AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 37

by Ariana Kemp

“I love me some Johnny Cash. Good taste.” I nodded, discreetly boxing up his treat. “Last question, which branch did you serve in?”

He cleared his throat, hand clasping his opposite wrist as he spoke.

“Army,” he informed me..

“Nice.” I started filling a to-go cup with my bold coffee blend, the movements like second nature. “I’ve already said this to Cohen, but each of you are going to get this as well, so no point in trying to dodge it. Thank you, Shepherd.” I poured a bit of milk and sugar in his coffee before slipping a lid on.

“That’s not nec—” he started to protest, but I held my hand up, signaling I wasn’t finished.

“I can’t even begin to fathom what you and the other men have given to keep us safe.” I slid the drink and pastry forward toward him. “But I see you and appreciate your sacrifice.”

I smiled genuinely at the man, analyzing the tiniest of facial tells. His jaw clenched. The side of his eye ticking. He was definitely uncomfortable.

“Huckleberry and mascarpone macaron.” I changed the topic yet again, nodding to the box on the counter. “And a dark roast with a healthy splash of milk.”

“That’s insane,” Adler whistled lowly. “Shepherd loves berries and takes his coffee on the side of his milk.”

“How’d you do that?” Shepherd asked quietly, intently studying me.

Once again, I shrugged.

“I’m observant,” I waved him off. “And I’m good at reading people.”

“Better than good,” Shepherd countered.

“Thanks,” I turned to Adler and smiled widely. “Alright, cowboy. You’re next.”

“I’m just a simple country boy,” he grinned, winking as he leaned against the counter. “Not much interesting about me.”

“I doubt that,” I waved him off, crossing my arms and tapping my foot as I gathered my questions. This man was all smoke and mirrors. He had a charming smile and easy swagger, but his honey brown eyes were sharp as a tack. I’d wager he saw everything, just as Cohen did.

“What’s your favorite movie?” I asked slowly, mulling over different pastry ideas.

“Easy. Speed.”

No hesitation. I couldn’t help the bark of laughter that bubbled up.

“Like, Keanu and Sandra, runaway bus, kind of cheesy, Speed?” I moved over to the pastry case and started assembling a box. This was too easy. “You’re kidding.”

“If you mean the cinematic masterpiece that is packed with nonstop action and peak ’90s Sandra Bullock, you would be correct,” he twisted my words back around, winking. “Don’t go yuckin’ on my yum.”

I shook my head at his antics. He was such a strange mix of boyishness and masculinity.

“I’d never dream of it.” I placed a kouign-amann in the box. “What position did you play in baseball?”

“Stop it right now!” Adler exclaimed, looking between Shepherd and Cohen, slapping his hat against his leg. “Shortstop. I played through high school and had a full ride scholarship. The military called to me though, much to my mother’s chagrin.”

“Seemed the type.” I nodded, satisfied with my assessment. “Lastly, if you could order any appetizer, what would it be?”

“Hushpuppies, hands down,” he rubbed his stomach, followed by a low whistle.

“You’ll have to stop by Lettie’s then.” I grinned as I poured a cup of cold brew and topped it with a splash of cream. “Her hush puppies are one of my favorites. Only second to her pastrami burger.”

“I know what I’ll be ordering tonight,” he grinned. “Now, whatcha got for me?”

I slid over the pastry and drink to him, Adler taking a sip of the cold brew as he peeked in the box. He let out a low whistle and smiled widely. It never got old seeing the look of surprise on people’s faces when I guessed their order correctly.

“You weren’t kidding about this one, man,” he looked at Cohen, shaking his head. “That’s downright scary.”