Page 38
We carried easy conversation for another few minutes before I nudged a coffee over to Cohen, smiling shyly.
“Try this and tell me what you think,” I prodded.
Cohen took the coffee and brought it to his lips, trying not to grin. My heart stuttered at the sight. I watched him, bouncing on my toes. I knew I must have looked overeager, and I didn’t care in the slightest.
He inhaled the faint aroma of the coffee first and his eyebrow quirked.
“Nutmeg this time?” he asked before taking a sip, humming. “Win, this is phenomenal.”
I clasped my hands together and beamed, elated. Cohen looked at me with a warm expression, something I couldn’t quite decipher. It wasn’t a look that I could recall anyone ever having for me. It was as if he was . . . fond? Was it fondness? Whatever it was, it gave his masculine features a softness to them that released a swarm of butterflies in my stomach.
I turned my attention back to the coffee.
“You mean it?” I pressed. “Should I add more orange? Or cinnamon?”
“I don’t say things I don’t mean.” He grinned, taking another sip. “And don’t change a thing. It’s delicious.”
“Thank you,” I said sincerely. “I’m so glad you like it. Oh! I almost forgot!” As I spoke, I moved to the oven on the far wall and used my apron to pull out a tray and set it on the counter.
“Do all of you like cheese?” I asked as I grabbed a mid-sized lavender box.
“You can’t savant that detail too?” Adler teased and I snorted, immediately blushing at the sound.
“I’m good, but not that good, Adler,” I chuckled. “Now cheese or no cheese?”
“We all like cheese except for Griffin, who’s not here,” Cohen informed me. “What are you up to? I already feel like our physiques are doomed.”
I waved him off as I brought the pan to the counter facing them.
“While I highly doubt that’s possible, these are healthy,” I popped a small cupcake looking puck out of the silicone mold and placed it in the box. “Egg bites. You guys need protein and I’m sure it was a crazy travel day. I always have a hard time getting protein in when I’m on the road.”
All of the men stared at me with that same look of . . . fondness? It was driving me crazy not being able to pinpoint that emotion. I was usually so good at reading people and these men were throwing me for a loop.
I looked down, blushing.
“Go ahead, try them.” I pushed the lavender box filled with egg bites toward them.
They each grabbed one and took a bite, their faces wearing various levels of surprise.
“These are magnificent.” Adler covered his mouth as he spoke.
“Wow,” Shepherd rumbled.
“Seriously, is your secret ingredient cocaine? First your donuts, and now this?” Cohen asked as he popped the rest of it in his mouth. “I won’t tell anyone, scout’s honor, Win.”
“No, you big goof,” I laughed as I closed up the box. “I hate eggs too, but they’re easy protein. Instead of forcing myself to eat them, I decided to make them yummy.”
“And these are for us?” Shepherd asked, obviously shocked.
My heart twisted a bit at the sound. Was he not used to people doing nice things for him?
“Well, yeah,” I smiled softly. “You guys seem like the type to always be taking care of others. Thought I would return the favor.”
I placed a few napkins and forks in a parchment bag and pushed the box toward them.
“And don’t even try to pay me. Cops, veterans, and firefighters get theirs on the house too, so don’t worry, it’s not special treatment.”
Cohen rolled his eyes and stuffed a couple of twenties in the tip jar, raising an eyebrow when I opened my mouth to protest. I knew it was no use and simply said a small “thank you”.