Seven and a half years ago, I’d agreed—even though it had been a lie.

Today, sitting across my tiny living room from a huge man who was promising to defend me against the monsters of my past, I couldn’t stomach the lie any longer. I straightened my shoulders and shook my head. “It wasn’t an accident. In that moment, when I saw his eyes, I wasn’t just trying to get him off Lanie. I wasn’t trying to de-escalate anything. I wanted…” My throat closed up, but I had to get the words out.

If I told Knox the worst of it, he’d surely push me away. Whatever had happened between us earlier—the heat and the tension and the need—would never happen again. And that was a good thing. It was exactly what I wanted.

So I lifted my chin and said, “I ran at him knowing that if I didn’t kill him, either my sister, me, or both of us would be dead. I wanted him to die. I ran at him with the intention of ending his life.”

The words slid like poison over my tongue, bitter and metallic. But they were true. The awful, shameful truth that I’d tried to push away for the better part of a decade.

Before that night, I’d thought I was a good person. A normal person. A nurse who had devoted herself to helping others. But after looking into Tony’s eyes, experiencing my reaction, and hearing the sickening thud of his head against the brick, I knew the truth. There was a killer inside me. I could dress it up as self-defense. Kill or be killed. But that didn’t change the fact that I’d wanted to take a life, and I’d done it.

I was a monster.

The sun’s rays slanted through the window at my back, illuminating thousands of dust motes floating through the air. Its warmth didn’t cut the ice in my bones. Down in my marrow, in the very core of me, I was as cold as I’d been the night he died.

Knox blew out a breath. His enormous hand smoothed down the silky lapel of my robe, the fingers of his other hand drumming against my couch’s armrest. He stared at the art on the far wall and frowned. “Was he mad about the pregnancy?”

“No. He never found out about that. None of the Costas did.” And thank goodness for that.

Knox nodded. “Why’d you run?”

“Once the police cleared us, I thought Lanie and I were safe. The coroner ruled Tony’s death an accident. But Enzo cornered me one day at the grocery store, and I could tell he didn’t care what the coroner thought. He promised to kill us, even though his father had him on a tight leash. Lanie and I were gone by the end of the day.”

And then there was the fact that Lanie was pregnant. That her son, Leo, would be coveted by the Costa family as soon as they found out about him. Lanie needed to get out, and the only way to keep her safe was to split up. Make myself the easier target. Leave a trail of breadcrumbs they thought they could follow, then circle back and disappear right here in Marswood Harbor.

Up until I saw Enzo outside my bakery window, I thought I’d succeeded.

Knox grunted, nodding. “Anyone other than Enzo I need to worry about?”

I watched him through narrowed eyes as my heart took off again. Did he know? Had he figured out the part of my secret that I’d thought I’d kept hidden? The reason I was here in the first place?

“I’m guessing that look means yes?” Knox said.

“Enzo’s dad is in prison awaiting trial for racketeering. The rest of the family has fallen apart in his absence. Enzo’s the only one who still wants us dead, as far as I know. He used to have two guys with him wherever he went. Brothers. Carmy and Sally. Carmine and Salvatore. I don’t know their last names.”

“Tell me about them.”

“They’re huge. They like to hit things. They do what Enzo says.”

“Anything else?”

“Sally’s deaf in one ear. Carmy set off a firework in their room while Sally was sleeping and burned down their childhood home.” Enzo’s mother had told me that one day, at a family gathering, when she’d had too much to drink and felt like being mean about her son’s best friends. She was as cruel as the rest of them.

“So they’re smart,” Knox deadpanned.

“Smart enough to follow Enzo’s orders. Vicious enough to enjoy it.”